Is Social Media making us Stupider

Johnnny

Frontiersman
Jun 8, 2007
9,388
124
63
Third rock from the Sun
Old article with some good points

Social Media Is Making You Stupid | Time

Social media, we all know, can make you unproductive. If you’re indiscreet or offensive, it can complicate your relationships. But can it also make you downright dumb?

That’s what a new study published in the Journal of the Royal Society Interface suggests. How can spending more time on Facebook or Twitter end up making us stupider?

It’s not just that all those hours clicking crops in Farmville and the like simply represnts time that could be spent, say, reading a book and actually learning something. The greater problem seems to be the human tendency to copy others.

Can You Copycat Your Way to Intelligence?
To come to this conclusion, the scientists created five artificial social networks made up of volunteers. Some connected their members in a tight net, where everyone was in contact with everyone else. Others kept the participants more separate. They then tasked the participants with answering a tricky set of brainteasers. Were those who were more socially connected more or less likely to figure out the right answers?

In the short term, more connections yielded more right answers, but not because members were learning. Nope, they were just stealing.

“The researchers found that in well connected networks volunteers…got better at giving the right answer the more times they were asked and the more opportunities they had to steal their neighbours’ answers,” Phys.org reports. “This result showed that when the students had lots of connections to peers they could recognise where they had given a wrong answer and swap it for the right one.”

But did copying smarter social connections improve participants’ ability to figure out the answers independently? In short, no. Given a fresh question, the copycats performed no better than when they first joined the social network.

The Good News–and the Bad
The results offer encouragement for both fans and critics of social networks. If you look at things on the group level, there is reason for cheer. “Being able to copy from other people in vast networks means analytical responses rapidly spread, fulfilling their promise of improved decision-making for well-connected people,” says Phys.org.

But for individuals, the implications are less positive. Social networking probably isn’t making you smarter. In fact, it could be making you dumber by supplying answers and insights without requiring any actual thinking, so that your analytic powers begin to waste away like an unused muscle.

Or as the research team puts it: “On the other hand, the bias may very well decrease the frequency of analytical reasoning by making it easy and commonplace for people to reach analytical response without engaging analytical processing.” In the long-term, they warn, “increased connectivity may eventually make us stupid by making us smarter first.”
 

spilledthebeer

Executive Branch Member
Jan 26, 2017
9,296
4
36

Here is an article illustrating the LIE-beral enthusiasm for Fake News that distorts reality and twists logic into something surreal!

There is CLEARLY too much diplomacy in govt. How else to explain WHY Ontari-owe Conservatives such as Jack MacLaren are just now picking up on a piece of shameless LIE-beral policy that has been public knowledge for YEARS! Set out below is the column MacLaren wrote for the Sun along with some comments of my own in brackets):

Ontario green policies actually driving up carbon dioxide
Jack MacLaren, Special to the Toronto Sun. First posted: Thursday, December 01, 2016 05:14 PM EST | Updated: Thursday, December 01, 2016 05:33 PM EST

The Ontario Liberals’ Green Energy Act is meant to reduce carbon dioxide emissions by generating power from wind turbines and solar panels. We already know this has turned into a wasteful boondoggle — just look at your hydro bill. But there’s another problem with the Green Energy Act, which I was shocked to learn about.

(There is a further issue being ignored here-related to hydro bills-LIE-berals have made HUGE and COSTLY promises to civil service union Hogs and these IOU`s have to be paid for somehow or else LIE-berals will suffer at election time-so they HIDE their electricity price gouging and union vote buying inside your hydro bills! Its why they sold off a SMALL portion of Hydro and then closed the books ENTIRELY to the public and to public auditors-NOBODY is allowed to know what LIE-berals have done with the extra thirty seven billion dollars that auditor Bonnie Lysyk says they have gouged us from us so far! And WHO bought that Hydro stock? Friends of LIE-berals-every one!)

A 2015 report from the Ontario Society of Professional Engineers (OSPE) makes the alarming case that Ontario green energy policy is actually driving up carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions.

Wind and solar energy seem like good, clean sources of energy. But wind power is intermittent, and about 40% of the generated power arrives when load demand is low. Solar energy is also intermittent and capacity is very low. All this means that wind and solar power are expensive and unreliable.

Basically, windmills and solar panels only produce power when the wind blows and the sun shines. They need backup in the form of other power sources to provide constant electricity when you need it. Ontario has gone with natural gas backup because that is the cheapest source of energy currently available. Other options were available, including nuclear and hydro plants, but natural gas was chosen.

This is unfortunate because nuclear and hydro do not emit CO2, but natural gas does. So as we dial down nuclear and hydro, we are doubling up on CO2 emissions from natural gas.

(What MacLaren overlooks is that it takes THREE DAYS to cycle up-and three MORE days to cycle DOWN a nuclear reactor-fully on to fully off or vice versa-thee days each way! Nuclear power simply cannot respond INSTANTLY to fluctuations in green energy. And govt NEEDS all the water power it can get-to offset the obscene prices being paid to FRIENDS of LIE-beral Party for their mouldy green energy! That leaves only natural gas fueled plants-kept at full steam-they are essentially STEAM driven generators-all day, every day, ready to swing into action whenever the wind don’t blow or the sun don`t shine. Green energy saves NOTHING-not the environment and certainly NOT tax payer cash!)

According to OSPE, Ontario currently produces electricity at less than 40 grams of CO2 per kWh. But wind and solar with natural gas backup release about 200 grams of CO2 per kWh.

Now, the trouble of building all the windmills and solar panels wouldn’t be so bad if it were actually worthwhile. But it isn’t. We do not have a cheap and effective way of storing the energy generated by wind and solar power. Simply put, storage is too expensive at the moment.

Adding solar and wind power to the Ontario grid just doesn’t make environmental or economic sense. Continuing to add wind and solar can only be justified on ideological grounds.

(MacLaren is right-LIE-berals are ideologically DRIVEN to offer up energy deals to their friends and allies! It is not ordinary tax payers who own those massive wind mills and the eye sore solar farms that have been forced into the lives of country residents! And who does own those monstrosities? Just run your fingers down the `sunshine list` of high govt earners and union Hogs! All that green energy is just LIE-berals doing what they do best-THEY BUY FRIENDS AND VOTES-and then LIE about the logic afterwards!)

(And for those who want to point out that some of those Big Wind monsters are owned by CAW-well sure-back in 2008, LIE-berals under Dalton McGinty saw a chance to BUY more votes and so GUARANTEED that they would not let CAW pension plan go bankrupt-not even if GM pulled out of Canada entirely! And how better to save CAW pensions than by giving them a RICH source of moudly green income! So what if LIE-berals have to LIE about the justification and too bad that Cdn tax payers think they are being gouged on electricity cost! All that matters is that LIE-berals get votes. We certainly cannot rely on GM to save itself by building good cars- IN CANADA- that the public WANTS to buy!!!)

Admittedly, the Wynne government announced a halt to further wind and solar contracts. I’m not sure how long they’ll put their ideology on hold, but this is a short-term solution anyway.

(LIE-berals can be counted on to RE-THINK their ENTIRE POLITICAL STRATEGY AFTER the next election in 2018. It wont matter if they win or lose-after 2018 it’s a new ball game! If LIE-berals win its because they have sold their souls to civil service union Hogs and will be taxing and revenue tooling us to death to pay for those promises-and then seeking creative new ways to renege on the promises after our economy starts to collapse because reality dictates we just don’t have the money to pay those promises! If LIE-berals lose that next election then look for a fantastic wave of labour unrest in all levels of govt as Hogs seek revenge on those who are trying to deny them gravy!)

We need to use more of our cheaper hydroelectric and nuclear power. And we need to stop exporting power abroad at low prices.

(Dimwit MacLaren really NEEDS to pay more attention to the electricity file-WE HAVE NO MORE HYDRO CAPACITY in Ontari-owe! There IS MASSIVE un-used hydro potential in Quebec-but that would require a major expansion of the James Bay Hydro station-which cannot currently be done as natives are blocking that project and govt-especially LIE-beral govt does not want to start world war three with natives. There is also the environmental reality of building the largest hydro dam on the planet-in a location FAR from major hydro users-and its COSTLY and difficult to ship electricity such long distances. When the Great Whale expansion of James Bay hydro was proposed, the LIE-beral Chretien govt was reluctant to get involved in complex political negotiations for the project-the James Bay power station is in Labrador but most of the area to be flooded is in Quebec and Chretien did not wish to deal with extortion minded separatists!)

(AS for exporting electricity abroad-under the insane terms of LIE-beral green energy contracts, LIE-berals are COMMITTED to buying ALL green energy that is produced by LIE-beral `friends` and that means electricity must be dumped some place-such as in United States at prices below what it cost to produce! LIE-berals had a chance to escape from the worst of the green energy deal as their `partners` had failed to meet several qualifications but LIE-berals renewed the deal anyway-with only some minor revisions and modest fiscal penalties!)

We all want to do the right thing for our environment and we all want clean air to breathe and water to drink. I sincerely believe it is important we strive for a cleaner and safer future.

But no one likes being misled or lied to. The Ontario Liberal government’s Green Energy Act is an environmental and economic disaster. As both a farmer and a civil engineer, I know about protecting the environment as well as long-term sustainability. Farming teaches you to understand the risks and benefits of co-operating with Mother Nature. Similarly, engineers are required to build things: We build things to last, and we do so in the public interest.

So I think most Ontarians would agree with me when I say that we need to have affordable, clean, reliable, and sustainable sources of energy which do not increase CO2.

Unfortunately the Green Energy Act just hasn’t got it right.

(And I say its ABOUT TIME you publicly said so!)

— MacLaren is the MPP for Carleton-Mississippi Mills
 

Hoof Hearted

House Member
Jul 23, 2016
4,477
1,173
113
Social media like Twitter lacks depth, nuance, critical thinking, patience, degrees of thought... etc.

So I'd say yeah, it is making everyone stupider. That's why I hang out on this forum and shoo the mainstream outlets. I like everyone's take on the current events of the day on this site....the good, the bad, and the fabulous! ;)
 

Curious Cdn

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 22, 2015
37,070
8
36
Here is an article illustrating the LIE-beral enthusiasm for Fake News that distorts reality and twists logic into something surreal!

There is CLEARLY too much diplomacy in govt. How else to explain WHY Ontari-owe Conservatives such as Jack MacLaren are just now picking up on a piece of shameless LIE-beral policy that has been public knowledge for YEARS! Set out below is the column MacLaren wrote for the Sun along with some comments of my own in brackets):

Ontario green policies actually driving up carbon dioxide
Jack MacLaren, Special to the Toronto Sun. First posted: Thursday, December 01, 2016 05:14 PM EST | Updated: Thursday, December 01, 2016 05:33 PM EST

The Ontario Liberals’ Green Energy Act is meant to reduce carbon dioxide emissions by generating power from wind turbines and solar panels. We already know this has turned into a wasteful boondoggle — just look at your hydro bill. But there’s another problem with the Green Energy Act, which I was shocked to learn about.

(There is a further issue being ignored here-related to hydro bills-LIE-berals have made HUGE and COSTLY promises to civil service union Hogs and these IOU`s have to be paid for somehow or else LIE-berals will suffer at election time-so they HIDE their electricity price gouging and union vote buying inside your hydro bills! Its why they sold off a SMALL portion of Hydro and then closed the books ENTIRELY to the public and to public auditors-NOBODY is allowed to know what LIE-berals have done with the extra thirty seven billion dollars that auditor Bonnie Lysyk says they have gouged us from us so far! And WHO bought that Hydro stock? Friends of LIE-berals-every one!)

A 2015 report from the Ontario Society of Professional Engineers (OSPE) makes the alarming case that Ontario green energy policy is actually driving up carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions.

Wind and solar energy seem like good, clean sources of energy. But wind power is intermittent, and about 40% of the generated power arrives when load demand is low. Solar energy is also intermittent and capacity is very low. All this means that wind and solar power are expensive and unreliable.

Basically, windmills and solar panels only produce power when the wind blows and the sun shines. They need backup in the form of other power sources to provide constant electricity when you need it. Ontario has gone with natural gas backup because that is the cheapest source of energy currently available. Other options were available, including nuclear and hydro plants, but natural gas was chosen.

This is unfortunate because nuclear and hydro do not emit CO2, but natural gas does. So as we dial down nuclear and hydro, we are doubling up on CO2 emissions from natural gas.

(What MacLaren overlooks is that it takes THREE DAYS to cycle up-and three MORE days to cycle DOWN a nuclear reactor-fully on to fully off or vice versa-thee days each way! Nuclear power simply cannot respond INSTANTLY to fluctuations in green energy. And govt NEEDS all the water power it can get-to offset the obscene prices being paid to FRIENDS of LIE-beral Party for their mouldy green energy! That leaves only natural gas fueled plants-kept at full steam-they are essentially STEAM driven generators-all day, every day, ready to swing into action whenever the wind don’t blow or the sun don`t shine. Green energy saves NOTHING-not the environment and certainly NOT tax payer cash!)

According to OSPE, Ontario currently produces electricity at less than 40 grams of CO2 per kWh. But wind and solar with natural gas backup release about 200 grams of CO2 per kWh.

Now, the trouble of building all the windmills and solar panels wouldn’t be so bad if it were actually worthwhile. But it isn’t. We do not have a cheap and effective way of storing the energy generated by wind and solar power. Simply put, storage is too expensive at the moment.

Adding solar and wind power to the Ontario grid just doesn’t make environmental or economic sense. Continuing to add wind and solar can only be justified on ideological grounds.

(MacLaren is right-LIE-berals are ideologically DRIVEN to offer up energy deals to their friends and allies! It is not ordinary tax payers who own those massive wind mills and the eye sore solar farms that have been forced into the lives of country residents! And who does own those monstrosities? Just run your fingers down the `sunshine list` of high govt earners and union Hogs! All that green energy is just LIE-berals doing what they do best-THEY BUY FRIENDS AND VOTES-and then LIE about the logic afterwards!)

(And for those who want to point out that some of those Big Wind monsters are owned by CAW-well sure-back in 2008, LIE-berals under Dalton McGinty saw a chance to BUY more votes and so GUARANTEED that they would not let CAW pension plan go bankrupt-not even if GM pulled out of Canada entirely! And how better to save CAW pensions than by giving them a RICH source of moudly green income! So what if LIE-berals have to LIE about the justification and too bad that Cdn tax payers think they are being gouged on electricity cost! All that matters is that LIE-berals get votes. We certainly cannot rely on GM to save itself by building good cars- IN CANADA- that the public WANTS to buy!!!)

Admittedly, the Wynne government announced a halt to further wind and solar contracts. I’m not sure how long they’ll put their ideology on hold, but this is a short-term solution anyway.

(LIE-berals can be counted on to RE-THINK their ENTIRE POLITICAL STRATEGY AFTER the next election in 2018. It wont matter if they win or lose-after 2018 it’s a new ball game! If LIE-berals win its because they have sold their souls to civil service union Hogs and will be taxing and revenue tooling us to death to pay for those promises-and then seeking creative new ways to renege on the promises after our economy starts to collapse because reality dictates we just don’t have the money to pay those promises! If LIE-berals lose that next election then look for a fantastic wave of labour unrest in all levels of govt as Hogs seek revenge on those who are trying to deny them gravy!)

We need to use more of our cheaper hydroelectric and nuclear power. And we need to stop exporting power abroad at low prices.

(Dimwit MacLaren really NEEDS to pay more attention to the electricity file-WE HAVE NO MORE HYDRO CAPACITY in Ontari-owe! There IS MASSIVE un-used hydro potential in Quebec-but that would require a major expansion of the James Bay Hydro station-which cannot currently be done as natives are blocking that project and govt-especially LIE-beral govt does not want to start world war three with natives. There is also the environmental reality of building the largest hydro dam on the planet-in a location FAR from major hydro users-and its COSTLY and difficult to ship electricity such long distances. When the Great Whale expansion of James Bay hydro was proposed, the LIE-beral Chretien govt was reluctant to get involved in complex political negotiations for the project-the James Bay power station is in Labrador but most of the area to be flooded is in Quebec and Chretien did not wish to deal with extortion minded separatists!)

(AS for exporting electricity abroad-under the insane terms of LIE-beral green energy contracts, LIE-berals are COMMITTED to buying ALL green energy that is produced by LIE-beral `friends` and that means electricity must be dumped some place-such as in United States at prices below what it cost to produce! LIE-berals had a chance to escape from the worst of the green energy deal as their `partners` had failed to meet several qualifications but LIE-berals renewed the deal anyway-with only some minor revisions and modest fiscal penalties!)

We all want to do the right thing for our environment and we all want clean air to breathe and water to drink. I sincerely believe it is important we strive for a cleaner and safer future.

But no one likes being misled or lied to. The Ontario Liberal government’s Green Energy Act is an environmental and economic disaster. As both a farmer and a civil engineer, I know about protecting the environment as well as long-term sustainability. Farming teaches you to understand the risks and benefits of co-operating with Mother Nature. Similarly, engineers are required to build things: We build things to last, and we do so in the public interest.

So I think most Ontarians would agree with me when I say that we need to have affordable, clean, reliable, and sustainable sources of energy which do not increase CO2.

Unfortunately the Green Energy Act just hasn’t got it right.

(And I say its ABOUT TIME you publicly said so!)

— MacLaren is the MPP for Carleton-Mississippi Mills

Hunh?
 

Murphy

Executive Branch Member
Apr 12, 2013
8,181
0
36
Ontario
My take on that, Johnny, is that news and events are reduced to a sound bite or a short Twitter response. People read tweets or FB posts, and respond in kind. Critical thinking and common sense go out the window, as people try to come up with something short and witty in response. Or worse, to jump on a trashing bandwagon.

The world continues to evolve.
 

spilledthebeer

Executive Branch Member
Jan 26, 2017
9,296
4
36
My take on that, Johnny, is that news and events are reduced to a sound bite or a short Twitter response. People read tweets or FB posts, and respond in kind. Critical thinking and common sense go out the window, as people try to come up with something short and witty in response. Or worse, to jump on a trashing bandwagon.

The world continues to evolve.

HAHAHAQHAHA!!!! Some deluded fool wants to suggest that social media is helping Putin win Yankee elections! What a Maroon!

Go watch that old movie called "The Falcon and the Snowman" in which Yankee meddling in the AUSTRALIAN ELECTION is exposed!

The FBI apparently knew for A YEAR prior to the Trump election that Russian agents were sniffing around Washington- and DID NOTHING! President Obama has admitted knowing the Russians were sniffing around at least FIVE MONTHS PRIOR to the Trump election!

THE MOST SENIOR PEOPLE IN YANKEE GOVT IGNORED RUSSIAN MEDDLING! This has nothing to do with social media and everything to do with bigotry and political GREED!
 

Hoid

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 15, 2017
20,408
4
36
Social media is the largest confluence of idiots ever invented.
 

spilledthebeer

Executive Branch Member
Jan 26, 2017
9,296
4
36
HAHAHAQHAHA!!!! Some deluded fool wants to suggest that social media is helping Putin win Yankee elections! What a Maroon!

Go watch that old movie called "The Falcon and the Snowman" in which Yankee meddling in the AUSTRALIAN ELECTION is exposed!

The FBI apparently knew for A YEAR prior to the Trump election that Russian agents were sniffing around Washington- and DID NOTHING! President Obama has admitted knowing the Russians were sniffing around at least FIVE MONTHS PRIOR to the Trump election!

THE MOST SENIOR PEOPLE IN YANKEE GOVT IGNORED RUSSIAN MEDDLING! This has nothing to do with social media and everything to do with bigotry and political GREED!

In addition some dign dongs want to suggest that social media lacks depth or nuance or some such crap! Social media has EXACTLY as much values as its creator desires- the honest poster produces honest results- the LIE-beral poster spews fake news like a super charged manure spreader!
 

Curious Cdn

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 22, 2015
37,070
8
36
In addition some dign dongs want to suggest that social media lacks depth or nuance or some such crap! Social media has EXACTLY as much values as its creator desires- the honest poster produces honest results- the LIE-beral poster spews fake news like a super charged manure spreader!

You are right, of course. Social media manipulation can't get someone elected. It takes tens of millions of compliant hillbilly Zombies with drool dripping off of their chins to do that.
 

Johnnny

Frontiersman
Jun 8, 2007
9,388
124
63
Third rock from the Sun
A bit of a conspiracy theory here from my part so here i go.

What do you guys think about the possibility of subliminal messaging on social media?

For example a government or corporation comes out with a new written report, whether it be a policy change or a quarterly update. They spend a lot of money on the cover page and fancy wording in the body of the report while the real details are in the footnotes. Fancy wording like passing off revenue as profits for example, which are then clarified in footnotes.

We all know that the majority of people don't read the footnotes in what they read, heck even im guilty of that sometimes. Like who wants to flip to the back of the book or a report for clarification...

Its of my opinion that social media is like the cover page of the report i mentioned and that the footnotes are the research you have to do on your own which is a similar process to flipping to the back of a book for the footnotes.

So people constantly get bombarded by these "cover pages" online and in the end everyone has the same opinion about a topic, because how can a person with a 1000+ followers be wrong. Then subsequently people see that a majority believe this persons opinion and then copy that opinion into their own.

And next thing you know everyone is following the leader.

I dunno, maybe i'm wrong.
 
Last edited:

Curious Cdn

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 22, 2015
37,070
8
36
A bit of a conspiracy theory here from my part so here i go.

What do you guys think about the possibility of subliminal messaging on social media?

For example a government or corporation comes out with a new written report, whether it be a policy change or a quarterly update. They spend a lot of money on the cover page and fancy wording in the body of the report while the real details are in the footnotes. Fancy wording like passing off revenue as profits for example, which are then clarified in footnotes.

We all know that the majority of people don't read the footnotes in what they read, heck even im guilty of that sometimes. Like who wants to flip to the back of the book or a report for clarification...

Its of my opinion that social media is like the cover page of the report i mentioned and that the footnotes are the research you have to do on your own which is a similar process to flipping to the back of a book for the footnotes.

So people constantly get bombarded by these "cover pages" online and in the end everyone has the same opinion about a topic, because how can a person with a 1000+ followers be wrong. Then subsequently people see that a majority believe this persons opinion and then copy that opinion into their own.

And next thing you know everyone is following the leader.

I dunno, maybe i'm wrong.

The Russians are banking on all of the above.

This appears to be a part of "real" 21st Century cyber warfare, this constant confusion and disinformation.
 

Hoid

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 15, 2017
20,408
4
36
There is a difference between hacking and state sponsored hacking.