Actually Jay, it has been about 20 years since I believed in a historical Jesus, though it's more recently that I have been led to the conclusions that a) the "historical Jesus" is a fabrication and that b) the idea that Biblical historicity is a recent one, born when the Fundementalists (in the original sense of the word) sought to try to make Christianity consistent with the rationalism of the Enlightenment at the end of the 19th century.
What I do respect most highly is what the mythical Jesus tells humankind about the way we should live and interact with each other, which things are important and which are not, and that death is not to be feared. As myth (in the positive sense), the Gospels are a brilliant allegory that hold the best of humanity's moral and social wisdom in the form of a figure who has incorporated the best we can strive for (God) with the essence of what we are (flawed humans).
I tend to see attempts to historicize the Bible and focus on miracles and the children's stories portions (Noah, Jonah etc), at best, childish and at worst, idolatry.
There is nothing found in Christianity that can't be found in any of the world's religions if one approaches them with love and humility and an eye to the truth.
Last word: Any religion that is in contradicition with the discoveries of science, is just superstition.