German Court Bans Head Scarves

Ariadne

Council Member
Aug 7, 2006
2,432
8
38
Lets take it one step further........If a teacher must give up thier individuality then so must the students.........correct?

No one in the building is allowed to wear hats. No one, in the name of religion, should be allowed to break the rules. Even teachers, the role models, are expected to follow the rules. How's that for breaking it down?
 

Tonington

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 27, 2006
15,441
150
63
Well, when a teacher is at work, they are a government employee. We have that separation between religion and state. While you are teaching, any expression of individuality, in this case religion, can be seen as a promotion of certain values by the state. Teachers have a very narrow SOP in this case, and rightly so, that's the way our system is set up. Do any of you know any teachers? If you think something like OH&S is bad, try reading the tomes they recieve yearly in some cases (at least in Nova Scotia). These manuals are constantly being updated, informing teachers how they are to teach, what they are to teach, etc.

You're free to be an individual on your own time, or at work I suppose if your employer allows it, but not as a government employee.
 

selfactivated

Time Out
Apr 11, 2006
4,276
42
48
62
Richmond, Virginia
No one in the building is allowed to wear hats. No one, in the name of religion, should be allowed to break the rules. Even teachers, the role models, are expected to follow the rules. How's that for breaking it down?


I disagee (and I'll do it without an attitude) if you take away one right you take away ALL rights. Hitler was a great example of all or nothing thinking.
 

RomSpaceKnight

Council Member
Oct 30, 2006
1,384
23
38
62
London, Ont. Canada
A teacher is a role model for all not just some students. They must teach in a way that does not in any way shape or form promote personal feelings beyond the caring attitude most good teachers have. This is a goverment run institution. You don't like it home school your kids. You want your kids indoctrinated in to someone elses faith or how about the goverment tell you what faiths are acceptable.

Borders are falling all over the world. We are becoming a global village. All this crap about traditional western values is history. All countries are multicultural wether they like it or not. Goverments are trying to be inclusive not exclusive. The falling birth rate in the west demands that we open our doors to immigration to prop up our social programs and infrastructure. To attract first class immigrants we need to offer an inclusive and open culture or else all we will get is the low class ones. No doctors, no middle businessmen just dirt poor refugees.

This is the 21st century. Stamping your feet and saying "I'm not changing, make him change" will only get you past over by history. We are the driving force of evolution on this planet and we must evolve. We must go forward. Standing still to up hold the status quo will only give the Chinese the leg up they need to usurp the position of the west as the driving force in world culture. We don't evolve by the next century our children's children will be learning Cantonese or Mandarin so as to be able to land a good paying job.
 

selfactivated

Time Out
Apr 11, 2006
4,276
42
48
62
Richmond, Virginia
A teacher is a role model for all not just some students. They must teach in a way that does not in any way shape or form promote personal feelings beyond the caring attitude most good teachers have. This is a goverment run institution. You don't like it home school your kids. You want your kids indoctrinated in to someone elses faith or how about the goverment tell you what faiths are acceptable.

Borders are falling all over the world. We are becoming a global village. All this crap about traditional western values is history. All countries are multicultural wether they like it or not. Goverments are trying to be inclusive not exclusive. The falling birth rate in the west demands that we open our doors to immigration to prop up our social programs and infrastructure. To attract first class immigrants we need to offer an inclusive and open culture or else all we will get is the low class ones. No doctors, no middle businessmen just dirt poor refugees.

This is the 21st century. Stamping your feet and saying "I'm not changing, make him change" will only get you past over by history. We are the driving force of evolution on this planet and we must evolve. We must go forward. Standing still to up hold the status quo will only give the Chinese the leg up they need to usurp the position of the west as the driving force in world culture. We don't evolve by the next century our children's children will be learning Cantonese or Mandarin so as to be able to land a good paying job.


Im sorry I cant buy into that. If I do I loose who I am to the masses. The coolest teachers I had wore Peace signs, Mason symbols and yes crosses. Taking religious rights away from people does not open boarders it slams them shut. Teaching kids there is nothing but what the government says there is isnt an open door policy its a match to light a bonfire
 

talloola

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 14, 2006
19,576
113
63
Vancouver Island
I would in a heart beat but the work was part time and under the table. Also Im bi-polar and its easy to blame that too. But let me tell you......as close as I am to DC my friends have the same problems. Being Pagan in the states makes it very difficult to find not only work but acceptance

Can you tell me where in the world it would be "easy to find work and be
accepted" in your situation?
 

talloola

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 14, 2006
19,576
113
63
Vancouver Island
This isn't Germany, this is Canada and we have chosen to be a multicultural country. Germany has made different decisions and at what point does anyone from Canada have the right to tell Germany that they should be multicultural, multireligion and just another great big melting pot of anything goes. Shouldn't some places in the world develop in their own way without having to adhere to the cultureless North American "anything goes" attitudes?

The true culture of north america would be "First Nation" and after that our
country contains many cultures, so I can't relate to your statement."cultureless.
And my understanding of the "anything goes" attitude would be, our "understanding" and
tolerance of many "cultures".

.[
 

selfactivated

Time Out
Apr 11, 2006
4,276
42
48
62
Richmond, Virginia
I would in a heart beat but the work was part time and under the table. Also Im bi-polar and its easy to blame that too. But let me tell you......as close as I am to DC my friends have the same problems. Being Pagan in the states makes it very difficult to find not only work but acceptance

Can you tell me where in the world it would be "easy to find work and be
accepted" in your situation?


England wasnt so bad about the Paganism. Work is a different story I dont think theres anyone in the working world that accepts paganism or any other "ism" unless its christianity but that aint an "ism" now is it?
 

sanctus

The Padre
Oct 27, 2006
4,558
48
48
Ontario
www.poetrypoem.com
It's not only head scafs being banned. Any open display of religion is gone. A cross openly worn in plain view applies as well. A jewish orthodiox male would not be allowed hos head covering either. This is not a law aimed at Muslims. It is aimed at all religions. Religion is for family and church not goverment and public schools.

And yes I feel that if I was a teacher my medicine bag would have to be tucked away out of site and that I would have to teach Hallowe'en as a chance to score free candy.


Then it is, by its own defintion, fair as a law. I believe France enacted the same conditions in its school systems a few years back. They are perfectly correct to do so, and in some ways it actually makes sense to me.

Our public schools, to a much minor degree, have done the same thing by promoting an environment that is not exclusive to the Christian religion any longer.
 

Ariadne

Council Member
Aug 7, 2006
2,432
8
38
Well, when a teacher is at work, they are a government employee. We have that separation between religion and state. While you are teaching, any expression of individuality, in this case religion, can be seen as a promotion of certain values by the state. Teachers have a very narrow SOP in this case, and rightly so, that's the way our system is set up. Do any of you know any teachers? If you think something like OH&S is bad, try reading the tomes they recieve yearly in some cases (at least in Nova Scotia). These manuals are constantly being updated, informing teachers how they are to teach, what they are to teach, etc.

You're free to be an individual on your own time, or at work I suppose if your employer allows it, but not as a government employee.

That was very well said and it is exactly the way it is. One of most important things students learn is to conform to the rules and do what everyone else is doing: their homework, listening in class, doing as their told, sitting still, not goofing around ... and the list goes on. I don't know why teachers would want a double standard where they can do their own thing while everyone else is supposed to conform to the rules.
 

Ariadne

Council Member
Aug 7, 2006
2,432
8
38
I disagee (and I'll do it without an attitude) if you take away one right you take away ALL rights. Hitler was a great example of all or nothing thinking.

Wearing a hat in school is not a right, it's a way for the students to hide and avoid eye contact.
 

darleneonfire

Electoral Member
Jan 12, 2007
203
2
18
65
Ontario
That was very well said and it is exactly the way it is. One of most important things students learn is to conform to the rules and do what everyone else is doing: their homework, listening in class, doing as their told, sitting still, not goofing around ... and the list goes on. I don't know why teachers would want a double standard where they can do their own thing while everyone else is supposed to conform to the rules.

Agreed. I wish we would do that in our public schools. I detest Muslims wearing those silly symbols of servitude. That's exactly what all that covering up is, an extreme form of chauvinism.

Just had a thought though, we couldn't possibly ban religious symbols in our schools since we have the Catholic school system and I hardly imagine them doing away with religious symbols in their schools.
 

Ariadne

Council Member
Aug 7, 2006
2,432
8
38
Then it is, by its own defintion, fair as a law. I believe France enacted the same conditions in its school systems a few years back. They are perfectly correct to do so, and in some ways it actually makes sense to me.

Our public schools, to a much minor degree, have done the same thing by promoting an environment that is not exclusive to the Christian religion any longer.

Canadian schools used to have some Christian celebrations. What has happened is that the Christian celebrations have been dropped ... not the other way around where all religious celebrations have been included: exclusive, not inclusive. The schools are excluding everything religious.
 

darleneonfire

Electoral Member
Jan 12, 2007
203
2
18
65
Ontario
Canadian schools used to have some Christian celebrations. What has happened is that the Christian celebrations have been dropped ... not the other way around where all religious celebrations have been included: exclusive, not inclusive. The schools are excluding everything religious.


Not all the schools here, the Catholic boards still are religious. My nephews go to Catholic school and it is very Christian orientated.

As for what you wrote about our public schools, very true. It made me quite made last year when my youngest came home and I saw he was studying Muslim holy days. I mean, give me a break. That's not fair to exclude his native religion in order to study the religion of others.He got in trouble once for bringing a Bible to school to do a project as his teacher said the bible would offend people.
 

mapleleafgirl

Electoral Member
Dec 13, 2006
864
12
18
35
windsor,ontario
Not all the schools here, the Catholic boards still are religious. My nephews go to Catholic school and it is very Christian orientated.

As for what you wrote about our public schools, very true. It made me quite made last year when my youngest came home and I saw he was studying Muslim holy days. I mean, give me a break. That's not fair to exclude his native religion in order to study the religion of others.He got in trouble once for bringing a Bible to school to do a project as his teacher said the bible would offend people.

in my school we have lots of muslims and the teachers and everybody goes out of their way to please them. makes me angry. i took to wearing a big crucifix for a well cos it irritated them. one of the teachers asked me to put it inside my shirt and i refused cos i said its not fair if they can wear their funny outfits and show off being muslim i can wear a crucifix. my mom actually backed me. i took it off after a few months cos i felt like a hypocrite cos i dont even know wha i believe and i certainly am not yet any kind of christian.
 

Ariadne

Council Member
Aug 7, 2006
2,432
8
38
Agreed. I wish we would do that in our public schools. I detest Muslims wearing those silly symbols of servitude. That's exactly what all that covering up is, an extreme form of chauvinism.

Just had a thought though, we couldn't possibly ban religious symbols in our schools since we have the Catholic school system and I hardly imagine them doing away with religious symbols in their schools.

Public schools have eliminated everything religious. Private schools and Catholic schools can make their own rules about religious symbols and celebrations.

I haven't researched the origin of the Muslim head scarf but it wouldn't surprise me if it has something to do with head bugs like lice and maybe it's to discourage men from coveting other's wives (in it's original form) but in any case, it's not consistent with Western views.
 

Ariadne

Council Member
Aug 7, 2006
2,432
8
38
Not all the schools here, the Catholic boards still are religious. My nephews go to Catholic school and it is very Christian orientated.

As for what you wrote about our public schools, very true. It made me quite made last year when my youngest came home and I saw he was studying Muslim holy days. I mean, give me a break. That's not fair to exclude his native religion in order to study the religion of others.He got in trouble once for bringing a Bible to school to do a project as his teacher said the bible would offend people.

There is absolutely nothing in the curriculum about learning the Holy days of other religions ... it sounds like the teacher was lost on some personal tangent, much like Jim Keegstra. I don't know what province you're in, but you can look at the entire curriculum for every grade online.
 

mapleleafgirl

Electoral Member
Dec 13, 2006
864
12
18
35
windsor,ontario
Public schools have eliminated everything religious. Private schools and Catholic schools can make their own rules about religious symbols and celebrations.

I haven't researched the origin of the Muslim head scarf but it wouldn't surprise me if it has something to do with head bugs like lice and maybe it's to discourage men from coveting other's wives (in it's original form) but in any case, it's not consistent with Western views.

thats not true. i go to a public school. instead of one prayer our principal has five minutres of "spiritual readings" in the morning after the o canada. he takes stuff from all over the place, a few times from the koran and a few times from the bible, but mostly stuff from non religious sources i think.
 

mapleleafgirl

Electoral Member
Dec 13, 2006
864
12
18
35
windsor,ontario
There is absolutely nothing in the curriculum about learning the Holy days of other religions ... it sounds like the teacher was lost on some personal tangent, much like Jim Keegstra. I don't know what province you're in, but you can look at the entire curriculum for every grade online.


im in ontario and we learned about ramadan and some jewish holiday that i cant remember right now, the one that comes around christmas.