It isn't a stupid question, Jon, and asking a question like this doesn't simply mean attaching human emotion to religion. It is a matter of religions. It is a very good question, in fact. I'd say so - I will trust a Pagan first and foremost, and then a Buddhist, I guess, and last come Muslims and Christians.
I will trust Pagans, and if I have a choice whether to deal with a Pagan person or with a person of some other religion, I will choose the Pagan. And it is not a matter of emotions. I know what the Pagan principles are, I know the rules of the Pagan religion, and I know that the main rule is not to cheat on those who are of your religion. I know that Pagan religion is a very strong uniting force, that really lets its followers see the necessity of standing by each other. While Christianity doesn't make it an emphatic point to respect people you deal with and to stand by your fellow christians. That is why I am always careful in dealing with christians, even when it comes to my relatives and old friends. Their mentality is such, that they might do something really lousy any time, and then just smile in a shy way, and say - oops....