yup, and you've had 8 years to ensure that.
Not my fault, I didn't take him prisoner.
yup, and you've had 8 years to ensure that.
So the Canucks who are fighting for the UN in Afghanistan have no Canadian rights? Canadians have been fighting for other countries pretty much since a few went and fought in the American Revolution.
Another Necro?
The Conservative party wants to take away the rights of Canadian citizens
rofl
As a Canadian, I voluntarily forfiet my right to throw grenades at american soldiers. All in agreement, say aye!
A point nobody has yet mentioned is that the US invasion of Iraq was illegal under international law. Regardless of whose politics you support, America had no business being there in the first place and even less right to legally prosecute somebody who resisted them. As several posters have noted, Khadr is a Canadian and Canada has a legal obligation to support him. Whether or not we agree with the ideological cause he supported is legally irrelevant.
I think it goes without saying that a US military judge is not impartial. If one of his judges had adjudicated that he was not guilty that judge’s career would have been finished. Khadr's trial was a kangaroo court. Under both international law and Canadian law Khadr's trial and imprisonment are illegal. He is a political prisoner of an extremist right wing war mongering state.
What does the above say about Mr. Harper? Nothing honourable or complimentary. If he is the sort of individual who will abandon Canadians who are detained contrary to international law because there is something about their politics he disagrees with, he does not deserve to govern. He does not have to agree with somebody’s politics to recognize his responsibility as PM to protect their legal rights. He lacks the morals and the intestinal fortitude for the job.
FYI- I have noted the invasion of both Afghanistan and Iraq as illegal from their inception. There is good reason the US has not followed international law and the Geneva conventions in these actions though. If they did adhere to such laws and treaties everything they have done would be viewed as war crimes. By not declaring war or waiting for UN mandate they avoid having to follow the laws and treaties surrounding wars.
FYI- I have noted the invasion of both Afghanistan and Iraq as illegal from their inception. There is good reason the US has not followed international law and the Geneva conventions in these actions though. If they did adhere to such laws and treaties everything they have done would be viewed as war crimes. By not declaring war or waiting for UN mandate they avoid having to follow the laws and treaties surrounding wars.
I'd say when he chose to fight for a foreign power he gave up any rights he once had as a Canadian citizen.
I can understand this, there is a big difference between allegedly being involved with a terrorist organization and being caught fighting for and killing friendly forces in the name of one.
As a Canadian, I voluntarily forfiet my right to throw grenades at american soldiers. All in agreement, say aye!
Which is why he is doing time. The question is :
1. is he entitled to 10 million? Nay.
For reasons I can't ascertain you are questioning my point #1`- the Supreme courts have decided that Mr. Khadr isn't entitled to the money. If you have anything that the court judgement erred in- produce it.Canada might need you to exercise that right some day. Whether or not it ever happens, you should not surrender the right. America is a foreign country, and not always a friendly one.
No? How much are years of life and torture worth? How much should the government have to be penalized to make certain it understands that it cannot abandon Canadians because it doesn't like their politics? The question will have to be answered by the courts after evaluating the issues involved. If it doesn't cost the government big time, why shouldn't the government just keep doing it?
Send him to Afghanistan??? Now THAt is a good idea.
For reasons I can't ascertain you are questioning my point #1`- the Supreme courts have decided that Mr. Khadr isn't entitled to the money. If you have anything that the court judgement erred in- produce it.
ITS produce OR BE QUIET TIME, MR TOBER.