Conversations with God
- Thread starter Said1
- Start date
No I haven't Said1 what is it about?
I did read Marly and me this summer, it is a short read but if you like dogs you must read this book. I laughed and cried, it was a wonderful book.
I did read Marly and me this summer, it is a short read but if you like dogs you must read this book. I laughed and cried, it was a wonderful book.
I have not read it, but I have talked to people that found it helpful in their own deconstructing the Christian mythology they were raised under.
What's it about? It's certainly not very Christian, in fact, I have a feeling most Christians would toss it on the fire with the rest of the new age books. I'm not very religious nor am I interested in new age gurus, but I like what he has to say so far.
Here's what wiki says:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conversations_with_God
Hi Said 1,
I've read the trilogy, as well as a few more of Neal Donald Walsh's books.... since I read them at a time in my life when I was actively questioning and redefining my concepts of faith, self, religion etc, they were very helpful in providing me with a new outlook. Opened my heart and mind to greater possibilities, provided me with the impetus to look at my own life, judgements, preconceived notions of right vs wrong etc. with new eyes. That said, I'd be very interested to hear your thoughts if you decide to read the trilogy. He continued to churn out many books after the initial three, none of which really seemed to be saying anything new. He has, since writing those books, gone on to become a bit of a 'guru' I suppose you could say, at least to some people... he now has an organization that offers retreats, workshops, study materials etc... at what I consider to be fairly steep prices... not necessarily in line with some of his writings, imo... at any rate, his books also resulted in a discussion forum for like-minded people - which has now split off from having any direct affiliation with Neal Donald Walsh - at his request - and I believe a new forum was established that focuses only on the message of the Conversations with God series. The old forum still exists, however, as it had become quite a community by the time Mr. Walsh disolved his connection with it. Anyway, hope to hear more from you as you read through the books! Enjoy !!
I've read the trilogy, as well as a few more of Neal Donald Walsh's books.... since I read them at a time in my life when I was actively questioning and redefining my concepts of faith, self, religion etc, they were very helpful in providing me with a new outlook. Opened my heart and mind to greater possibilities, provided me with the impetus to look at my own life, judgements, preconceived notions of right vs wrong etc. with new eyes. That said, I'd be very interested to hear your thoughts if you decide to read the trilogy. He continued to churn out many books after the initial three, none of which really seemed to be saying anything new. He has, since writing those books, gone on to become a bit of a 'guru' I suppose you could say, at least to some people... he now has an organization that offers retreats, workshops, study materials etc... at what I consider to be fairly steep prices... not necessarily in line with some of his writings, imo... at any rate, his books also resulted in a discussion forum for like-minded people - which has now split off from having any direct affiliation with Neal Donald Walsh - at his request - and I believe a new forum was established that focuses only on the message of the Conversations with God series. The old forum still exists, however, as it had become quite a community by the time Mr. Walsh disolved his connection with it. Anyway, hope to hear more from you as you read through the books! Enjoy !!
Hi Said 1,
I've read the trilogy, as well as a few more of Neal Donald Walsh's books.... since I read them at a time in my life when I was actively questioning and redefining my concepts of faith, self, religion etc, they were very helpful in providing me with a new outlook. Opened my heart and mind to greater possibilities, provided me with the impetus to look at my own life, judgements, preconceived notions of right vs wrong etc. with new eyes. That said, I'd be very interested to hear your thoughts if you decide to read the trilogy. He continued to churn out many books after the initial three, none of which really seemed to be saying anything new. He has, since writing those books, gone on to become a bit of a 'guru' I suppose you could say, at least to some people... he now has an organization that offers retreats, workshops, study materials etc... at what I consider to be fairly steep prices... not necessarily in line with some of his writings, imo... at any rate, his books also resulted in a discussion forum for like-minded people - which has now split off from having any direct affiliation with Neal Donald Walsh - at his request - and I believe a new forum was established that focuses only on the message of the Conversations with God series. The old forum still exists, however, as it had become quite a community by the time Mr. Walsh disolved his connection with it. Anyway, hope to hear more from you as you read through the books! Enjoy !!
I like a lot of his answers thus far but am disappointed to read he's been elevated to such an exulted status. LOL.
There are many things he says that do not stray far from the writings of other newagers but I'm enjoying his use of scripture to illustrate many of his points.
So far, this is what has stuck with me the most:
heh heh yes, said 1, I have to admit, I really enjoyed the persona of 'God' that provided the answers to Neal's questions... forthright, logical and non judgemental... and at times, Neal's 'God' even came off as incedulous at the ways in which we've managed to evade some truths that appear almost ridiculously obvious once pointed out... of course, there were also some points made that just didn't ring true for me... a few pat answers that didn't stand up to deeper scrutiny...
as to the author's 'exalted status' (hahaha I liked that phrase said 1) I was also disappointed for a time, but I've since concluded that I got what I wanted from the first 3 books, and it's only the message that's relevent to me... as for the messenger... well, I suppose his journey continues eh? I don't really know how it could have been avoided, since the material appeals to such a broad range of people who are compelled to think outside the box, he has attracted a pretty huge fan base... there's alot of people out there who are sick to death of the answers organized religion provides... particulalry Christian based religions... I viewed his writings as a springboard for me to really challenge and redefine my own beliefs... but not as the be all and end all final word on the subject of spirituality...
anyway, thanks for sharing your thoughts so far...
as to the author's 'exalted status' (hahaha I liked that phrase said 1) I was also disappointed for a time, but I've since concluded that I got what I wanted from the first 3 books, and it's only the message that's relevent to me... as for the messenger... well, I suppose his journey continues eh? I don't really know how it could have been avoided, since the material appeals to such a broad range of people who are compelled to think outside the box, he has attracted a pretty huge fan base... there's alot of people out there who are sick to death of the answers organized religion provides... particulalry Christian based religions... I viewed his writings as a springboard for me to really challenge and redefine my own beliefs... but not as the be all and end all final word on the subject of spirituality...
anyway, thanks for sharing your thoughts so far...
The book and his other words sound interesting and I would enjoy reading all I can by that author...
My introduction to this kind of thought was from a little pocket book called The Wisdom of Insecurity by Alan Watts http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alan_Watts.
I received it in the late 80s and devoured it in one sitting and walked around in a trance trying to understand all of his words. I still re-read it and his other writings to "get" things - many of which defy my ability to comprehend all of it.
Still, it doesn't hurt to open a few doors as I am certain we lack many answers in the here and now of evolution. He wrote many essays and articles, and while I collect them I have to space them out as they take so much time to
think of the things he writes.
My introduction to this kind of thought was from a little pocket book called The Wisdom of Insecurity by Alan Watts http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alan_Watts.
I received it in the late 80s and devoured it in one sitting and walked around in a trance trying to understand all of his words. I still re-read it and his other writings to "get" things - many of which defy my ability to comprehend all of it.
Still, it doesn't hurt to open a few doors as I am certain we lack many answers in the here and now of evolution. He wrote many essays and articles, and while I collect them I have to space them out as they take so much time to
think of the things he writes.
The Author, from what I can tell has not had a realtionship with God. Its nothing as he makes it to be in his book, Making it just a book with an interesting concept.
That's just it. As Zan said 'thinking outside the box', food for thought if you will. Have you read the book? I don't have much of a relationship with God either, but I always enjoy reading scripture as well as how others interpret the words and teachings of Jesus.
Curiosity: What is the book you mentioned about? I've heard several others say similar things but have yet to come accross it.
Zan: When guys like Neal make it big, it always reminds me of my granny who's favorite phrase is 'beware of the false prophet'. To her there was no other philosopher or person who could match Jesus. She was a funny old gal.
Id Much rather read it for myself and gather my own Interpertations of the Bible, Instead of taking the word of someone who doesnt seem to have any Spirtual or Theolgical input.
So you didn't read the book? No one said his word was the gospel either, just his take and an interesting one at that. I suppose you don't read anyone's interpretations of things, then?
Not really, I usally read books where I can make my Own interpretations, I have found that its better to Interpret things for myself, because most people have thier own motives behind their Interpretations. Especailly when it is on Spirtuality.
Spirtuality is something you must procive yourself, and I think that it is something also personal. I dont let preachers or authors tell me what to, or what I should think. I understand this book is just a book, but if its just a book, than whats the point of reading it? Imean if its not going to really give you any spirtual jump on things. Thats My Opinion, Iam into reading Factual books on Wars, Polotics, and Books writen about the Bible that give insight into things, But nopthing that has its own opinon or conflicts with mine. Why have an Opinion if you dont think its right?
Anyway Iam sure its a good book, but it doesnt seem like anything id like to read.
If you want a good spiritual book try "5 people you meet in heaven"..bring Kleenex for the ending though
I know a great deal about CWG AND the author. I was in charge of Neales message board since since 2002. And I met Neale in 2004 in PA. Neale himself was a great disappointment and a liar. The first 3 books and Frendship are a must read and started me on the spiritual path I'm currently on. Yes the beginning books are creative and wonderful to read but the following books are repetitive, political and I follow NOONE as a Guru!
Through Neale Ive met the most wonderful and the most teribble people in my life. The people I stayed with in England are among the most wonderful and some local people here in the states among the worst. But thats with any group.
I splintered off Neales group after a disagreement about allowing a pedaphile on the site after I banned him. Neale is just as much a hypocrite as any man searching to be a leader instead of following his own printed words.
Wednesday (I think thats you isnt it curiosity? My friend lived in NYC and was an actress. Her screen name was Wednesday too) (If not I oppologize) Is the one that introduced me to CWG on Lynn Grabhorn's Board. We were quite the little family.
I should write a book about the man behind the printed word. He had a protage, Cedric, the most amazing young man Ive ever met! He goes back and forth from working to volunteering in India. I want to be like Cedric when I grow up. He's my hero. He found out about Neale like I did, the hard way. All experiences are for a purpose and without them we arent who we are in this now. Nothing in my world ever goes wrong.
Through Neale Ive met the most wonderful and the most teribble people in my life. The people I stayed with in England are among the most wonderful and some local people here in the states among the worst. But thats with any group.
I splintered off Neales group after a disagreement about allowing a pedaphile on the site after I banned him. Neale is just as much a hypocrite as any man searching to be a leader instead of following his own printed words.
Wednesday (I think thats you isnt it curiosity? My friend lived in NYC and was an actress. Her screen name was Wednesday too) (If not I oppologize) Is the one that introduced me to CWG on Lynn Grabhorn's Board. We were quite the little family.
I should write a book about the man behind the printed word. He had a protage, Cedric, the most amazing young man Ive ever met! He goes back and forth from working to volunteering in India. I want to be like Cedric when I grow up. He's my hero. He found out about Neale like I did, the hard way. All experiences are for a purpose and without them we arent who we are in this now. Nothing in my world ever goes wrong.
Last edited:
cant you say the same thing about the bible or whatever book it is you are using/reading for spiritual knowledge??
other books about the bible? couldent they be taken as opinions? the bible is a large book..if everyone was on teh same page with its readings, wouldent everyone be enlightened.? arent those other peopls opinions you are reading?
you werent born with opinions programmed in the back of your head..how did you get your opinions..im assuming by reading books and listening/talking about others opinions.?
many have said, even in this book, that the bible itself is a book written/edited around personal agenda.
certain things/facts let in and certain things/facts left out..all for a matter of agenda..generally at the hand of fear...
even if, all books are stating facts as the nature of their writing, but cant all words still be left open to interpretation?? regardless if they come across as "facts" ?
none of this is a personal "slam" againts you..i just dont get your logic..
Love the nic oneeno reminds me of someone I know. We ARE one. But we all dont get it now do we. And if we did how boring would life be. Isnt THAT Neales original message? Tolerence.