The best beef roast and how to cook it

Niflmir

A modern nomad
Dec 18, 2006
3,460
58
48
Leiden, the Netherlands
I am quite lazy, so the simpler the recipe the better.

For roasts, I usually stick them in a slow cooker in the morning with some onion soup mix and maybe a small amount of water if I am worried about burning (depends how fatty the roast is). By the time I come home from work it is time to put the potatoes, carrots and other veggies in.

Usually my problem is that it becomes too tender and falls apart the minute I try to slice it. Here in Berlin I do not have a slow cooker, so I usually put it on the stove top on the lowest heat setting and use more water (less than 200cc). I usually don't leave for work when cooking on the stove top like this.

With the onion soup mix, it will make a quite nice gravy which will stew the potatoes and carrots. Maybe you don't want that, so you can always cook them seperately.
 

#juan

Hall of Fame Member
Aug 30, 2005
18,326
119
63
I am quite lazy, so the simpler the recipe the better.

For roasts, I usually stick them in a slow cooker in the morning with some onion soup mix and maybe a small amount of water if I am worried about burning (depends how fatty the roast is). By the time I come home from work it is time to put the potatoes, carrots and other veggies in.

Usually my problem is that it becomes too tender and falls apart the minute I try to slice it. Here in Berlin I do not have a slow cooker, so I usually put it on the stove top on the lowest heat setting and use more water (less than 200cc). I usually don't leave for work when cooking on the stove top like this.

With the onion soup mix, it will make a quite nice gravy which will stew the potatoes and carrots. Maybe you don't want that, so you can always cook them seperately.

I've used a recipe very much like your recipe and it always works. What I was trying to do is emulate the slow cooker using the oven I'm guessing that 260 degrees was a bit too hot.
 

#juan

Hall of Fame Member
Aug 30, 2005
18,326
119
63
The biggest insult to a good roast beef is an empty air bubble called Yorkshire Pudding.

Yorkshire Pudding might be an aquired taste but I love it. If you have a really good dark gravy, Yorkshire Pudding is another vehicle for it. Roast beef and Yorkshire Pudding go together like bacon and eggs....but better
 

YukonJack

Time Out
Dec 26, 2008
7,026
73
48
Winnipeg
#juan, I am a meat and potato kind of guy. I have had Yorkshire Pudding served to me by various restaurants/girlfriends/wife, once, but you can keep it. It is not the taste, I like the taste - identical - in my pancake breakfast.

But NOT with beef.
 

#juan

Hall of Fame Member
Aug 30, 2005
18,326
119
63
#juan, I am a meat and potato kind of guy. I have had Yorkshire Pudding served to me by various restaurants/girlfriends/wife, once, but you can keep it. It is not the taste, I like the taste - identical - in my pancake breakfast.

But NOT with beef.

Hey, we like what we like. Nobody can say you are wrong.....;-)...
 

YukonJack

Time Out
Dec 26, 2008
7,026
73
48
Winnipeg
Recently I saw a show on the Food Channel about rump roast and how to prepare it, hosted by Anna Olsen.

I tried the recipe, and came to the conclusion, that there is none better.

No sissy Yorkshire Pudding involved.