Owner of 'Reptile Ocean' exotic pet store had blood on hands, clothing

SLM

The Velvet Hammer
Mar 5, 2011
29,151
5
36
London, Ontario
Owner of 'Reptile Ocean' exotic pet store had blood on hands, clothing


Newly-obtained documents reveal the owner of the New Brunswick exotic pet store located below an apartment where two young brothers were found dead after a snake escaped its enclosure, was outside the building with blood on his hands and clothing when police arrived.
Search warrants obtained by CTV Atlantic reveal that Jean-Claude Savoie, owner of the Reptile Ocean pet store in Campbellton, N.B., told police on Aug. 5 that two children had been killed by an African rock python. He also told officers that the snake was still unaccounted for.
The documents also reveal that a number of dead animals were found stored in freezers inside Reptile Ocean.

The search warrants include a statement from a conservation agent who said that the dead reptiles were eventually thawed and buried on crown property.
Three different agencies are investigating the circumstances surrounding the deaths of brothers Noah Barthe, 4, and Connor Barthe, 6, including the coroner's office and the Department of Natural Resources.
Early autopsy results concluded that the boys were asphyxiated by an African rock python.
No charges have been laid at this time.

Following the deaths, conservation authorities seized a total of 27 animals from Reptile Ocean. The reptiles were transferred to zoos in New Brunswick and Ontario.
Four American alligators and four snakes were euthanized on site because no zoos were able to accommodate them.
The African rock python has been banned in the province since 1992. Only accredited zoos with permits are allowed to own the snake species.
Police said the snake escaped its enclosure, entered the apartment's ventilation system and dropped into the room where the brothers were sleeping.
The boys, who are friends with Savoie's child, were sleeping over at the apartment at the time of their death.

Read more: Owner of African rock python that killed N.B. brothers had blood on hands, clothing | CTV News

Way, way, way more going on here than initial reports have stated.



 

Sal

Hall of Fame Member
Sep 29, 2007
17,135
33
48
Owner of 'Reptile Ocean' exotic pet store had blood on hands, clothing


Newly-obtained documents reveal the owner of the New Brunswick exotic pet store located below an apartment where two young brothers were found dead after a snake escaped its enclosure, was outside the building with blood on his hands and clothing when police arrived.
Search warrants obtained by CTV Atlantic reveal that Jean-Claude Savoie, owner of the Reptile Ocean pet store in Campbellton, N.B., told police on Aug. 5 that two children had been killed by an African rock python. He also told officers that the snake was still unaccounted for.
The documents also reveal that a number of dead animals were found stored in freezers inside Reptile Ocean.

The search warrants include a statement from a conservation agent who said that the dead reptiles were eventually thawed and buried on crown property.
Three different agencies are investigating the circumstances surrounding the deaths of brothers Noah Barthe, 4, and Connor Barthe, 6, including the coroner's office and the Department of Natural Resources.
Early autopsy results concluded that the boys were asphyxiated by an African rock python.
No charges have been laid at this time.

Following the deaths, conservation authorities seized a total of 27 animals from Reptile Ocean. The reptiles were transferred to zoos in New Brunswick and Ontario.
Four American alligators and four snakes were euthanized on site because no zoos were able to accommodate them.
The African rock python has been banned in the province since 1992. Only accredited zoos with permits are allowed to own the snake species.
Police said the snake escaped its enclosure, entered the apartment's ventilation system and dropped into the room where the brothers were sleeping.
The boys, who are friends with Savoie's child, were sleeping over at the apartment at the time of their death.

Read more: Owner of African rock python that killed N.B. brothers had blood on hands, clothing | CTV News

Way, way, way more going on here than initial reports have stated.



so in other words it looks like our feelings of apprehension about what had actually occurred is seeming more correct ... even though they kept saying the snake did it...

those poor frigging kids... I wonder if an accident happened with one and the snake got used for the other with a bit of wrapping help...I wonder if we will ever really know...I think most of us immediately decided...no way the snake did it the way they were saying
 

SLM

The Velvet Hammer
Mar 5, 2011
29,151
5
36
London, Ontario
so in other words it looks like our feelings of apprehension about what had actually occurred is seeming more correct ... even though they kept saying the snake did it...

those poor frigging kids... I wonder if an accident happened with one and the snake got used for the other with a bit of wrapping help...I wonder if we will ever really know...I think most of us immediately decided...no way the snake did it the way they were saying

We still don't know what actually happened, but why the hell would he have blood on his hands and clothes?

Mind you the autopsy still shows the boys died of asphyxiation, but did the authorities dispose of a live snake? Was the guy in the room, maybe had the snake out and the snake attacked? The blood could belong to the snake if he was trying to rip it off a kid.

More questions than answers but of course we're not privy to all the information either.
 

Sal

Hall of Fame Member
Sep 29, 2007
17,135
33
48
We still don't know what actually happened, but why the hell would he have blood on his hands and clothes?

Mind you the autopsy still shows the boys died of asphyxiation, but did the authorities dispose of a live snake? Was the guy in the room, maybe had the snake out and the snake attacked? The blood could belong to the snake if he was trying to rip it off a kid.

More questions than answers but of course we're not privy to all the information either.
they removed the snake at the time and euthanized several days later...
 

spaminator

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 26, 2009
39,036
3,605
113
Jury selection begins in case of N.B. Boys killed by escaped python
Kevin Bissett, THE CANADIAN PRESS
First posted: Monday, October 31, 2016 08:17 AM EDT | Updated: Monday, October 31, 2016 03:12 PM EDT
CAMPBELLTON, N.B. — A New Brunswick hockey rink hosted jury selection Monday for the trial of a man charged in the deaths of two boys who were suffocated by a python.
Jean-Claude Savoie, who now lives near Montreal, pleaded not guilty to criminal negligence causing death as the case convened Monday at the Campbellton Civic Centre.
Four-year-old Noah Barthe and his six-year-old brother, Connor, died after a 45-kilogram African rock python fell on them as they slept in Savoie’s Campbellton apartment in August 2013.
At the time, the RCMP said the snake managed to get out of its tank overnight while the boys were sleeping.
The apartment was above the Reptile Ocean pet store, also owned by Savoie, who was a family friend and had taken the boys shopping and to a farm before the sleepover with his son.
Once jury selection is complete, the trial will be held at the nearby Campbellton courthouse. Two weeks have been set aside for the trial.
Jury selection is being held at the rink to accommodate nearly 400 potential jurors. One end of the rink has been converted into a make-shift court.
“Your job will be to consider the evidence, and in the end decide if Jean-Claude Savoie is guilty or not-guilty,” Judge Fred Ferguson told the potential jurors.
By early afternoon, about half the jury pool had been excused and the process to pick individual jurors was set to begin.
Savoie, who has glasses and a short beard, sat quietly throughout proceedings.
In the days after the boys’ deaths, 23 reptiles were seized from his store.
Environment Canada said one of its wildlife officers took the snake to Reptile Ocean in 2002.
Mark Johnson, a spokesman for the department, said they were asked to help take the snake to Reptile Ocean after it was abandoned at the SPCA in Moncton, N.B.
In an email, he said department records indicate Reptile Ocean was operating as a zoo when the snake arrived at the facility in August 2002.
Canada’s Accredited Zoos and Aquariums, the only nationally recognized body in the country that grants accreditation for zoos, said Reptile Ocean was never accredited nor requested accreditation.
The grave of Noah and Connor Barthe, decorated for Halloween, is seen in Tide Head, N.B., Sunday, Oct. 30, 2016. Jean-Claude Savoie is charged with criminal negligence causing death after the two young brothers were asphyxiated by an African rock python in Campbellton in August 2013. Jury selection begins on Monday, Oct. 31, 2016. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Andrew Vaughan)

Jury selection begins in case of N.B. Boys killed by escaped python | Canada | N
 

spaminator

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 26, 2009
39,036
3,605
113
'Tragic story': Python kills two sleeping boys after escaping pen
The Canadian Press
First posted: Tuesday, November 01, 2016 03:48 PM EDT | Updated: Tuesday, November 01, 2016 03:56 PM EDT
CAMPBELLTON, N.B. - An “aggressive” python likely used an air duct to escape its enclosure and kill two sleeping boys — and had tried to escape before, a New Brunswick prosecutor says.
Crown attorney Pierre Roussel told a jury Tuesday that the man charged with criminal negligence in the deaths, Jean-Claude Savoie, breached his duty to the boys as they had a sleepover with his son.
Savoie, who now lives near Montreal, owned the Reptile Ocean pet store below his Campbellton apartment.
“Mr. Savoie committed a breach of duty to take care of those children when they were left with him by their mother,” Roussel told the jury. “He didn’t kill them himself but he failed to take precautions.”
Four-year-old Noah Barthe and his six-year-old brother, Connor, died after a 45-kilogram African rock python fell into the room where they slept in August 2013.
Roussel told the jury they will hear the snake had gotten into the duct before, and that an employee had warned Savoie the vent cover needed to be repaired.
“Mr. Savoie neglected to cover said vent and left an opening in his snake pen and that through that the snake was able to escape and cross through the vent and drop into the living room.”
He said the cover was found on the floor of the snake enclosure.
“Mr. Savoie was aware of the behaviour and nature of this African rock python that he was keeping. You will hear evidence that this snake was pretty aggressive. That there were special measures that had to be taken in order to care for it,” he said.
Roussel called the deaths of the boys “a sad story, a tragic story.” Savoie was a family friend who had taken the boys shopping and to a farm before the sleepover with his son.
The judge instructed the four-man, eight-woman jury about the presumption of innocence, and said Savoie starts with a “clean slate” at the beginning of the trial.
Jean-Claude Savoie heads from court in Campbellton, N.B., on Tuesday, Nov. 1, 2016. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Andrew Vaughan)

'Tragic story': Python kills two sleeping boys after escaping pen | Canada | New
 

spaminator

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 26, 2009
39,036
3,605
113
Python ’growled,’ lunged after killing two N.B. boys, Mountie tells trial
'There’s a python that got out and killed the two kids' 911 call
Kevin Bissett, The Canadian Press
First posted: Tuesday, November 01, 2016 03:48 PM EDT | Updated: Wednesday, November 02, 2016 07:56 AM EDT
CAMPBELLTON, N.B. - A 45-kilogram python lunged, snapped its jaws, and made “growling noises” when it was forced back into its pen after killing two sleeping boys, an RCMP officer told a New Brunswick jury Tuesday.
Const. Stephane Dugas described the scene on the morning of Aug. 5, 2013, shortly after Jean-Claude Savoie, who is facing trial for criminal negligence in the boys’ deaths, called 911.
Dugas testified that he found Savoie wearing a bloody shirt, two boys who were beyond medical help, and a 4.7-metre snake in the laundry room.
Savoie followed Dugas’ instructions to return the snake to its enclosure, where it made noises, rose up almost 1.8 metres and lunged at the glass, Dugas said.
The two boys -- four-year-old Noah Barthe and his six-year-old brother, Connor -- were covered in red marks, and one had a lot of wounds.
“I knew at the time not much could be done,” said Dugas. “There was lots of blood.”
He said a paramedic examined the boys, but just shook her head.
Savoie, who now lives near Montreal, owned the Reptile Ocean pet store below his Campbellton apartment. The boys were having a sleepover with his son.
Crown attorney Pierre Roussel told the jury the python likely used an air duct to escape its enclosure in the apartment — and had tried to escape before.
“Mr. Savoie committed a breach of duty to take care of those children when they were left with him by their mother,” Roussel told the jury. “He didn’t kill them himself but he failed to take precautions.”
Roussel said in his opening statement they will hear the snake had gotten into the duct before, and that an employee had warned Savoie the vent cover needed to be repaired.
“Mr. Savoie neglected to cover said vent and left an opening in his snake pen and that through that the snake was able to escape and cross through the vent and drop into the living room.”
He said the vent cover was found on the floor of the snake enclosure.
“Mr. Savoie was aware of the behaviour and nature of this African rock python that he was keeping. You will hear evidence that this snake was pretty aggressive. That there were special measures that had to be taken in order to care for it,” he said.
Roussel called the deaths of the boys “a sad story, a tragic story.” Savoie was a family friend who had taken the boys shopping and to a farm before the sleepover with his son.
Some people in the public gallery became emotional as the audio of Savoie’s 911 call was played for the jury Tuesday.
“Two kids are dead,” Savoie told the dispatcher. “There’s a python that got out and killed the two kids.”
He told the dispatcher that the snake was still loose, and he had to go back upstairs because he had another child up there.
“Can you just send someone here please?” Savoie said to the dispatcher.
Another police officer who responded to the scene also told the court Tuesday that he observed the python being very aggressive after it was put back into its enclosure.
“It was standing on its tail and charging the glass,” Sgt. Rene Labbe said.
“I observed the snake trying to reach the vent hole in the ceiling.”
Labbe said Savoie then grabbed the snake and put it in a garbage bin. It was then padlocked and removed from the property.
As the trial got underway Tuesday, the judge instructed the four-man, eight-woman jury about the presumption of innocence, and said Savoie starts with a “clean slate” at the beginning of the trial.
Transcript of 911 call: ’There’s a python that got out and killed the two kids’
The following is a transcript of the 911 call made by Jean-Claude Savoie after a python killed two sleeping boys in his apartment above Reptile Ocean, a pet store he owned in Campbellton, N.B. Savoie is charged with criminal negligence in the deaths of four-year-old Noah Barthe and his six-year-old brother, Connor. Sections of this transcript have been edited.
---
911 operator: Where is your emergency?
Jean-Claude Savoie: 2 Pleasant (Street). Two kids are dead.
Operator: Is that where you live, sir?
Savoie: Yes, that’s where I live.
Operator: What do you mean, the kids are dead?
Savoie: That’s where Reptile Ocean is. There’s a python that got out and killed the two kids.
Operator: Say that again?
Savoie: There’s a python that got out. It’s a store here. We have... (he’s cut off by the operator)
Operator: A python?
Savoie: Yeah man.
Operator: Are they your kids?
Savoie: (Breathing heavily) They’re my neighbour’s kids. She knows. She’s here too. She’s next door. She’s freaking out.
Operator: OK. Stay on the line. Who lives there?
Savoie: I live there... The snake is still out. I got another kid up there. I have to catch the snake. Can you just send somebody here please?
Python ’growled,’ lunged after killing two N.B. boys, Mountie tells trial | Cana

'I felt they would be as safe,' says mom of N.B. boys killed by python
Kevin Bisset, THE CANADIAN PRESS
First posted: Wednesday, November 02, 2016 10:56 AM EDT | Updated: Wednesday, November 02, 2016 10:02 PM EDT
CAMPBELLTON, N.B. — A New Brunswick courtroom was gripped Wednesday by the testimony of a grieving mother whose two boys were killed by a python weeks after the owner was warned the snake’s possible escape route needed to be better secured.
Jean-Claude Savoie is on trial on a charge of criminal negligence causing death. His 45-kilogram African rock python escaped an enclosure within his Campbellton apartment in August 2013 and killed Noah Barthe, 4, and Connor Barthe, 6, while they were having a sleepover.
It’s believed the snake travelled through a ventilation duct.
Savoie, who now lives near Montreal, owned the Reptile Ocean pet store below his apartment at the time. He wept Wednesday as the boys’ mother, Mandy Trecartin, talked about her sons.
She said she dropped them off for a sleepover that night certain they were in good hands.
“I felt they would be as safe with him as they would be with me,” Trecartin testified.
Trecartin says they lived behind Savoie’s apartment, and her sons were best friends with Savoie’s son. She says Savoie was a good friend, although she hasn’t seen him since Aug. 4, 2013.
They had spent that day with the boys at a farm owned by Savoie’s father, where the boys played with a lot of animals.
That evening, she and her boyfriend dropped the kids at Savoie’s apartment for a sleepover, something they did often.
At 6:49 the next morning, she heard pounding on her door, and heard Savoie saying: “Oh my God, your two kids are dead.”
She said her boyfriend went next door with Savoie, and when he came back he told her: “It’s true. It’s a (expletive) nightmare but it’s true.”
One of the first officers to arrive at the scene said he was surprised such a large snake could move so quickly. But RCMP Const. Eric Maillet said Savoie was able to recapture the python.
“The snake coiled around his arm,” Maillet said.
Savoie put the snake in its enclosure, where it could be seen through a large floor to ceiling window, he said.
“The snake started hissing at us and lunging and hitting the window with its face.”
The python appeared to be trying to escape its enclosure again, said Maillet, who was concerned the snake wanted to feed and was trying to get back to the living room where the bodies of the boys were.
“It was going straight up in the air towards the vent opening,” he said.
Maillet said he was quite surprised how the snake was able to stand straight up — almost reaching the vent opening.
“I didn’t expect such a large reptile to be able to do that.”
He said the snake was put in a garbage bin and removed from the building.
Later Wednesday, another witness told the jury that the python had previously escaped its enclosure.
Ocean Eagles, a volunteer at Jean-Claude Savoie’s reptile store, said the snake had escaped about two-and-a-half weeks earlier through a ventilation duct. She later said it could have been a month-and-a-half earlier, but she was confused on dates.
“(Savoie) told me he was sitting down in his living room and he looked up and the snake was halfway out,” Eagles testified.
Eagles said she placed a cover over the ventilation duct, but warned Savoie it needed to be screwed on. She said she often cared for the “dangerous” snake and fed it rabbits, but was very cautious.
“I knew what the snake was capable of. It can overtake any man,” she said.
Under cross-examination by defence lawyer Leslie Matchim, Eagles said the snake appeared about 2 inches larger in diameter than the duct, and she never thought it could escape through it.
“I would never think so when you look at the size of the snake. It would never cross my mind,” she said.
Eagles said her children had stayed at Savoie’s apartment before and she would not have an issue with them staying there, even after the first escape attempt by the python.
“I still can’t think it could fit out that pipe, but it did,” she said.
Judge Fred Ferguson had a few final questions for Eagles following her testimony, and asked her to look at a particular picture showing the ventilation duct. However, while flipping to that picture, Eagles burst into tears.
She sobbed and said “Oh my God,” stating she had seen a picture of the dead boys.
The Crown will call its next witness on Thursday.
'I felt they would be as safe,' says mom of N.B. boys killed by python | Canada
 

spaminator

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 26, 2009
39,036
3,605
113
Brothers killed by python ’were blue,’ N.B. negligence trial told
Kevin Bissett, THE CANADIAN PRESS
First posted: Thursday, November 03, 2016 01:49 PM EDT | Updated: Thursday, November 03, 2016 07:22 PM EDT
CAMPBELLTON, N.B. — An escaped python coiled itself around two young boys, strangling them and biting them repeatedly, a pathologist told the trial of the snake’s owner Thursday.
“Most of the puncture wounds were found on the face,” Dr. Marek Godlewski testified Thursday about injuries to Connor Barthe, 6, at the criminal negligence trial of Jean-Claude Savoie in Campbellton, N.B.
Godlewski conducted autopsies on both Connor and his four-year-old brother, Noah, on Aug 6, 2013, a day after the snake killed them during a sleepover with Savoie’s son. He described each autopsy separately Thursday.
Godlewski found Connor suffered multiple puncture wounds, abrasions and bruises, as well as hemorrhages in his neck muscles, while Noah had multiple puncture wounds compatible with bites over his body. He says there was blood on Noah’s upper body.
Godlewski said the puncture wounds to Connor were consistent with snake bites.
“I do agree the pattern of the wounds (were) consistent with the pattern of the teeth of this snake,” he testified.
The boys died as a result of the snake “coiling” around them, he said, with the specific cause of death being “asphyxia due to neck strangulation.”
There was evidence of “coiling” around Noah’s chest and neck, as well as marks on his face and nose, he said.
Savoie’s African rock python had escaped its enclosure. It’s believed the snake travelled through a ventilation duct and fell into the living room where the boys were sleeping. Savoie’s own son, who was sleeping in a different room, was unharmed.
Earlier Thursday, John O’Brien, the boyfriend of the boys’ mother, testified he had noticed the cover for the ventilation duct on the floor of the python’s enclosure on several visits to the apartment — as recently as the week before the boys’ death.
The apartment was above a reptile store owned by Savoie.
The boys’ mother, Mandy Trecartin, lived next door to Savoie, and O’Brien said he came over the morning of the tragedy, pounded the door and shouted: “Oh my God, the kids are dead.”
O’Brien said he went to Savoie’s apartment, and found Trecartin’s sons dead on the floor.
“I checked for a pulse but there wasn’t anything. They were blue,” he testified.
Dr. James Goltz, the chief provincial veterinarian for New Brunswick, testified Thursday he saw nothing abnormal with the snake when he conducted a necropsy a day after the tragedy.
He said its stomach was empty, indicating it hadn’t eaten for at least a day. He also described how a python can change its diameter by contracting — an issue that has come up during the trial because its resting width appeared larger than the duct it apparently escaped through.
Goltz said the snake was about 3.7 metres long and weighed about 24 kilograms.
Also Thursday, Bernard Gallant, co-ordinator at the Magnetic Hill Zoo in Moncton, told the court he had visited Savoie’s Reptile Ocean store four or five times over the years, and often conferred with Savoie on reptile issues.
“He showed us he was competent,” said Gallant. “I was quite impressed with what he put into the construction of the facility.”
He said when the Canadian Wildlife Service was trying to place the snake, it had offered it to the Magnetic Hill Zoo, but they didn’t have an appropriate enclosure at the time. Gallant said he told them to approach Savoie.
The Crown expects to call its final witness Friday.
Noah Barthe, left, and Connor Barthe pose in this undated photo posted on the Facebook page of Mandy Trecartin. Police in New Brunswick have charged Jean-Claude Savoie with criminal negligence causing death after two young brothers were asphyxiated by a python. The Savoie criminal negligence trial is currently underway. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/HO- Facebook)

Brothers killed by python ’were blue,’ N.B. negligence trial told | Canada | New
 

spaminator

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 26, 2009
39,036
3,605
113
Python target boys because they played with farm animals?
Kevin Bissett, THE CANADIAN PRESS
First posted: Monday, November 07, 2016 09:59 AM EST | Updated: Monday, November 07, 2016 05:24 PM EST
CAMPBELLTON, N.B. — Two boys killed by a python may have become prey because they had been playing with farm animals, a reptile expert testified Monday.
Bob Johnson, the now-retired former curator of reptiles and amphibians at the Toronto Zoo, told the criminal negligence trial of the python’s owner that a snake’s keen sense of smell lets it know prey is nearby.
“The smell of food would really excite,” he said. “That could be the trigger.”
Noah Barthe, 4, and his six-year-old brother Connor had spent Aug. 4, 2013, petting animals and playing at a farm owned by the father of Jean-Claude Savoie before a sleepover in Savoie’s apartment. Savoie is on trial on charges of criminal negligence causing death.
Johnson said snakes become more aggressive when they detect possible sources of food — and an attack would have been unlikely had there been no animal smells on the boys.
“Those boys could have been a stimulant to that snake,” he said.
The brothers were killed by Savoie’s African rock python after it escaped an enclosure in his apartment by travelling through a ventilation duct and dropping into the living room where they slept. Savoie’s own son, sleeping in another room, was unharmed.
A number of witnesses have said it was common to see the cover of the vent on the enclosure’s floor.
Defence lawyer Leslie Matchim told the jury in his opening statement Monday that Savoie believed the snake was too big get through the duct, so he didn’t see a need to secure the opening.
Savoie, he said, was clearly wrong.
“Being wrong isn’t necessarily criminal negligence,” Matchim said.
The lawyer reminded the jury of testimony from a volunteer at Savoie’s reptile shop downstairs from his apartment: she said Savoie told her that the snake had gotten into the ventilation pipe before, but only made it part way through.
In his testimony, Johnson said any snake enclosures for the Toronto Zoo would have a system of double doors and any openings would be securely caged. The enclosure in Savoie’s apartment had a “dryer vent” style of cover for the ventilation duct that was not secured with screws or tape, he said.
Johnson said the enclosure lacked items such as rocks and branches to stimulate the python.
“I would not say that is very conducive to the well-being of the snake,” he said.
Last week, a veterinarian who conducted the necropsy on the snake testified it appeared the snake hadn’t fed in at least 24 hours.
A pathologist who performed autopsies on the boys said they died of asphyxiation and each were covered in puncture wounds from snake bites.
Johnson said once a snake bites, it is very difficult to unlock that bite, and the large snake could have coiled around both boys at once.
“You do not get away from that anchor bite,” he said.
He responded to the earlier testimony of RCMP officers about the python’s aggressive behaviour after it was captured — hissing and lunging at the glass of the enclosure.
“A snake that responds like that is a very aggressive snake,” he said.
“It was an extreme response to human presence. This animal was dangerous.”
During cross-examination of Johnson, Matchim asked about the testimony of earlier witnesses who described the snake as being much larger in diameter than the ventilation pipe and said they were surprised that the snake could have slithered through it.
Johnson said most people exaggerate the size of snakes they’ve seen — often describing them as much larger and longer than they really are.
The court learned last week that measurements during the necropsy put the snake at 3.7 metres long and 10.8 centimetres in diameter at its thickest point.
During cross-examination, Johnson agreed that the dead snake could have measured skinnier when stretched out on the examination table.
Meanwhile, a snake expert from Florida said dead snakes have a diameter that is 10 to 25 per cent smaller than when they are alive.
Eugene Bessette is a snake farmer who owns Ophiological Services in Archer, Florida. He is the only witness being called by the defence.
His company breeds various kinds of snakes, including 7,000 to 8,000 pythons for sale each year.
Bessette testified that after raising large snakes for more than 40 years, he was “in shock and disbelief that a snake that size got through that four-inch hole, but it did.”
Outside the court, defence lawyer Mikael Bernard said Bessette’s comments go to the merits of whether a reasonable person believed the snake could escape.
The Crown will be able to cross-examine Bessette Tuesday morning.
Jean-Claude Savoie goes through the security check as he arrives at court in Campbellton, N.B., on Tuesday, Nov. 1, 2016. Savoie is on trial on a charge of criminal neglicence causing death after two young brothers, Connor and Noah Barthe, were asphyxiated by an African rock python in August 2013. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Andrew Vaughan)
Connor Barthe, 6, and Noah Barthe, 4, were found dead Monday, Aug. 5, 2013, in Campbellton, N.B. It's believe they were killed by an African rock python. Facebook/Toronto Sun/QMI Agency


Python target boys because they played with farm animals? | Canada | News | Toro
 

spaminator

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 26, 2009
39,036
3,605
113
Covering python's escape route 'common sense': Expert
THE CANADIAN PRESS
First posted: Tuesday, November 08, 2016 10:36 AM EST | Updated: Tuesday, November 08, 2016 07:40 PM EST
CAMPBELLTON, N.B. — After more than a week of testimony, the trial of a man whose African rock python escaped and killed two young New Brunswick boys came down to one question: Did his decision not to cap a ventilation pipe constitute a crime?
Both the Crown and defence presented their closing arguments Tuesday in the Court of Queen’s Bench in Campbellton.
The defence said Jean-Claude Savoie didn’t cover a ventilation pipe above his python’s enclosure not because he was careless or reckless, but because he simply didn’t believe the large snake could possibly fit through it.
Savoie pleaded not guilty to criminal negligence causing death after the python escaped an enclosure in his Campbellton apartment and killed four-year-old Noah Barthe and his six-year-old brother Connor in August 2013.
The python travelled through a ventilation duct and dropped into the living room where the boys slept. Savoie’s own son, sleeping in another room, was unharmed.
A number of witnesses have said it was common to see the cover of the vent on the enclosure’s floor.
Defence lawyer Leslie Matchim said Tuesday the snake did try to escape about a month or so before the boys were killed, but got stuck partway through the pipe, convincing Savoie and others that it could not escape that way.
“They were wrong, but not from a lack of caring,” he said.
Matchim said Savoie didn’t go out and buy the snake. The Canadian Wildlife Service asked him to take it after the snake was seized in Saint John, and Savoie was never given any money to care for the snake in the subsequent 11 years.
Savoie lived in the apartment with his three-year-old son.
“Would he put his own safety and that of his son at risk?” Matchim asked.
The boys had spent Aug. 4, 2013, petting animals and playing at a farm owned by Savoie’s father before a sleepover in Savoie’s apartment.
Matchim said the trip to the farm with the children showed Savoie was a good father and guardian and was not cavalier with their safety.
Matchim said the issue here is foreseeability.
“Does omission constitute criminal negligence?” he said.
He said Savoie didn’t cover the ventilation pipe because he didn’t think there was any chance the snake could exit through the ventilation pipe.
“There is no need to install a barrier if you’ve come to that conclusion in your mind,” he said.
Matchim said there’s no proof Savoie was being reckless.
“Accidents happen, but not everyone who causes an accident is guilty of criminal negligence causing death,” he said.
He says if the jury finds reasonable doubt, they must find Savoie not guilty.
But Crown prosecutor Pierre Roussel said Savoie had a legal duty to care for Noah and Connor Barthe when they stayed in his apartment. He was the only adult there.
“Mr. Savoie obviously failed in that duty,” Roussel said.
Roussel said snake experts Bob Johnson and Eugene Bessette both testified the first thing they would do after an attempted escape would be to block the opening.
“Mr. Savoie failed to do that,” Roussel told the jury. “That shows wanton and reckless disregard for the safety of others.”
Roussel said Savoie should have foreseen that his failure to take action could result in the snake escaping.
“By failing to take action that’s when he became negligent,” he said.
Earlier in the day, Bessette, a snake expert from Florida testified it would have been “common sense” to cover the ventilation pipe after an escape attempt.
Bessette was the only witness for the defence.
During cross-examination by Roussel, Bessette told the court he was impressed by photos of the snake’s enclosure in Savoie’s apartment, calling the locked door “very sufficient” security.
Roussel referred to earlier testimony about the snake’s escape attempt through a ventilation pipe above the enclosure, and asked what Bessette would have done if there was such an escape attempt at his snake farm.
“I would have made an attempt to rectify the situation,” Bessette said.
“You would have covered the opening?” Roussel asked. “You would cover the hole for the safety of the animal and the public?”
“That would be common sense,” Bessette said.
Judge Fred Ferguson will instruct the jurors on the law and their duties Wednesday morning before they begin their deliberations.
Noah Barthe, 4, and Connor Barthe, 6, seen with their mother Mandy Trecartin, were found dead Monday, Aug. 5, 2013, in Campbellton, N.B. It's believe they were killed by an African rock python. (Facebook/Toronto Sun/QMI Agency)

Covering python's escape route 'common sense': Expert | Canada | News | Toronto
 

spaminator

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 26, 2009
39,036
3,605
113
Jury finds python owner not guilty in deaths of New Brunswick boys
THE CANADIAN PRESS
First posted: Wednesday, November 09, 2016 08:17 PM EST | Updated: Wednesday, November 09, 2016 09:45 PM EST
CAMPBELLTON, N.B. — A jury has found a New Brunswick man not guilty of criminal negligence causing death after his African rock python escaped its enclosure and killed two young boys three years ago.
Four-year-old Noah Barthe and Connor Barthe, 6, died during a sleepover in Jean-Claude Savoie’s apartment in August 2013.
The python escaped by travelling through a ventilation duct and dropping into the living room where the boys slept. A pathologist who performed autopsies on the boys said they died of asphyxiation and each was covered in puncture wounds from snake bites.
Savoie and his relatives wept in court as the verdict was delivered Wednesday night, eight hours after the jury began its deliberations.
Savoie, 40, declined comment as he left the court, but defence lawyer Leslie Matchim said his client was relieved.
“It’s been quite a roller coaster road for him to have been implicated in this matter, investigated and at one point told that there would be no charges,” he said.
Matchim said an investigation by the RCMP and two subsequent reviews concluded that charges were not appropriate. He said he received that assurance in writing.
The lawyer said a new lead investigator was then appointed and suddenly is client found himself facing a charge.
He said Wednesday’s verdict is ultimate vindication for his client.
“This tragedy took a tremendous toll on him. He was really like family to those two victim boys and that is something that he absolutely has to carry for the rest of his life,” Matchim said.
Mandy Trecartin, the boys’ mother, showed little emotion and declined comment as she left the court Wednesday night.
Crown prosecutor Pierre Roussel said the family was disappointed with the verdict, but said it’s too soon to consider whether to appeal.
In his charge to the jury Wednesday, Judge Fred Ferguson said that the Crown must have proven “three essential ingredients” in order for them to convict Savoie of criminal negligence causing death:
- That Savoie, “as the only adult in his residence that night,” had a duty to protect the brothers, and that he failed that duty.
- That he “showed wanton and reckless disregard for the lives and safety” of the boys.
- And that his failure to take “reasonably appropriate measures to care for or protect Connor and Noah Barthe” contributed significantly to their death.
“If Crown counsel fails to prove any one of these three essential ingredients beyond a reasonable doubt, you must find Jean-Claude Savoie not-guilty of criminal negligence causing death,” the judge said.
The boys had spent the day of the sleepover petting animals and playing at a farm owned by Savoie’s father. Bob Johnson, the now-retired former curator of reptiles and amphibians at the Toronto Zoo, testified at Savoie’s trial that snakes become more aggressive when they detect possible sources of food — and an attack would have been unlikely had there been no animal smells on the boys.
“Those boys could have been a stimulant to that snake,” he said.
A number of witnesses testified during Savoie’s trial that it was common to see the cover of the vent on the enclosure’s floor, and the court heard the snake nearly escaped a matter of weeks before the boys’ death, but got stuck in the ventilation pipe.
Savoie’s lawyer told the jury in his opening statement that Savoie believed the snake was too big get through the duct, so he didn’t see a need to secure the opening.
Savoie, he said, was clearly wrong.
“Being wrong isn’t necessarily criminal negligence,” said Matchim.
In his testimony, Johnson said any snake enclosures for the Toronto Zoo would have a system of double doors and any openings would be securely caged. The enclosure in Savoie’s apartment had a “dryer vent” style of cover for the ventilation duct that was not secured with screws or tape, he said.
Johnson said the enclosure lacked items such as rocks and branches to stimulate the python.
“I would not say that is very conducive to the well-being of the snake,” he said.
A veterinarian who conducted the necropsy on the snake testified it appeared the snake hadn’t fed in at least 24 hours.
Johnson said once a snake bites, it is very difficult to unlock that bite, and the large snake could have coiled around both boys at once.
He responded to the earlier testimony of RCMP officers about the python’s aggressive behaviour after it was captured — hissing and lunging at the glass of the enclosure.
“A snake that responds like that is a very aggressive snake,” he said. “It was an extreme response to human presence. This animal was dangerous.”
Jury finds python owner not guilty in deaths of New Brunswick boys | Canada | Ne
 

spaminator

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 26, 2009
39,036
3,605
113
Mounties broke deal in python-deaths case: Lawyer
Kevin Bissett, THE CANADIAN PRESS
First posted: Thursday, November 10, 2016 12:25 PM EST | Updated: Thursday, November 10, 2016 02:08 PM EST
CAMPBELLTON, N.B. — Jean-Claude Savoie has been found not guilty of criminal negligence in the deaths of two boys killed by his escaped python in northern New Brunswick, and now his lawyer says the RCMP broke a deal not to lay a charge in the first place.
“It’s been quite a roller coaster road for him to have been implicated in this matter, investigated and at one point told that there would be no charges,” Leslie Matchim said.
Matchim said an investigation by New Brunswick RCMP concluded no charge was warranted.
“The investigation does not support an offence of causing death by criminal negligence,” reads a report signed by the lead investigator and the head of the major crime unit on Nov. 22, 2013.
That investigation ended three months after Savoie’s African rock python slithered through an uncovered ventilation duct to escape from its enclosure and kill four-year-old Noah Barthe and his six-year-old brother Connor, who were attending a sleepover in Savoie’s Campbellton apartment.
The file was then subjected to an external review by major crime investigators in Halifax, and they agreed with the initial finding that charges were not warranted.
According to a court document released Thursday, the original investigator sought to have Savoie answer some lingering questions that police had about the morning the dead boys were discovered.
Matchim said they’d agree if they got a guarantee in writing that no charge would be laid.
“And in fact we received that very thing — a written indication, clearly by the RCMP, that these are the questions and should you provide Mr. Savoie’s answers, he will not be charged.”
However on Feb. 5, 2014, RCMP Inspector Marc Bertrand was assigned to review the investigation and decided a charge should be laid.
“I hope it bears more scrutiny by someone that the RCMP would give a written guarantee to somebody in exchange for breaking their constitutional right to remain silent that they would not be charged,” Matchim said.
Matchim sought a stay of proceedings earlier this year, but was denied.
There had been a publication ban on the nature of that hearing and the decision until it was unsealed by Judge Fred Ferguson Thursday.
According to the decision, Bertrand said the previous officer did not have right to give a guarantee of no charges.
“If what Cpl. Deveau did in giving a written statement to counsel for Mr. Savoie that no criminal charge would be laid amounted to a granting of immunity, it was without the consent of his superiors and beyond his authority as that could only be authorized by the attorney general of New Brunswick,” Bertrand wrote in an affidavit.
The trial was allowed to proceed, but without the use of Savoie’s answers to the RCMP questions.
The jury returned a verdict of not guilty Wednesday night after deliberating much of the day.
Matchim said the verdict is the ultimate vindication and said Savoie is relieved.
Mounties broke deal in python-deaths case: Lawyer | Canada | News | Toronto Sun