One reason for Centralized Authority

Jo Canadian

Council Member
Mar 15, 2005
PEI...for now
:D Whilest bored at work I've been pouring over a very interesting book, it's more or less an anthropoligical view on the development and evolution of societies and why some have developed at the rate they did. :scratch: I'm not too sure if this could go in the History thread or the book thread or not, but I thought I'd share this one paragraph on why there's a need for centralized authority (this one's for all you anarchists)

In a band of 20 people where everyone is closley related to everyone else, people related simultaneously to both quarreling parties step in to mediate quarrels. In a tribe of 100 to 200 people, many people are still close relatives and everyone at least knows everybody else by name, mutual relatives and mutual friends mediate the quarrel. But once the threshold of "several hundred," below which everyone can know everyone else, has been crossed, increasing numbers of dyads become pairs of unrelated strangers. when strangers fight, few people present will be friends or relatives of both combatants, with self interest in stopping the fight. Instead many onlookers will be friends or relatives of only one combatant and will side with that person, escalating the two person fight into a general brawl. Hence a large society that continues to leave conflict resolution to all of its members is guaranteed to blow up. That factor alone would explain why societies of thousands can exist only if they develop centralized authority to monopolize force and resolve conflicts.

Guns, Germs, and Steel
By Jared Diamond


Hall of Fame Member
Oct 19, 2004
Ottawa, ON
Decentralization doesn't have to mean no federal authority whatsoever.

Certainly the fed's ought to keep the police and military, currency, things like that.

But alot of other things could easily be decentralized, not at the provincial level, but even at the local level.

And this comming from a world federalist!? Talk about 'for every action there is an equal and opposite reaction'.