Louis Riel, Hound or Hero?

CDNBear

Custom Troll
Sep 24, 2006
43,839
207
63
Ontario
I think what we are seeing is the creation of a Metis hero out of a nutcase who's only solution was armed insurrection

Highlighting contributions to Canadian society is laudable. Where Riel is concerned, however, that promotion must be limited to the facts about his troubled, chequered life. Riel, who claimed to be Metis on the basis of having one-tenth aboriginal blood, assumed the role of Metis leader in western Canada. His psychosis manifested itself in the conviction that he was a great religious leader and the spiritual hero of the people of Rupert's Land. The problem was that Metis not of French and Indian descent did not share his vision, any more than did the English-speaking settlers or most aboriginal persons. In fact, the inhabitants of the region simply did not want change through violence.

In short, Riel did not have the full support of his people, let alone Rupert's Land that he needed to create his own territory. Instead, he used arms and force, those ancient non-democratic methods, resulting in death and terror. He was accordingly confronted by force for his crimes, lost and hung.

Read the full article:
Untitled Document
:lol:

An unsupported article written by an MP and a "Canadian Alliance" MP at that!!!? You've got to be kidding? Even the wording in the article is telling to its factual integrity. Or lack thereof.
The aboriginals of Canada never accepted the Metis so really they are not Indians so Louis Riel was a criminal
I'm willing to bet you haven't a clue as to why they weren't accepted... Please by all means, elaborate.
 
Last edited:

Liberalman

Senate Member
Mar 18, 2007
5,623
36
48
Toronto
:lol:

An unsupported article written by an MP? You've got to be kidding? Even the wording in the article is telling to its factual integrity. Or lack thereof.
I'm willing to bet you haven't a clue as to why they weren't accepted... Please by all means, elaborate.

Oh do tell why weren't they accepted but the fact remains is they still are not accepted
 

CDNBear

Custom Troll
Sep 24, 2006
43,839
207
63
Ontario
Oh do tell why weren't they accepted but the fact remains is they still are not accepted
They're not accepted by some, but certainly not for the reasons as were outlined in the article juan supplied, nor for the reasons of Riel's actions.

Other then that, you can either chose to educate yourself, or remain ignorant. Google is your friend. It may not be the end all of educational tools, but you can certainly get the gist of it, if you truly wish to broaden your mind.
 

The Old Medic

Council Member
May 16, 2010
1,330
2
38
The World
As a Métis, I see him a bit differently. He was in no way a "vilain", he was fighting to see that his people were not discriminated against, nor their property confiscated by the new government. My family lost three farms, farms they had been granted by the Hudson's Bay Company, taken by the new provincial government of Manitoba. My great grandmother was issued "Manitoba Script, as were other family members. It was utterly worthless.

He tried to redress the grievances of his people. the response of the government was to use force against him. he paid the ultimate price for his beliefs. Even the Federal Government now recognizes that he was much more of a hero, than a "villain".
 

Liberalman

Senate Member
Mar 18, 2007
5,623
36
48
Toronto
Riel got quite a decent statue in Winnipeg. I can see why he might be some kind of hero to some people but Riel's actions opposed John A. MacDonald's plan to build a railroad across the country and nothing was going to stop that railroad.

The railroad united the country.

I read somewhere that McDonald had to build it because of his fears of losing the province of British Columbia to the Americans
 

Bar Sinister

Executive Branch Member
Jan 17, 2010
8,252
19
38
Edmonton
The railroad united the country.

I read somewhere that McDonald had to build it because of his fears of losing the province of British Columbia to the Americans

Actually the promise Canada made to BC was to pay off the colony's debt and built a road to connect it to the rest of Canada. It was decided that a railroad made more sense than a mere road and Canada had the example of the US which had just finished building the Union Pacific.