Canadian Idol Fans Watching American Idol
- Thread starter ross 1
- Start date
What was the winner's song that year? All I Ever Wanted?
I liked those pictures of Kris and Katie. I hate seeing a guy walking ahead while the girl trails him, though. I hope that was just a momentary thing! You know what I mean? The high school guy with his girlfriend at the mall, and she's walking behind him four or five paces.
I liked those pictures of Kris and Katie. I hate seeing a guy walking ahead while the girl trails him, though. I hope that was just a momentary thing! You know what I mean? The high school guy with his girlfriend at the mall, and she's walking behind him four or five paces.
Okay, now you made me google him.
Jaydee drove me nuts, but the kid does have a good voice.
YouTube - Jaydee Bixby Boy inside The man.MOD
It's a Tom Cochrane cover - The original. Red Rider was so good.
When bad videos happen to good songs.
This would be a good song for Lee come to think of it.
Jaydee drove me nuts, but the kid does have a good voice.
YouTube - Jaydee Bixby Boy inside The man.MOD
It's a Tom Cochrane cover - The original. Red Rider was so good.
When bad videos happen to good songs.
This would be a good song for Lee come to think of it.
Last edited:
I agree with MJ's assessment of Siobhan:
Siobhan Magnus – “Paint it Black”
...Siobhan is sitting on the stairs, lit up red. She’s all in black. Wow, she looks beautiful. Hm. She’s slightly underpitch all the way through. I’m not sure I like this arrangement. She gets kind of screamy at the end. Oh that last note before the end was not good. She’s trying too hard. You know I really really want to like Siobhan. I really do. On paper I like her, but I’ve got mixed feelings about her performances. She’s unique, for sure, but she’s all over the place. Randy says, “That was hot.” Ellen says, “I love the way you look tonight,” Kara says, “The best interpretation tonight, most interesting.” Siobhan reminds Kara of Adam Lambert. Adam had better control of his vocals (mostly) Simon says, “It was the standout performance of the night. Now I see the development from the middle to the end. There’s a lot of people who are going to hate that…better than being boring.” Wow. The judges totally overpraised that performance. I highly suggest they go home and watch that back on TV.
Siobhan Magnus – “Paint it Black”
...Siobhan is sitting on the stairs, lit up red. She’s all in black. Wow, she looks beautiful. Hm. She’s slightly underpitch all the way through. I’m not sure I like this arrangement. She gets kind of screamy at the end. Oh that last note before the end was not good. She’s trying too hard. You know I really really want to like Siobhan. I really do. On paper I like her, but I’ve got mixed feelings about her performances. She’s unique, for sure, but she’s all over the place. Randy says, “That was hot.” Ellen says, “I love the way you look tonight,” Kara says, “The best interpretation tonight, most interesting.” Siobhan reminds Kara of Adam Lambert. Adam had better control of his vocals (mostly) Simon says, “It was the standout performance of the night. Now I see the development from the middle to the end. There’s a lot of people who are going to hate that…better than being boring.” Wow. The judges totally overpraised that performance. I highly suggest they go home and watch that back on TV.
Last edited:
I also have to agree about Tim. (Shoot me. lol):
Tim Urban – “Under My Thumb”
...The sway bots are singing and clapping along. WTF. Has Tim really listened to the lyrics of this song? Is he f*cking serious with this jaunty reggae arrangement of the song? The lyrics are sinister. This might be one of the most mean-spirited Stones songs ever. It’s meant to be performed with edge. Randy is laughing, “Wow, I didn’t get that dude. It was really bizarre. It was weird for me.” Ellen says, “I felt like I was at a resort and listening to someone sing. Nothing wrong with it, it just didn’t work” (Oh, there was a lot wrong with that) Kara says, “I got to applaud you for doing something so different with the song…you made it your own.” Simon says, “I have to applaud you for doing something different…it didn’t work. Rolling Stones fans would be turning the TVs off. It was a crazy decision.” Tim says he knew it was going to be a huge risk. I found a song I could have some fun with. Dear GOD. PLEASE GO AWAY.
Tim Urban – “Under My Thumb”
...The sway bots are singing and clapping along. WTF. Has Tim really listened to the lyrics of this song? Is he f*cking serious with this jaunty reggae arrangement of the song? The lyrics are sinister. This might be one of the most mean-spirited Stones songs ever. It’s meant to be performed with edge. Randy is laughing, “Wow, I didn’t get that dude. It was really bizarre. It was weird for me.” Ellen says, “I felt like I was at a resort and listening to someone sing. Nothing wrong with it, it just didn’t work” (Oh, there was a lot wrong with that) Kara says, “I got to applaud you for doing something so different with the song…you made it your own.” Simon says, “I have to applaud you for doing something different…it didn’t work. Rolling Stones fans would be turning the TVs off. It was a crazy decision.” Tim says he knew it was going to be a huge risk. I found a song I could have some fun with. Dear GOD. PLEASE GO AWAY.
Last edited:
I'm just kidding I'm still here. But, man, Jaydee? I still have residual dislike for that kid and it's been YEARS!
LMAO. To console you. My current play count on that song is 1.
I think I bought it because it was the first time they released both songs to itunes. At least that I recall.
Oh, he was super annoying. And sang Elvis like every other song which didn't help, lol.
I've been voting for Andrew. I didn't think about it, he was just the one I started voting for. I'm trying to do what my unconscious is telling me. I'll vote for some others, too.
Do I need to vote for Crystal? What if no one votes for her because they think she's covered, and she's voted off?
I'll vote for some others, too. Do I need to vote for Crystal? What if no one votes for her because they think she's covered, and she's voted off?
Really interesting interview with David:
Catching up with David Cook | Idol Tracker | Los Angeles Times
ETA: Well, I hadn't squeed at the possibility of a single in April, so I had to do it: SQUUEEEE!
Catching up with David Cook | Idol Tracker | Los Angeles Times
ETA: Well, I hadn't squeed at the possibility of a single in April, so I had to do it: SQUUEEEE!
Last edited: