No public secular education in Morinville AB

TenPenny

Hall of Fame Member
Jun 9, 2004
17,467
139
63
Location, Location
and I asked her to be specific. I want to know WHAT is being taught outside of religion classes that is objectionable.


I'd also like to point out for the mentally challenged. One can NOT receive first communion, first confession, or confirmation if one is NOT baptized into the Catholic Faith...period. Therefore one who is NOT Catholic can NOT be forced to receive communion.

From the Globe and Mail:

The district is clear that religion in its schools isn’t isolated to one class a day. Students pray before lunch and snacks, sing songs about Jesus and move through classrooms adorned with doves, crosses and other religious symbols.
In a letter posted on its website board officials write: “Through faith-based encounters with learning, our students come to understand a journey of life which extends from knowing the Christ within, to acting as Christ for others.”
 

abmom

New Member
Apr 19, 2007
18
0
1
No, all 4 schools in Morinville are PUBLIC. We have no separate schools in Morinville. All 4 public schools are run by a Catholic school board. That is the problem. We cannot create a secular public school as we already have a public school, 4 public schools in fact.

Sturgeon School Division (public non faith based)cannot service Morinville, even though their head office is located right in the middle of town, because we already have a public school board. They service communities surrounding Morinville. The closest public non faith based school is Namao which is a 40 mins bus ride, shared with high school students. Now, as a "non resident" of that school, one cannot vote for school trustees, cannot be a school trustee, and you are not guaranteed a seat.

We cannot create a secular separate school board as separate schools must be denominational, either Protestant or Catholic.

There is the latest article: In an Alberta town, parents fight for a secular education - The Globe and Mail

www.morinvilleparentdelegation.webs.com

In a city or municipality with a two school system your taxes go to the school of your choice or it goes public by default.

It's not hard to figure out who the home owners are in this thread or who pays attention where their municipal taxes go


In Alberta, public schools and separate schools (Protestant and Catholic) are publicly funded. Everyone's taxes go into one pot, then gets distributed. One does not get to chose.
 

gerryh

Time Out
Nov 21, 2004
25,756
295
83
In Alberta, public schools and separate schools (Protestant and Catholic) are publicly funded. Everyone's taxes go into one pot, then gets distributed. One does not get to chose.


wrong, but no surprise.


Still waiting for you to answer my question.
 

abmom

New Member
Apr 19, 2007
18
0
1
From the Globe and Mail:

What is questionable is the fact that one religion is permeated within the entire curriculum in every teachable moment. The constant reference to one religion in a public school, in exclusion to all other religions. They teach it as fact, not as a religion.

Oh this is easy, defund the religious schools and use that money to start a secular public school. If the religious schools want to continue operation they can ask god for the money.

And this is why the government is relunctant to get involved. Politicians are afraid they will lose many of the Catholic voters.

and I asked her to be specific. I want to know WHAT is being taught outside of religion classes that is objectionable.


I'd also like to point out for the mentally challenged. One can NOT receive first communion, first confession, or confirmation if one is NOT baptized into the Catholic Faith...period. Therefore one who is NOT Catholic can NOT be forced to receive communion.

It is the constant reference to religion. When they have assemblies, they open the bible and start referencing, they watch Veggies Tales etc. In mornings, they have the opening prayer, at recess and lunch. When they do crafts, it's about the wonders of God, they sing songs about it, when they do puzzles it's a religious theme, etc. Everything is faith based-and only one faith. There is no mention of any other religions in the world.

Students who are not in religious studies take Health. Even in Health, they watch Veggie Tales.

This is what a separate school should be....not a public school. IMO

Um... no, other way around, according to what you've said. There's nothing but separate schools in Morinville , there's no public school. Hard to know what's really going on based on what you posted, but it seems pretty obvious to me that if 70% of the people in the district aren't Catholic, what's to prevent them from setting up a public school board and a public school? Asking the separate school board to do it for them is just dumb, of course it'll refuse, the non-Catholics need to take matters into their own hands instead of asking people with no interest in what they want to do it for them. Besides, my experience with the separate schools where I live suggests it's not very hard to counter the religious instruction kids get in the separate school system, if that's what you want to do, it's not a very forceful indoctrination. When they're around 13 or 14, just hand them Bertrand Russell's book Why I Am Not A Christian. and be prepared to talk to them about what he says.

No, we only have public schools...all run by a Catholic school board. We have no separate schools in town. We cannot create a secular public school as we already have public schools. We cannot create a secular separate school as they must be faith based.
 

gerryh

Time Out
Nov 21, 2004
25,756
295
83
Well then, I guess you're gonna have to get your politicians do something for ya's. Having a Catholic School change to become non sectarian is not the answer though. Build your own schools and fill em.
 

TenPenny

Hall of Fame Member
Jun 9, 2004
17,467
139
63
Location, Location
Well then, I guess you're gonna have to get your politicians do something for ya's. Having a Catholic School change to become non sectarian is not the answer though. Build your own schools and fill em.

That's a good idea. I wonder why nobody thought of that.