Filthy French and awful Arabs...the un-PC travel guide of a Victorian lady

Blackleaf

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 9, 2004
48,430
1,668
113
In the days when Britain was the richest and most powerful country in the world, the Top Dog, and when it was the head of the largest empire the world had ever known, a Victorian British lady (who probably only step foot abroad into the lands of "savages" only once in her life) wrote travel books about foreign lands - and most of these places she hated and looked down on.


It gives a glimpse of the time when Victorian Britain was about to reach its imperial zenith as the world's superpower and when the British people looked down with pity on people - "savages" - from abroad as though they weren't lucky enough to be born British....

The mad world of Mrs Mortimer - the un-PC travel guides of a Victorian lady

by RICHARD PENDLEBURY
19th July 2007
Daily Mail


Politically incorrect: The 19th-century British writer Favell Mortimer (1802-1878 ) hated most foreigners - and wasn't afraid to let us know



Filthy French, lawless Aussies and awful Arabs...the eye-poppingly un-PC travel guides of a Victorian lady...

She really despised Mexicans.

The Spanish were also pretty bad. The Portuguese were like the Spanish but worse, and clumsy to boot.

And as for the Egyptians, they were simply beyond the pale.

The French could also do with a good wash and the Russians were absolutely filthy, though that didn't save them from being torn apart by wolves on a daily basis.

Gambling-stricken San Francisco was one of the planet's most wicked cities, while Rome ran it close, on account of the number of priests.

Idleness, alcohol, Islam and Roman Catholicism, though not necessarily in that order, were the "evils" found in heathen lands which most exercised the mind of Favell Lee Mortimer.

If she were alive and writing today, the remarkable Mrs Mortimer and her jaw-dropping views on the world would undoubtedly fall foul of any number of laws. Politically correct, she was not.

Nor a loss to the diplomatic service.

But 150 years ago, this parson's wife from Shropshire was the million-selling author of travel guides which advised England's youth on the perils and pitfalls awaiting them if they ever dared to leave this sceptred isle.

One can only marvel at the effect they must have had on Victorian would-be travellers.

Who, for example, would have been greatly encouraged to venture eastwards to Poland, where Mrs Mortimer vouch-safed "you may go a great way without seeing anything pretty" and the people "speak so loud they almost scream - and they are proud of this".

Even further east were the Russians, who were 'generally not to be trusted' and ran at great speed through the streets to avoid freezing to death.

Now, Mrs Mortimer's outrageous and gloriously politically incorrect vignettes have been collected in one entertaining volume that will be published later this year.

They serve as a fascinating snapshot of an age when, as Great Britain neared the zenith of its imperial powers, it was the national mindset that foreigners were to be pitied for the misfortune of not being British.

Pity, though, does not quite do justice to Mrs Mortimer's unrestrained disappointment in their myriad weaknesses, nor accurately describe her often random and hair-raising prejudices, backed by questionable anecdotal proof.

But if Mrs Mortimer's opinions are surprising, their provenance is even more so. For the truth is that Mrs Mortimer was no prototype Michael Palin.

She had never paddled up the Amazon, sailed the Atlantic to be robbed by Mexicans, priggishly tut-tutted in the convict-filled streets of "very wicked" Sydney, nor even clapped eyes on the Mediterranean shore along which, she asserted, the filthy and indolent Latin races lived their useless lives.

In fact, the woman who presented to her thousands of English readers this prism through which they saw the world had only stepped across the nation's borders once in her entire life.

That was a family jaunt to Brussels and Paris as a teenager.

So who was this extraordinary woman, and how had her splenetic view of the world been shaped?

Born Favell Bevan in 1802 in London, the future writer was the daughter of one of the cofounders of Barclays Bank. She was brought up a Quaker but, as a young woman, converted to the Evangelical branch of Christianity. Aged 39, she married a Shropshire clergyman called
Mortimer, but it was an unhappy union which lasted nine years until his death.

Perhaps by way of catharsis, Mrs Mortimer began to write about a world she had hardly seen, at a time when continental Europe was in the grip of political turmoil.

Her first volume, The Countries Of Europe Described, appeared in 1849 and her detestation of the Church of Rome was already quite clear.

Italy, she described as being "full of fine houses and palaces, empty and going to decay - but that is not the worst part - the people are ignorant and wicked. Their religion is Roman Catholic".

But it was only in her later books that Mrs Mortimer really hit her venomous stride.

By 1857, she had completed her series spanning the globe; she subsequently retired to Norfolk, where she died at the age of 76.

Taken as a whole, her "travelogues" perhaps tell us more about Mrs Mortimer than they do about 19th-century humankind.

Let us then take a whistlestop tour around her weird, worrying and largely imaginary world of foreigners. She is largely well-disposed towards north European, Protestant countries, or at least restrained in her abuse.

Icelanders are dull but honest, though their churches stink of fish to "almost make you sick".

She admires much that is German, save the ladies' reading of frivolous fiction.

"They are not fond of reading useful books. When they read, it is novels about people who have never lived. It would be better to read nothing."

On approaching the Middle East, Mrs Mortimer really sharpens her critical knife.

"The worst quality in any character is hypocrisy, and this is to be found in the Egyptian," she declares.

"It is a rare quality in Egypt to speak the truth."

In Bethlehem, she describes the statues of Mary and white crosses offered to visitors, before delivering the inevitable withering put-down: "They are very pretty. But they are idols. And God hates idols."

In Arabia, there are three evils: locusts, burning winds and want of water. "But there is one still greater - the religion of Mohammed."

Turkey is no better. She declares: "How dreadful it would be if our churches should ever be turned into mosques!'"

The neighbouring Kurds are the "fiercest people in Asia... The reason why the Armenians live in holes in the ground is because they hope the Kurds will not find out where they are".

Then she turns her gaze on China.

"We must allow that the Chinese are very clever," she admits, before describing them as "very selfish and unfeeling".

Mrs Mortimer's forays into the farthest reaches of the known world now seem unabashedly racist, though they are sometimes touched with pity for the suffering she describes there.

She calls for more missionaries to be sent to convert the Maoris of New Zealand - and quickly, because "Catholic priests are hastening".

What, though, of the world that she could see from her writing desk? This passage at least rings very true. "What is the character of the English?" she writes.

"They are not very pleasant in company, because they do not like strangers... They like best being at home, and this is right. They are very much afraid of being cheated; therefore they are careful and prudent, and slow to trust people 'til they know them.

"They are cold in their manners, yet they will often do kind actions. They are too fond of money, as well as of good eating and drinking. They are often in low spirits, and are apt to grumble, and to wish they are richer than they are, and to speak against the rulers of the land.

"Yet they might be the happiest people in the world, for there is no country in which there are so many Bibles."

Save for the last sentence, have we really changed?
----------------------

The Clumsiest People In Europe: Or Mrs Mortimer's Bad Tempered Guide To The World, edited by Todd Pruzan, is published by Random House Books at £9.99.

dailymail.co.uk
 
Last edited:

gopher

Hall of Fame Member
Jun 26, 2005
21,513
65
48
Minnesota: Gopher State
"What is the character of the English?"

Invading the Indian subcontinent, killing innocent people, and then invading China and spreading opium.

No wonder King George isn't well thought of around here.
 

Phil B

Electoral Member
Mar 17, 2007
333
10
18
Brighton,UK
"What is the character of the English?"

Invading the Indian subcontinent, killing innocent people, and then invading China and spreading opium.

No wonder King George isn't well thought of around here.

Ever heard the phrase "stuck record"

People would pay far more attention to your ramblings if they were not quite so openly biased - you could for example point many other interesting things as well, for example historically the roman invasion and subjugation of Jews in Judea, most of Europe and a large portion of north Africa, the muslim invasion of Jewish Judea, maybe the moorish invasion of spain, perhaps even the viking plunderings of England and a large portion of Northern Europe, not forgetting how different the world may have been if the Ottoman Empire hadn't backed the losing side in the first world war - unfortunately these fantastic historical tales fail to interest you enough to divert you away from your obsession with all things English and American.
 
Last edited:

gopher

Hall of Fame Member
Jun 26, 2005
21,513
65
48
Minnesota: Gopher State
Phil B said:
Ever heard the phrase "stuck record"

People would pay far more attention to your ramblings .


That's a horesh*t reply.

Since when did any of those other societies praise themselves with high falluttin' sh*t about Victorian refinement and other self absorbed nonsense?

The French certainly have their faults and I have posted enough times here my objections to their invasions of Morocco, Tunisia, and Vietnam. Like the British they felt it was their God given right to invade and rape every land they could get their hands on. But nobody in France today praises their country for past mistakes. On the Guardian web site where I post quite often nobody does the same when discussing Queen Victoria's racist invasions and murders. And that is also true for the USA's invasions of foreign lands as well.

If you are smart, you would do the same.
 

Phil B

Electoral Member
Mar 17, 2007
333
10
18
Brighton,UK
That's a horesh*t reply.

Since when did any of those other societies praise themselves with high falluttin' sh*t about Victorian refinement and other self absorbed nonsense?

Every single one of those empires/cultures considered themselves superior to others.
 
Last edited:

gopher

Hall of Fame Member
Jun 26, 2005
21,513
65
48
Minnesota: Gopher State
Big sh*t.

And like all warmongering empires, they all declined as did the British empire. Soon enough the same thing will happen to Washington DC's plan of world conquest.
 

karrie

OogedyBoogedy
Jan 6, 2007
27,780
285
83
bliss
LOL. This is totally what you'd get if you got almost any one of my great grandparents to write a travel guide. Fear, racism, and religious intolerance. An era of tribalism, where only your own culture was safe or worthwhile. It's neat to read it and see how far we've come, while still letting all those same old fears lurk in our subconscience.