Man Goes Without Food or Drink for Seven Decades


SirJosephPorter
#1
There is a Yogi in India who claims that he has gone without food or water for seven decades. Now, at first glance there may be nothing to it. Many people make all kinds of claims; most of them tend to be exaggeration or outright phony.

However, Indian doctors decided to test his claim. The put him in a hospital for two weeks and observed him with round the clock vigilance. He was under constant surveillance from a team of 30 medics equipped with cameras and closed circuit television.

For two weeks he did not eat or drink anything. Nor did he go to the toilet (of course). The doctors hope that the findings, set to be released in greater detail in several months, could help soldiers survive without food and drink, assist astronauts or even save the lives of people trapped in natural disasters.

So, how does he do it (and now there is no reason to doubt his claim that he has spent seven decades without food or drink)? We don’t know. There is still so much about human body that is unknown. Where does he get the energy, from sunlight?

During the 15-day observation, which ended on Thursday, the doctors took scans of Jani's organs, brain, and blood vessels, as well as doing tests on his heart, lungs and memory capacity.

"The reports were all in the pre-determined safety range through the observation period," Shah told reporters at a press conference last week.

--

Anyway, he has gone back to his village and to his prayers and meditation.
 
bill barilko
#2
Quote:

So, how does he do it

.......prayers and meditation
 
Ron in Regina
#3
I can see (& believe) this, as long as the guy died in 1940.
 
lone wolf
#4
Yogi ... and no pickinick baskets?
 
Liberalman
#5
BooBoo says Yogi is smarter than the average?
 
Bar Sinister
Avatar
#6
I don't see a problem with a simple magician's trick. It is not more baffling than making an airplane disappear. Most skilled magicians could duplicate the feat.
 
SirJosephPorter
#7
Quote: Originally Posted by Bar SinisterView Post

I don't see a problem with a simple magician's trick. It is not more baffling than making an airplane disappear. Most skilled magicians could duplicate the feat.

There is no magic trick here, he was under surveillance 24/7. We are not talking of levitation trick here, done with wires. There was only the Yogi on a hospital bed and nothing else. He was not carrying a whole bunch of equipment with him (as magician would during magic experiments).

And indeed, can any magician live without going to bathroom for 14 days? From the article, I understand the results will soon be published in scientific journals. They don’t publish magic experiments in scientific journals.

Indeed, I would like to see a magician perform the trick of going without food or drink for 14 days (and without going to bathroom for 14 days).

The fact is, there is still plenty about the workings of human body, about its physiology that we don’t understand.
 
JLM
#8
That is just one of thousands of mysteries to man yet unsolved.
 
Dexter Sinister
#9
Quote: Originally Posted by SirJosephPorterView Post

So, how does he do it... ?

--
 
CDNBear
#10
Quote: Originally Posted by Dexter SinisterView Post

--

Leave it to you, to shed light on those little mysteries...
 
TenPenny
Avatar
#11
How does he do it?

Easy. First of all, he's not white. Second, he's not a Christian. Therefore, anything reported about him is, quite definitely, true and verifiable.

Now, if he were a Christian, this would obviously be some fakery dreamed up the the Republican Right Wing Christian Extremists.

But it's not, so it is therefore true and real.
 
DaSleeper
#12
I wonder if his wife and son said it was possible
 
SirJosephPorter
#13
Quote: Originally Posted by Dexter SinisterView Post

--

Possibly. They have said the results will be published in scientific journals, we will see if they do that. If they don't and only report it on internet blogs, then of course it is fraud.
 
karrie
Avatar
#14
My first assumption was, "... that he knows of." Knowing people who sleep eat, I would have simply assumed, even if he was being honest, that was what was going on.
 
darkbeaver
Avatar
#15
Quote: Originally Posted by SirJosephPorterView Post

Possibly. They have said the results will be published in scientific journals, we will see if they do that. If they don't and only report it on internet blogs, then of course it is fraud.

Scientific journals include plenty of fraud. There isn't any human institution yet that can foil determined human ingenuity, especially the fraudulent variety.
 
petros
#16
Does he fart?
 
SirJosephPorter
#17
Quote: Originally Posted by darkbeaverView Post

Scientific journals include plenty of fraud. There isn't any human institution yet that can foil determined human ingenuity, especially the fraudulent variety.

Sure it does. However, when something goes against common sense (like this does), I don't see any reputable scientific journal publishing it without ample documentation, without getting it refereed from skeptics of the first order. Let them publish in a reputable journal such as Nature or Science and I am sold.
 
lone wolf
#18
Whichever be thine fertilizer....
 
Bar Sinister
Avatar
#19
Quote: Originally Posted by SirJosephPorterView Post

There is no magic trick here, he was under surveillance 24/7. We are not talking of levitation trick here, done with wires. There was only the Yogi on a hospital bed and nothing else. He was not carrying a whole bunch of equipment with him (as magician would during magic experiments).

And indeed, can any magician live without going to bathroom for 14 days? From the article, I understand the results will soon be published in scientific journals. They don’t publish magic experiments in scientific journals.

Indeed, I would like to see a magician perform the trick of going without food or drink for 14 days (and without going to bathroom for 14 days).

The fact is, there is still plenty about the workings of human body, about its physiology that we don’t understand.

Actually in tests of so called psychics in the US, scientists were shown to be remarkably easy to deceive. One of the main reasons for this what that the scientists in question were incredibly trusting. It apparently did not occur to them that the people they were supposedly observing would actually cheat to obtain the desired results.

Let me test this swami. I'd put him in an airtight vault with two weeks supply of air and leave him there. However, I would first check certain body cavities to make sure he did not have an intestine full of food concentrates and water. This case speaks more closely to the gullibility and sloppiness of the observers more than anything else.
 
JLM
Avatar
#20
This is where religion comes into play, he has a pact for osmosis with God.
 
The Old Medic
#21
This is neither true, nor is it possible. No human being could survive without any food or liquid. If you believe this actually happened, you are the most gullible person around. I have some land in S. Florida that you would find astonishing. It has this fountain, and if you drink from it, you never age. Contact me privately, and send money to the following e-mail address: -------
 

Similar Threads

16
Biofuels = higher food costs/less food
by Nuggler | Jul 6th, 2008
3
Pet food probe turns to human food supply
by CBC News | May 6th, 2007
1
Continuous Warfare for Decades to Come
by jjw1965 | Oct 10th, 2005
no new posts