Canadians are skewing the national obesity stats



Canadians are miscalculating their weight and height, resulting in faulty national statistics.
Two different studies looked at the effects of data collected through Statistics Canada's Canadian Community Health Survey (CCHS) and National Population Health Survey (NPHS). The studies relied heavily on self-reported weight and height information by respondents in order to estimate body mass index (BMI). The information was then used by StatsCan determine national obesity rates.
"People tend to over-report their height and under-estimate their weight and that results in huge problems," Ian Janssen, Queen's University obesity expert told Canada AM.
As people get older, the reporting errors tend to increase as well.
StatsCan discovered that men who responded to the 2005 CCHS survey tended to over-estimate their height by roughly one centimetre and women by about half that much.
Weight miscalculations were more pronounced. Women tended to under-report their weight by about 2.5 kilograms on average, and men by 1.8 kilograms. The study found the heavier the person, the more they under-reported.

Quote has been trimmed
Self reporting is notoriously unreliable when it comes to nutrition, exercise and weight. It's unfortunate that so many people struggle with this issue and it will cost them enormously in the future. My dad's just been diagnosed as diabetic. He's overweight and has been for years. Add that to a family history of diabetes and his diagnosis didn't come as a complete shock. The good thing is it seems to have served as a bit of a wakeup call. He doesn't want to wind up an amputee like his father. He and my mom have started eating much better and exercising more. It doesn't take a huge weight loss to make a difference either. His doctor was thrilled at a 5% loss. Hopefully he will be able to continue to manage it through diet for a while and not have to go to insulin.

Similar Threads

Stats Can Gun Facts.
by Colpy | Jul 3rd, 2008
Gender Skewing
by karrie | Apr 23rd, 2008
Stats on Canadians working in the U.S.
by tallen | Jan 5th, 2006
no new posts