while some of the thing you rate the docs on makes sense, others are just ridiculous... like punctuality. I'm sorry, but half the time in this neck of the woods, if your doc is late its because they got called into the hospital for something. it happens all the time when things get too busy, or their patients take a turn for the worse. so 'jo blo' gets pissed off because his health care wasn't given priority and writes a bad review, but it doesn't give the doc a chance to explain.
but all in all, i think it's good to have a rating system. i've had some really ****ty docs. especially during the onset of my fibromyalgia. i was fed all sorts of bull**** about why i was in so much pain. everything from false diagnosis of depression, to telling me that it was just a weight issue (i was roughly 20lbs overweight at the time, not enough to cause severe pain). it hit the point where i was not allowed to seek anymore help from the docs in my town until i let them put me on anti-depressants, because they did not believe that i was a happy person aside from the pain. i ended up playing guinea pig just to get a diagnosis, and wound up suicidal from the meds. turns out, if you're not depressed, antidepressants have the totally opposite effect.
it wasn't until i moved here that i found a doc who was willing to discuss physio and natural options (and didn't think i'm just a head case). she's very hesitant to prescribe meds (especially since fibro tends to make you react the wrong way to meds, sleeping pills will keep you awake that sort of thing), and she's very thorough about making sure what a problem is before proceeding, not forming an opinion and charging ahead with no proof like my past docs.
all that being said, I still don't think I'd write a review for any of them, or pay any attention to anyone else's opinion about what makes a good doc. my opinion is the one that matters, and it really only matters to me
) This is one of my pet peeves, I lecture my friends all the time. 