Police, union stand behind officer appearing to punch woman in video
By David Larkins, Winnipeg Sun
First posted: Monday, September 18, 2017 07:01 PM EDT | Updated: Monday, September 18, 2017 07:53 PM EDT
The Winnipeg Police Service and the union that represents its members are standing behind the actions of an officer who appears to punch a woman in a video obtained by the Winnipeg Sun.
In the video, two women are in a shoving match in the middle of Manitoba Avenue when one WPS officer walks over to break them up. While the three are engaged in a skirmish, a woman is thrown to the ground – although it’s unclear by whom – while a second woman appears to deliver a punch to the fallen woman. At that point the officer swings his right hand and connects with the head of the second woman.
A number of observers then converge on the officer and one can be heard yelling “Are you serious?” in response to the officer’s swing. The woman who was hit by the officer appears to attempt to retaliate while friends try to push her away. Twenty-seven seconds into the 54-second clip, the officer aggressively pushes the woman away, possibly even slapping her, while she flails her arms in his direction. As she is being pulled away by friends, the woman’s wrist is being held by the officer, who then charges towards her, puts her in a headlock and forcefully takes her to the ground. A second officer, who observed the entire sequence, then steps in and yells “Get in your house”.
Winnipeg police confirmed they were called to the 600 block of Manitoba around 6:45 p.m., on Sept. 12 for reports of “a number of intoxicated neighbours fighting”. Police said “at least 20 people” were involved and four calls were placed to 911 in the lead-up.
In an email response, Winnipeg police spokesperson Const. Jay Murray said the video only shows the “tail-end” of the incident and “given the totality” of the situation believes the officer made “an appropriate decision”.
“An officer perceived that if he didn’t intervene and stop these individuals from fighting, a serious injury could have occurred,” Murray said. “The officer chose to use a hard empty-hand control technique in the midst of a chaotic situation in an attempt to gain control and prevent the groups from further physically fighting.”
Winnipeg Police Association president Maurice Sabourin agreed.
“When the one female comes at him aggressively, we are allowed to use force that is reasonable to prevent an assault or prevent an attack,” Sabourin said. “... (Encountering an incident) We don’t know whether there’s a knife or a gun. When somebody comes at you aggressively and you’re trying to place a person under control, I would say that’s justified especially when your personal safety is at stake.”
A spokeswoman from the Independent Investigation of Manitoba said police would be obligated to inform the IIU if a person filed a complaint with the WPS, but declined comment on the video itself.
Corey Shefman, a Toronto-based lawyer who continues to practise in Winnipeg and handles human rights files, argued use of force should be applied to protect an officer or to effect an arrest.
“The fact that an arrest was not made in this situation suggests to me that the use of force was not justified,” Shefman said.
“... From what we’ve seen, it looks to me like one of the officers took a woman to the ground, threw a woman to the ground, and then sort of just walked away.”
Shefman also takes issue with the second officer, who observes most of the incident without stepping in.
“You have the main officer who’s right in the thick of things, getting involved and the second officer just sort of standing back and watching, not trying to de-escalate the situation,” Shefman said. “Neither of them are trying to de-escalate the situation and that’s another concern.”
An adult male was the lone arrest made, police said.
dlarkins@postmedia.com
Twitter: @LarkinsWSun
Incident underscores need for police body cams
A video showing Winnipeg police trying to contain a large fight in a city street is further evidence of the need for police body cameras, a human-rights lawyer says.
Corey Shefman, who is now based in Toronto but continues to practise in Manitoba, said a 54-second clip of an altercation between residents and police doesn’t provide enough information to adequately judge the actions of two officers, and argues body cameras would provide greater context.
“It might be that in the context of the whole encounter that the officer’s behaviour here was reasonable. It doesn’t look like it, but we don’t know and that’s really the point,” Shefman said. “Body cameras are good for citizens but, frankly, they’re also good for police. And if there’s one lesson to come out of this video it’s that body cameras are needed in this situation.”
The Winnipeg Police Board approved a body cameras pilot project in February 2015, but budget constraints meant that was scrapped before it could ever got off the ground.
Shefman argues citizens who want to pursue a complaint against police “don’t have a lot of options.”
“This is one of many situations where it’s their word against citizens,” he said. “Citizens are often left without recourse because it is very difficult to hold somebody accountable when there isn’t a recording and we were lucky in this case there was a recording.
“... Information is power and body cameras would have made a big difference in this situation.”
Police, union stand behind officer appearing to punch woman in video | Canada |
Officer in nurse arrest was reprimanded for sex harassment
THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
First posted: Monday, September 18, 2017 03:21 PM EDT | Updated: Monday, September 18, 2017 03:26 PM EDT
SALT LAKE CITY — Police documents show a Utah officer caught on video dragging a nurse from a hospital and putting her in handcuffs had previously been reprimanded for sexually harassing a female co-worker.
The records say Salt Lake City police internal affairs confirmed allegations that Detective Jeff Payne harassed a department employee in a “severe and persistent” way in 2013.
Payne’s lawyer, Greg Skordas, said Monday that while the reprimand is a problem, it’s only one part of a decorated 27-year record.
Payne’s discipline history was released in response to a public-records request from The Associated Press and other media outlets as multiple investigations into the arrest of nurse Alex Wubbels play out.
Payne handcuffed Wubbels after she refused to allow a blood to be drawn from an unconscious patient, citing hospital policy.
Officer in nurse arrest was reprimanded for sex harassment | Home | Toronto Sun
'Police owned' St. Louis: Riot cops arrest more than 80
Jim Salter and Summer Ballentine, THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
First posted: Sunday, September 17, 2017 10:56 PM EDT | Updated: Monday, September 18, 2017 08:25 AM EDT
ST. LOUIS — Hundreds of riot police mobilized in downtown St. Louis overnight, arresting more than 80 people and seizing weapons amid reports of property damage and vandalism following another day of peaceful protests over a former police officer’s acquittal in the killing of a black man.
The arrests late Sunday came after demonstrators ignored orders to disperse, police said.
“I’m proud to tell you the city of St. Louis is safe and the police owned tonight,” Interim Police Chief Lawrence O’Toole said at a news conference early Monday.
A judge ruled Friday that Jason Stockley, who left the police department and moved to Houston three years ago, was not guilty in the 2011 death of Anthony Lamar Smith. The ruling set off raucous protests throughout the weekend. Another peaceful demonstration was expected Monday.
On Sunday, more than 1,000 people gathered at police headquarters then marched without trouble through downtown St. Louis, the posh Central West End, and the trendy Delmar Loop area of nearby University City. Protesters also marched through two shopping malls in a wealthy area of St. Louis County.
By nightfall, most had gone home. The 100 or so people who remained grew increasingly agitated as they marched back toward downtown. Along the way, they knocked over planters, broke windows at a few shops and hotels, and scattered plastic chairs at an outdoor venue.
According to police, the demonstrators then sprayed bottles with an unknown substance on officers.
One officer suffered a leg injury and was taken to a hospital. His condition wasn’t known.
Soon afterward, buses brought in additional officers in riot gear, and police scoured downtown deep into the night, making arrests and seizing at least five weapons, according to O’Toole. Later, officers in riot gear gathered alongside a city boulevard chanting “whose street, our street” — a common refrain used by the protesters — after clearing the street of demonstrators and onlookers.
“We’re in control. This is our city and we’re going to protect it,” O’Toole said.
Mayor Lyda Krewson said at the same Monday news conference that “the days have been calm and the nights have been destructive” and that “destruction cannot be tolerated.”
The recent St. Louis protests follow a pattern seen since the August 2014 killing of Michael Brown in nearby Ferguson: The majority of demonstrators, though angry, are law-abiding. But as the night wears on, a subsection emerges, a different crowd more willing to confront police, sometimes to the point of clashes.
Protest organizer Anthony Bell said he understands why some act out: While change can come through peaceful protests, such as those led by Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., years of oppression has caused some to turn violent.
“I do not say the (violent) demonstrators are wrong, but I believe peaceful demonstrations are the best,” Bell said.
State Rep. Bruce Franks, a Democrat who has participated in the peaceful protests, said those behind the violence “are not protesters.”
The late night unrest since the verdict was issued has led to destruction across the St. Louis area. It was after nightfall Friday that people shattered a window at the home of Mayor Lynda Krewson, smashed about two dozen windows and threw trash cans and rocks at police in University City on Saturday, and knocked out windows downtown on Sunday.
Many protesters believe police provoked demonstrators by showing up in riot gear and armoured vehicles; police said they had no choice but to protect themselves once protesters started throwing things at them.
Democratic Rep. Michael Butler said police should target the agitators and allow others to continue demonstrating. He protested Friday, and after that said police have been doing a poor job of identifying bad actors in the crowds.
“There’s not been any learning from Ferguson,” Butler said.
Stockley shot Smith after high-speed chase as officers tried to arrest Smith and his partner in a suspected drug deal.
Stockley, 36, testified he felt endangered because he saw Smith holding a silver revolver when Smith backed his car toward the officers and sped away.
Prosecutors said Stockley planted a gun in Smith’s car after the shooting. The officer’s DNA was on the weapon but Smith’s wasn’t. Dashcam video from Stockley’s cruiser recorded him saying he was “going to kill this (expletive).” Less than a minute later, he shot Smith five times.
Stockley’s lawyer dismissed the comment as “human emotions” during a dangerous pursuit. St. Louis Circuit Judge Timothy Wilson, who said prosecutors didn’t prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Stockley murdered Smith, said the statement could be ambiguous.
'Police owned' St. Louis: Riot cops arrest more than 80 | World | News | Toronto