Woman's testimony begins in ex-Woodstock mayor's sexual assault trial
Two-term former mayor Trevor Birtch entered not guilty pleas Monday
Author of the article:Jane Sims
Published May 27, 2024 • Last updated 1 day ago • 5 minute read
Former Woodstock Mayor Trevor Birtch faces a total of six sex charges.
Former Woodstock Mayor Trevor Birtch faces a total of six sex charges.
She thought it was going to be a romantic Valentine’s Day date with her boyfriend at a cozy London spa.
Her partner was then-Woodstock Mayor Trevor Birtch. He had pulled out all the mid-pandemic stops on Feb.14, 2021, and convinced his friend, who happened to be the owner, to give him a suite at the Idlewyld Inn.
“I really thought it was going to be something special,” the 45-year-old woman testified Monday at Birtch’s sexual assault trial.
There were no other guests at the inn. Birtch had run her a bubble bath, lit candles and poured her wine. He already was in bed when she got out of the tub and climbed in beside him.
“And that’s when things went south really fast,” she said.
Instead of snuggling and watching a movie, the woman said Birtch began trying to move her head toward “his anatomy.” She resisted and he kept trying.
Then Birtch stopped and was angry, she said. “What good are you, then?” she testified he said to her. “I shouldn’t have brought you here.”
She testified he kicked her out of bed, got out himself and then yanked on her leg and hair and threw her out.
Birtch, 48, who served two terms as mayor until he was defeated in fall 2022, entered not guilty pleas to two counts of sexual assault and one count of assault involving the woman, with whom he was having an intimate relationship in 2021. Her identity is protected by court order.
He sat in the courtroom beside his defence lawyer, James Battin, while the woman answered questions from assistant Crown attorney Artem Orlov through a closed-circuit TV feed.
Orlov told Superior Court Justice Michael Carnegie that, at this point, she will be the only Crown witness. Battin said he would be calling Birtch and one other witness.
The charges involve three incidents involving the woman and Birtch. In two of them, the Valentine’s Day rendezvous and a day-long ride on country roads, she refused to perform a sex act. The third incident involved her consenting to the same sex act while in his bedroom, but, when things got too aggressive, she was unable to withdraw her consent.
Consent is clearly an issue in the case. So will be the photographs tendered into evidence showing extensive bruising on her arms and knee, which she said was caused when Birtch forcibly removed her from his car after the rural ride and threw her across a gravel parking lot.
She testified she took those photos an hour after she was injured and she never sought medical advice.
Birtch, she said, “was like Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde.” He could be “Mr. Wonderful, just the most caring and compassionate person ever and in a split second, it’s a monster.”
The woman said she and Birtch met at a community function where he asked her out and gave her a wink. “I thought he was being a nice, friendly mayor,” she said.
They began to communicate on social media and began their relationship in April 2020, at the beginning of the pandemic. It progressed rapidly.
At the time, she said Birtch was going through a divorce. He had no place to live, so he kept clothing and a toothbrush at her place and eventually moved in with his parents.
She said Birtch helped her out financially and was a reliable, comforting partner. “The Trevor that I fell in love with . . . was not the same Trevor by the end of it. I don’t know why,” she said through tears.
But, she said, there always were rumours about other women in Birtch’s life and he was a heavy drinker, with Devil’s Cut bourbon his drink of choice. He became angrier, she said, starting on Valentine’s Day 2021.
On that day, Birtch picked her up – she said he shouldn’t have been driving because he was drinking – and they drove to London. She was told to leave her phone and purse in the car.
Everything was great until the incident in bed. She hadn’t been “a good girl,” as he called her. She said she tried to sleep on the bathroom floor and once got back onto the edge of the bed. She told him she wanted to go home and she said Birtch told her: “I’ll bring you home when I’m good and ready.”
The next day, she said he drove the long way home and he seemed to soften up. But the anger returned when they reached her home. “I should have brought somebody else and now I know where I’m going,” he told her, she said. She didn’t hear from him for several days.
The relationship re-kindled within days.
That summer, she said they were out for a country drive and stopped several times for sexual activity. At about midnight, they stopped at a little stone church. They were talking about his family issues when he undid his pants and tried to push her face toward his crotch.
The woman said she resisted, angering Birtch. Then, as Birtch was trying to push her out of the car, she got out to urinate in a corn field.
“Are you sure you’re not going to be a good girl for daddy?” she said he asked her when she returned. When she said she wanted to go home, he drove away, leaving her behind with no cell service or clue where she was.
He was very angry, she said, and had “the same expression I’d seen on his face on Valentine’s Day. There was rage and there was anger.”
He returned 40 minutes later and made her ride in the back seat part of the way back to her apartment, where she said she wanted to have a conversation. Instead, he pulled her out of the car, causing the bruises, and sped away.
The relationship was back on days later, she said. In December 2021, she went to his home where she said she consented to a sex act, but found herself trapped in his clutches while in the middle of it and unable to cry out to stop and break free.
Afterward, she said Birtch was sobbing uncontrollably, saying that he loved her and “he didn’t mean to hurt me, but he couldn’t help it.”
The relationship did not continue once the woman said she saw another woman leaving Birtch’s house.
She went to the police in February 2022 after three of her vehicles had their windows broken with a baseball bat. She said she had suspicions about who did it, but wouldn’t tell police.
She was staying with a friend at an all-women’s residence when Birtch showed up looking for her. The friend called police.
She said she hesitated to go to the police because Birtch, as mayor, sat on Woodstock’s police board, and she didn’t go for medical treatment because Birtch sat on the hospital board.
“I just wanted Trevor to go away. I just wanted to live my own life. I didn’t want to be the reason he lost everything,” she said.
The defence is slated to begin cross-examination on Tuesday.
jsims@postmedia.com
Two-term former mayor Trevor Birtch entered not guilty pleas Monday in London to two counts of sexual assault and one of assault.
torontosun.com