Judge backs Ottawa’s bid to break up wheat-board monopoly

The Federal Court of Appeal has upheld the government's move to effectively dismantled the Canadian Wheat Board, dealing a blow to farmers who had opposed the law.

A group of former wheat-board directors, elected by farmers, argued that by law the federal government had to consult grain growers before making fundamental changes to how the agency operates. The government disagreed, saying it won a mandate in the last election to change legislation.

The farmers won a ruling in Manitoba upholding much of their claim but an appeal court has now overturned that decision, ruling that elected members of Parliament can change legislation as they see fit.

“I have found nothing in the record which leads to the conclusion that the repeal of the single desk as a whole or of the [Canadian Wheat Board Act] in its entirety were somehow made conditional to obtaining the prior consent of the CWB or of grain producers,” Mr. Justice Robert Mainville wrote in the ruling.

“In our system of representative democracy, which is similar in principle to that of the United Kingdom, the ultimate expression of democracy is effected through the elected members of the House of Commons and of the various provincial legislatures acting within their respective spheres of jurisdictions. Democracy in Canada rests ultimately on the participation of citizens in elections to the public institutions created under the Constitution.”

Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz said he was pleased with the decision. The law removing the CWB's monopoly over the sale of wheat and barley grown in Western Canada, “is in force and farmers are moving forward and contracting their wheat and barley with buyers of their choice for delivery beginning Aug. 1, 2012.”

Judge backs Ottawa
Every now and then judges get it right; this is one of those times. Hopefully, if and when this gets to the Supreme Court, those judges, too, will see the veracity of the Federal Court of Appeal ruling.
The Old Medic
How could it be otherwise? If Parliament could not change the laws, this would put various boards and commissions in charge of the government.

Similar Threads

Wheat board monopoly to end
by Locutus | Oct 24th, 2011
Wheat Board monopoly to end in 2012
by petros | May 25th, 2011
the Wheat Board ruling is in
by BitWhys | Jul 31st, 2007