Punished for a bit of banter? Itís rugby gone mad


Blackleaf
#1
Englandís first grand slam since 2003. That will be my abiding memory of this yearís Six Nations rugby tournament, a competition in which we saw England bounce back from their World Cup humiliation in rip-roaring fashion under the impeccable leadership of new boss Eddie Jones.

Typically, though, the perpetually offended want to spoil my and every other English rugby fanís fun by dragging political correctness, complete with accusations of racism, on to the field of play...


Punished for a bit of banter? Itís rugby gone mad

6 April 2016
Guy Birchall
Spiked


England's Joe Marler and Wales's Samson Lee confront each other during Wales's 25-21 defeat

Englandís first grand slam since 2003. That will be my abiding memory of this yearís Six Nations rugby tournament, a competition in which we saw England bounce back from their World Cup humiliation in rip-roaring fashion under the impeccable leadership of new boss Eddie Jones.

Typically, though, the perpetually offended want to spoil my and every other English rugby fanís fun by dragging political correctness, complete with accusations of racism, on to the field of play. England prop Joe Marler has just been banned for two games and fined £20,000 by World Rugby for calling his Welsh opposite number Samson Lee a Ďgypsy boyí during the first half of the England-Wales clash at Twickenham in March. Lee is of Traveller stock, so it was plainly not a very pleasant thing for Marler to say. But to brand him a racist for a remark made in the heat of the moment? Is that fair?

I know it might come as a shock to people who spend their entire lives in Safe Spaces, but when 30 blokes are knocking seven bells out of each other for 80 minutes in pursuit of sporting victory and national pride, things can get a bit heated. I played in Marler and Leeís position myself as a schoolboy, and I can tell you that even 16-year-olds can come up with some pretty colourful language after theyíve been lying at the bottom of a ruck as studded boots rain down from all sides.

Marler apologised to Lee at half-time and Lee himself dismissed the comment as Ďbanterí, as did Wales coach Warren Gatland. England coach Jones reprimanded Marler afterwards, and then, as is typical of rugby players, everyone shook hands and carried on. Officials for the Six Nations tournament itself also decided (quite rightly) that no further action need be taken, since no one directly affected by the incident cared about it.

But this is 21st-century Britain, when people can claim to be offended on othersí behalf. So Gatland has since been castigated for dismissing the exchange of unpleasantries as banter and has been forced to apologise to anyone who might have been offended. And the Welsh Rugby Football Union has now decided that Marler hasnít been sufficiently punished (though I suspect Eddie Jones may have pin-pointed the ulterior motive behind the WRFUís sudden outbreak of thin skin).


England celebrate last month after winning their first Six Nations Championship since 2011 and their first Grand Slam since 2003

Marler himself has also been forced into an act of public contrition. ĎIím not a racistí, he said. ĎWhat I said to Samson was out of order and wrong and I am sorry it was said. Whatever happens to me, I will accept. Iím sorry to anyone who was offended. Saying it was ďin the heat of the momentĒ isnít an excuse, but one comment, one mistake, does not make me a racist.í

Marler has now been banned and fined. All because he said something in a moment of anger to someone who, it turns out, wasnít bothered by it. He has been punished because people utterly uninvolved in the incident claim to have been offended on behalf of someone who was not offended.

If only there were a sin bin in life to which we might send the perpetually offended, so that they could calm down and realise how daft theyíre being. Perhaps then this idiocy would stop permeating fields of life that Iím prepared to bet most of the offended regard as abhorrent, macho and elitist anyway.

Guy Birchall is a writer based in London.


Punished for a bit of banter? Itís rugby gone mad | Free speech | Sport | spiked
 
coldstream
#2
calling a Welshman a 'gypsy boy'. Good grief it'd be hard to find any definable demographic that could be found to be outraged by this 'insult'. It's political correctness in desperate seach for a victim.

Glad to see English Rugby on the rebound.. wish they broadcast the 6 Nations over here.
 
Blackleaf
#3
Quote:

calling a Welshman a 'gypsy boy'. Good grief it'd be hard to find any definable demographic that could be found to be outraged by this 'insult'. It's political correctness in desperate seach for a victim.

Glad to see English Rugby on the rebound.. wish they broadcast the 6 Nations over here.

Plenty of English players have been called a lot worse by Welsh players over the years. But the English are used to the chippy "Celtic" nations acting like this over the years when England beat them at sport. The Scots and Irish are the same.

Also, it wasn't just Marler who got into trouble after that match. Wales's Tomas Francis has been banned for eight weeks for his attempted eye gouge of England's Dan Coles, a far worse crime, you would think, than calling somebody "a gypsy boy" . Yet, judging by all the outrage in the largely anti-English British media over the last couple of weeks, you'd be forgiven for thinking that it was Marler who committed the biggest and most outrageous crime during that match. The attempts by Francis to gouge Coles's eye out of its socket has largely been ignored by the media.