Georgia teacher suspended after pupils don Klan robes

Praxius

Mass'Debater
Dec 18, 2007
10,609
99
48
Halifax, NS & Melbourne, VIC

The teacher wanted to include the
Klan in a lesson on American racism


BBC News - Georgia teacher suspended after pupils don Klan robes

A teacher in the US state of Georgia has been suspended after allowing students to dress in mock Ku Klux Klan robes for a project.

The teacher had asked four students, none of whom were black, to re-enact scenes from history for a class film.

Officials said the teacher had used poor judgement. Georgia has a history of violent racial tension and students and parents were upset by the incident.

The teacher, who is white, acknowledged it was a mistake to film the scene.

"It was poor judgement on my part," Catherine Ariemma told the Associated Press news agency.

The class at Lumpkin County High School near Atlanta included no black children, and the school system is roughly 90% white.

The Ku Klux Klan is one of the oldest and most infamous hate groups in the US and was known for the white robes and cone-shaped hoods members wore at rallies.

Founded as a vigilante group amid the turmoil after the US civil war, the Klan violently opposed civil rights for African Americans, although the group also turned its ire toward Jews, Catholics and immigrants, according to the Southern Poverty Law Center, which tracks hate groups.

Its membership and influence have waned in recent decades.

Ms Ariemma told US media she had asked the students to film scenes from American history for a course combining US history with film study. For the scene in question, the students were exploring American racism.

"This is a film about racism and we have to discuss racism in our society," she said.

"You can't discuss racism and not include the Klan."

Ms Ariemma, a teacher for nearly six years, said the students had brought in bed sheets and cone-shaped party hats to make their costumes.

Other students observed four of their robed classmates walking through the cafeteria to another location in the school where another student filmed the scene.

Some African-American students and parents complained to school administrators and Ms Ariemma was suspended. She could face further disciplinary measures.

"We determined, obviously, that she used extremely poor judgment," school system superintendent Dewey Moye told the Atlanta Journal-Constitution newspaper.
Yeah a bit stupid if you ask me.... based on the situation and the area in which the situation occurred, one would think it would have been wise for her to approve the student's projects before they did them, and when this came up, address it with the school principal, etc. to ensure it was allowed..... and make sure people were aware of why it was being done.... which was to talk about the racism in US history..... not promote it. (If that was their original intentions, that is)

Having the students stroll around the cafeteria dressed up was completely stupid and should have confined the project to the classroom.
 

wulfie68

Council Member
Mar 29, 2009
2,014
24
38
Calgary, AB
My wife and I read this, and if the student's project was an honest attempt at discussing racism and learning about it, then the teacher deserves a slap on the wrist at worst. She was a little naive/insensitive if she didn't think someone walking in Klan apparrel, even in a predominantly white area/district, would evoke a reaction. If she white-washed an attempt by the kids to make light of the issue then she deserves a much harsher punishment. The proof should ultimately come form the film the students put together.
 

AnnaG

Hall of Fame Member
Jul 5, 2009
17,507
117
63
Yup. Lack of forethought.
It probably would go over in Canada because most would realize it wasn't promoting anything, just portraying a little history, but in the middle of the confed states? Dum dum dum dum dah!
 

ByTheRiver

New Member
May 20, 2010
9
0
1
Toronto
on the other hand...
If she were to go to the school, parents etc prior seeking approval - I doubt she would have gotten it.
Personally, I think she did the right thing. To judge something as being wrong because it makes people uncomfortable is not enough for me. There are things that need to be brought out into the open - like racism and discussed. Thats the one thing I would say she'd need to do - talk with parents, the school and children about the point of the assignment afterwards.
Racism is never easy to talk about but it has to be done.
 

AnnaG

Hall of Fame Member
Jul 5, 2009
17,507
117
63
on the other hand...
If she were to go to the school, parents etc prior seeking approval - I doubt she would have gotten it.
Personally, I think she did the right thing. To judge something as being wrong because it makes people uncomfortable is not enough for me. There are things that need to be brought out into the open - like racism and discussed. Thats the one thing I would say she'd need to do - talk with parents, the school and children about the point of the assignment afterwards.
Racism is never easy to talk about but it has to be done.
You'd probably wander into a nunnery and start talking about syphilis in the porn industry or something then, right?
 

ByTheRiver

New Member
May 20, 2010
9
0
1
Toronto
You'd probably wander into a nunnery and start talking about syphilis in the porn industry or something then, right?


No - don't think I'd do that ;-)
I don't don't see how this comepares to a nunnery...unless to compare the kids to innocents. I don't view kids as 'innocent' heard many racial slurs on the play ground. but this isn't the point.