Harper"s Economic Growth Record Lowest Since RB Bennet

petros

The Central Scrutinizer
Nov 21, 2008
109,294
11,384
113
Low Earth Orbit
Economic mediocrity not good enough for Canada!




While criticisms of Stephen Harper’s speech at the recent Conservative Party convention in Calgary focused primarily on his failure to offer the slightest acknowledgement of the ethical scandal currently engulfing his office, the economic content of that speech was also highly dubious.

He began with the absurd claim that he has cut the cost of government. Maybe that’s what embarrassed Party delegates would like to hear and believe, but it’s not true.

Mr. Harper has escalated federal government spending to an all-time record high in excess of $280-billion annually. He has run six consecutive deficits, adding some $160-billion to accumulated federal debt and pushing Canada’s debt burden to an all-time record high of more than $620-billion.

His debt-to-GDP ratio is no better than when he first took office nearly eight years ago — even though the recession (which he blames for everything) ended more than four years ago. He recently postponed his target for any significant debt-ratio improvement until 2021.

Among the things for which Mr. Harper is increasing his spending is grossly misleading government advertising — all those irritating “economic action plan” TV ads, for example. Just 30-seconds of air-time for just one of those commercials costs taxpayers close to $100,000!

He is also heavily promoting his so-called “Jobs Grant” mentioned in the last federal Budget. He would like you to think he has a credible plan to expand employment and training. Trouble is, the grant program he’s advertising doesn’t exist. It’s beyond federal jurisdiction. There’s not a penny of new federal money for it. It would have to be negotiated with provinces. And all of the provinces have already rejected it. So both the plan and the advertising are a complete scam.

Mr. Harper is also increasing government spending on his political machine. The budget for his own office, for instance, is going up by more than 7%, while programs and services for war veterans and wounded soldiers are being cut by more than 20%.

On another front, Mr. Harper likes to promote the fiction that he doesn’t raise taxes. But, in fact, he has increased the net federal tax burden on Canadians in each of his last four budgets. It happens in dozens of nefarious ways, which he hopes you won’t notice — like a new federal tax on hospital parking fees and an extra $75-million every year in higher incomes taxes taken from Credit Unions.

And there have been several very large tax increases — $3.6-billion extracted from employers and employees over the past three years in higher Employment Insurance payroll taxes, $333-million every year on-going in higher tariff taxes on consumer goods, and $550-million per year in new taxes on the owners of small businesses.

Most of these new and higher Conservative taxes directly hit and hurt Canada’s middle-class and all those who are working hard to join the middle-class. But Mr. Harper remains oblivious to their needs.

And finally, there’s the crucial issue of economic growth. It has stalled under Stephen Harper. As mentioned above, the recession ended more than four years ago, but Canada’s growth remains slow and sluggish, falling behind a number of OECD countries with whom we must compete. Domestically, Mr. Harper’s growth record is, in fact, the worst of any Prime Minister since R.B. Bennett. And he has no plan to get any better.

Such mediocrity is just not good enough for Canada.

http://www.ralphgoodale.ca/blog/economic-mediocrity-good-canada/
 

Locutus

Adorable Deplorable
Jun 18, 2007
32,230
45
48
65
Even ralphie's followers don't buy his borrowed little 'graph' :lol:

B.Jones-Vaillancourt ‏@BrynDartCentre 9 Nov @RalphGoodale where did these stats come from?


Saskie ‏@Saskie_21 9 Nov @RalphGoodale I'm not a fan of Harper, but this argument is a bit weak as he has been in power during one of the worst intn'l econ disasters


jordan rinehart ‏@jrine11 9 Nov
@RalphGoodale nice graph and all, but without numbers it seems very invalid


Tomasz Wlodarczyk ‏@twlodarczyk 9 Nov
@RalphGoodale Graphic without axis labels is useless...I suspect GDP or something but who knows...this..on its own is misleading. Sorry.


Saskie ‏@Saskie_21 9 Nov
@RalphGoodale If this world bank data is right (http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/ny.gdp.mktp.kd.zg …), Canada is 1st in G8 cumulative from 09 to 12 and 3rd from 10 to 12


Ralph Goodale ‏@RalphGoodale 9 Nov
@Saskie_21 - Thnx for kind words. Ec comparisons shld be beyond G8 which was epi-centre of recession. Many OECD countries have done better.


Saskie ‏@Saskie_21 9 Nov
@RalphGoodale Right, but it's G8 counties that are closest to Canada's for comparability. Plus we are economically too reliant on the US








https://twitter.com/RalphGoodale/status/399245588346056704/photo/1
 

Machjo

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 19, 2004
17,878
61
48
Ottawa, ON
I'd rather the government focus on stability rather than unstable growth. Unstable growth is what leads to recessions.
 

Machjo

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 19, 2004
17,878
61
48
Ottawa, ON
What do you export besides bureaucrats with bad accents and worse attitude.?

Hey, Taxslave, haven't you noticed that the poorer the country, the quicker its growth tends to be?

When a country has nowhere to go but up, it's economy is bound to grow quickly. :)

Must be that extra dose of socialism Britain enjoys.

Maybe. Debt and inflation spending tends to promote economic growth. Not stable groth in the long run but hey, growth is growth, right?
 

captain morgan

Hall of Fame Member
Mar 28, 2009
28,429
146
63
A Mouse Once Bit My Sister
Yup nuts and flakes.

The spending and debt has nothing to do with G8. It is what it is.


... But it has everything to do with comparing the effects of the recession with other nations that were impacted.

I can't think of any G8 or G20 nation that didn't increase spending and/or assume debt during this time. Pretending that Canada is somehow immune to the effects of a global recession is naive
 

taxslave

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 25, 2008
36,362
4,337
113
Vancouver Island
Hey, Taxslave, haven't you noticed that the poorer the country, the quicker its growth tends to be?

When a country has nowhere to go but up, it's economy is bound to grow quickly. :)



Maybe. Debt and inflation spending tends to promote economic growth. Not stable groth in the long run but hey, growth is growth, right?

So Greece should be experiencing record growth next year?
 

Blackleaf

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 9, 2004
48,400
1,667
113
What do you export besides bureaucrats with bad accents and worse attitude.?


We export more than Canada does.

We also export a third of the amount that the USA exports despite having just a fifth of the USA's population.
 

Tonington

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 27, 2006
15,441
150
63
We export more than Canada does.

We also export a third of the amount that the USA exports despite having just a fifth of the USA's population.

LMAO

I remember you going on about per capita when it came to Nobel prizes and the UK v America comparisons.

Nice of you to mention that the UK exports more than Canada, and in the next sentence mention population when comparing to the US who exports more than the UK.

2012 values
UK exports, $474.6 billion, population 63.2 million. Export value per capita is $7,509.49.
Canada exports, $462.9 billion, 34.9 million. Export value per capita $13,263.61.

How do you like them apples? They're probably from Canada :lol: