Sexting Victoria teen girl to be tried on child porn charge
Girl, 16, faces child porn charge for texting nude photo of another girl
Sexting Victoria teen girl to be tried on child porn charge - British Columbia - CBC News
The trial of a Victoria-area teen who is facing child pornography charges for allegedly texting a nude picture of another girl without her consent will go ahead before a constitutional challenge, a judge has ruled.
The 16-year-old Saanich girl is facing charges of possession and distribution of child pornography and uttering threats after she allegedly distributed nude pictures of her boyfriend's ex-girlfriend.
Today, a provincial court judge ruled the trial will go ahead this fall, before a related constitutional challenge to the child pornography law will be heard.
The teen's lawyer Christopher Mackie says they are launching a constitutional challenge against Canada's child pornography laws as they apply to people under age, claiming the charges amount to age discrimination.
"Originally, those provisions were created in order to protect children, so is it appropriate to use those provisions now to prosecute children?" Mackie said earlier this week.
The director of the B.C. Civil Liberties Association Micheal Vonn agreed and said this isn't what the laws were meant for.
"It's obviously absurd.…The unbelievably heavy hand of criminal law cannot be used as an educational tool and a deterrent in this fashion," said Vonn.
Act of a bully?
But Saanich police Sgt. Steve Eassie said this was an act of bullying.
"This it appears this was part of harassment or threatening behaviour on the part of the accused."
Stephanie Owen, of the Children of the Street Society, agreed, based on the allegations and the growing problem of online bullying, that the charges are appropriate.
"We're really trying to raise awareness about really thinking about what you put online."
But the mother of the accused said no one else involved in the case faces any charges and she believes the whole situation should have been dealt with outside of the legal system.
She said her daughter is not a pornographer or a pedophile and the law does not fit the alleged crime.
"They should have all been, suffered the same consequences, if you want to say … but also, they should all been offered the same counselling, they should have been offered the same education as far as the negative effects that this can have on them. Everybody's a loser here, really," said the girl's mother.
She said her daughter has been singled out and forced to transfer schools.
Nobody involved in the case can be named, in order to protect the identity of the minors involved.
Girl, 16, faces child porn charge for texting nude photo of another girl
Sexting Victoria teen girl to be tried on child porn charge - British Columbia - CBC News
The trial of a Victoria-area teen who is facing child pornography charges for allegedly texting a nude picture of another girl without her consent will go ahead before a constitutional challenge, a judge has ruled.
The 16-year-old Saanich girl is facing charges of possession and distribution of child pornography and uttering threats after she allegedly distributed nude pictures of her boyfriend's ex-girlfriend.
Today, a provincial court judge ruled the trial will go ahead this fall, before a related constitutional challenge to the child pornography law will be heard.
The teen's lawyer Christopher Mackie says they are launching a constitutional challenge against Canada's child pornography laws as they apply to people under age, claiming the charges amount to age discrimination.
"Originally, those provisions were created in order to protect children, so is it appropriate to use those provisions now to prosecute children?" Mackie said earlier this week.
The director of the B.C. Civil Liberties Association Micheal Vonn agreed and said this isn't what the laws were meant for.
"It's obviously absurd.…The unbelievably heavy hand of criminal law cannot be used as an educational tool and a deterrent in this fashion," said Vonn.
Act of a bully?
But Saanich police Sgt. Steve Eassie said this was an act of bullying.
"This it appears this was part of harassment or threatening behaviour on the part of the accused."
Stephanie Owen, of the Children of the Street Society, agreed, based on the allegations and the growing problem of online bullying, that the charges are appropriate.
"We're really trying to raise awareness about really thinking about what you put online."
But the mother of the accused said no one else involved in the case faces any charges and she believes the whole situation should have been dealt with outside of the legal system.
She said her daughter is not a pornographer or a pedophile and the law does not fit the alleged crime.
"They should have all been, suffered the same consequences, if you want to say … but also, they should all been offered the same counselling, they should have been offered the same education as far as the negative effects that this can have on them. Everybody's a loser here, really," said the girl's mother.
She said her daughter has been singled out and forced to transfer schools.
Nobody involved in the case can be named, in order to protect the identity of the minors involved.
