Man in India beheads daughter, UN?

dumpthemonarchy

House Member
Jan 18, 2005
4,235
14
38
Vancouver
www.cynicsunlimited.com
So, what is the govt of India doing about this? Is the UN condeming the govt of India for its inaction? Don't hear much. A Commonwealth member country also.


World News: Man beheading daughter in India





Man beheading daughter in India ‘a ghastly sight,’ says police officer

Published On Tue Jun 19 2012

Oghad Singh, centre, stands with policemen after they placed Singh in custody in Charbhuja, Rajasthan state, India. Police said Singh remains unrepentant after beheading his daughter with a ceremonial sword in a rage over her alleged relationships with men.
AP FROM VIDEO
Prakash Bhandari The Associated Press





JAIPUR, INDIA—A father in northwestern India remained unrepentant Tuesday after beheading his daughter with a ceremonial sword in a rage over her relationships with men, police said.

Man beheads daughter

The father surrendered at a police station, carrying the head in one hand and the bloodied sword in the other, police said.
Residents of Dungarji village expressed shock as they performed the last rites for the 20-year-old woman.
Police said the father, marble miner Oghad Singh, accused his daughter of bringing dishonour to the family and making it hard to find husbands for her two unmarried sisters.

Women wailing in grief lined the dusty road of the village in Rajasthan state as a procession carried Manju Kanwar's remains to her funeral pyre. As in many north and west Indian villages, the women, including her mother and four sisters, were not allowed to attend the funeral.

A coroner stitched Kanwar's head onto her body for the funeral. About 100 men, many of them relatives wearing ceremonial Rajput warrior clan turbans, surrounded her muslin-wrapped body, and her brother lit the funeral pyre.

Villagers condemned the father's actions as extreme. They said the father, his shirt soaked in blood, had carried his daughter's head through the village, describing what he'd done to neighbours.

“He told me that he took the sword out, and when the daughter was all alone in the house he beheaded her with a single stroke and the head fell on the ground,” said Narayan Singh, a distant relative.

He said he persuaded Singh to surrender, and took him by motorcycle to a police station 5 kilometres away. Police charged Singh, 46, with murder.

“It was a ghastly sight,” officer Ranjit Singh said, describing the father sitting in the station's waiting room holding the head in one hand and the sword in the other. “Oghad admitted immediately that he killed his daughter because she had earned a bad name for the family.”

Police described Kanwar's recent life as difficult and unorthodox for the traditional community of about 1,000 just outside the Rajasthani tourist town of Udaipur.

She left her husband from an arranged marriage two years ago and moved back home to live with her parents. She recently began seeing several men which “disgusted” her father, deputy police superintendent Umesh Ojha said.
“Oghad said he was fed up with the lifestyle of his daughter,” Ojha said.

When Manju eloped with one man two weeks ago, her father forced her to return on Sunday and killed her.
Rapidly modernizing India faces increasing social clashes as youths resist traditions like arranged marriage or limits on women venturing outside their parents' or husbands' homes.

The country is considered one of the harshest places in the world for women, with female infanticide and child marriage still common.
The UN's gender inequality index places India second to last, above Saudi Arabia, based on labour, reproductive health, education and politics. The index does not consider issues of violence.
 

Suemorgs

New Member
May 17, 2012
6
0
1
So, what is the govt of India doing about this? Is the UN condeming the govt of India for its inaction? Don't hear much. A Commonwealth member country also.


World News: Man beheading daughter in India





Man beheading daughter in India ‘a ghastly sight,’ says police officer

Published On Tue Jun 19 2012

Oghad Singh, centre, stands with policemen after they placed Singh in custody in Charbhuja, Rajasthan state, India. Police said Singh remains unrepentant after beheading his daughter with a ceremonial sword in a rage over her alleged relationships with men.
AP FROM VIDEO
Prakash Bhandari The Associated Press





JAIPUR, INDIA—A father in northwestern India remained unrepentant Tuesday after beheading his daughter with a ceremonial sword in a rage over her relationships with men, police said.

Man beheads daughter

The father surrendered at a police station, carrying the head in one hand and the bloodied sword in the other, police said.
Residents of Dungarji village expressed shock as they performed the last rites for the 20-year-old woman.
Police said the father, marble miner Oghad Singh, accused his daughter of bringing dishonour to the family and making it hard to find husbands for her two unmarried sisters.

Women wailing in grief lined the dusty road of the village in Rajasthan state as a procession carried Manju Kanwar's remains to her funeral pyre. As in many north and west Indian villages, the women, including her mother and four sisters, were not allowed to attend the funeral.

A coroner stitched Kanwar's head onto her body for the funeral. About 100 men, many of them relatives wearing ceremonial Rajput warrior clan turbans, surrounded her muslin-wrapped body, and her brother lit the funeral pyre.

Villagers condemned the father's actions as extreme. They said the father, his shirt soaked in blood, had carried his daughter's head through the village, describing what he'd done to neighbours.

“He told me that he took the sword out, and when the daughter was all alone in the house he beheaded her with a single stroke and the head fell on the ground,” said Narayan Singh, a distant relative.

He said he persuaded Singh to surrender, and took him by motorcycle to a police station 5 kilometres away. Police charged Singh, 46, with murder.

“It was a ghastly sight,” officer Ranjit Singh said, describing the father sitting in the station's waiting room holding the head in one hand and the sword in the other. “Oghad admitted immediately that he killed his daughter because she had earned a bad name for the family.”

Police described Kanwar's recent life as difficult and unorthodox for the traditional community of about 1,000 just outside the Rajasthani tourist town of Udaipur.

She left her husband from an arranged marriage two years ago and moved back home to live with her parents. She recently began seeing several men which “disgusted” her father, deputy police superintendent Umesh Ojha said.
“Oghad said he was fed up with the lifestyle of his daughter,” Ojha said.

When Manju eloped with one man two weeks ago, her father forced her to return on Sunday and killed her.
Rapidly modernizing India faces increasing social clashes as youths resist traditions like arranged marriage or limits on women venturing outside their parents' or husbands' homes.

The country is considered one of the harshest places in the world for women, with female infanticide and child marriage still common.
The UN's gender inequality index places India second to last, above Saudi Arabia, based on labour, reproductive health, education and politics. The index does not consider issues of violence.
Punishment should fit the crime.
 

B00Mer

Keep Calm and Carry On
Sep 6, 2008
44,800
7,297
113
Rent Free in Your Head
www.getafteritmedia.com
This is a country where they abort female fetuses, because a woman worth is less that a man..

It's very said, and where is the UN now with their high and mighty opinions now..???

I hope the execute the father for this tragic and horrific deed..
 

Machjo

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 19, 2004
17,878
61
48
Ottawa, ON
First off, the Indian government is fighting as best it can against selective abortions and does not condone beheadings and honour killings.

Certainly the courts will deal with this.

To be fair, we can't say the Canadian government condones murder because there are murders in Canada. there is a difference between official policy and individual actions.

This is a country where they abort female fetuses, because a woman worth is less that a man..

It's very said, and where is the UN now with their high and mighty opinions now..???

I hope the execute the father for this tragic and horrific deed..

I know they did execute an honour killer not long ago.
 

gerryh

Time Out
Nov 21, 2004
25,756
295
83
So, what is the govt of India doing about this? Is the UN condeming the govt of India for its inaction? Don't hear much. A Commonwealth member country also.


The government of India is doing plenty, but why would anyone expect your type to actually do any research before spouting off your BS. The man is under arrest and will be dealt with through the courts, which by the way, frowns on honour killing. What more would you like the Government of India to do? Please remember, that honour killings take place here in Canada also.

As for the U.N., it has already placed India second to last just above Saudi Arabia on the gender inequality index as is pointed out in the article you quoted. I guess it was too long for you to be able to read the entire thing. Or maybe the person you have reading to you is getting tired of having to read to you.


The country is considered one of the harshest places in the world for women, with female infanticide and child marriage still common.
The UN's gender inequality index places India second to last, above Saudi Arabia, based on labour, reproductive health, education and politics. The index does not consider issues of violence.

This is a country where they abort female fetuses, .



and that doesn't happen in Canada also?
 

damngrumpy

Executive Branch Member
Mar 16, 2005
9,949
21
38
kelowna bc
Lets be honest here, the government is living in the present and the past depending
on whether it is an urban or rural part of the country. There are areas where law
enforcement is adequate, however India as such is a corrupt nation, and a nation that
still lives in a semi feudal way although there is more money than their used to be.
To suggest India is a modern nation governed by laws is to stretch the imagination.
China is a nation living in the semi dark ages with increasing wealth, the difference is
the Chinese just shoot you and bill the family for the bullet, in India if you pay the right
sum of money you can get away with almost anything.
Corruption is a part of the fabric of society in that nation, and has been all along.
 

Machjo

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 19, 2004
17,878
61
48
Ottawa, ON
Lets be honest here, the government is living in the present and the past depending
on whether it is an urban or rural part of the country. There are areas where law
enforcement is adequate, however India as such is a corrupt nation, and a nation that
still lives in a semi feudal way although there is more money than their used to be.
To suggest India is a modern nation governed by laws is to stretch the imagination.
China is a nation living in the semi dark ages with increasing wealth, the difference is
the Chinese just shoot you and bill the family for the bullet, in India if you pay the right
sum of money you can get away with almost anything.
Corruption is a part of the fabric of society in that nation, and has been all along.

Actually, China does not charge the family for the bullet anymore.
 

damngrumpy

Executive Branch Member
Mar 16, 2005
9,949
21
38
kelowna bc
Gerry unfortunately the courts in India don't operate like they do here at all.
Justice is still a far away dream.
 

dumpthemonarchy

House Member
Jan 18, 2005
4,235
14
38
Vancouver
www.cynicsunlimited.com
An example of tribal, pre-modern people that take the law into their own hands and expect to get away with it. Doesn't sound like a democracy to me. Supposedly the progressive ones are immigrating here. There are Indo-Canadian girls who are told, "Next month you're getting married in India."

I just noticed below, in Similar Threads, that beheadings occur every few years there. A very good reason to dump the monarchy and get out of the Commonwealth ASAP.
 

hermanntrude

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Jun 23, 2006
7,267
118
63
45
Newfoundland!
Apparently the US government condones the weird cultural practice of face-eating as well. Perhaps we should pour scorn upon all other countries in which other people do bad things.

it'd be awfully convenient for government people who want to keep attention away fromn the bad things they are doing
 

Cliffy

Standing Member
Nov 19, 2008
44,850
192
63
Nakusp, BC
You get caught too much up in the personalities. A woman had her head chopped of by a maniac and you criticise me. kookoo
Like people in Canada or any other country don't do horrific acts of violence. It was one man not an entire nation, as the OP insinuates. That is what is racist about your remarks.
 

captain morgan

Hall of Fame Member
Mar 28, 2009
28,429
146
63
A Mouse Once Bit My Sister
This is a country where they abort female fetuses, because a woman worth is less that a man..

It's very said, and where is the UN now with their high and mighty opinions now..???

I hope the execute the father for this tragic and horrific deed..

Sounds to me like the UN should step in here and appoint this man as head of their Human Rights Department... Being the architect of some form of violence and abuse against others seems to be an experiential qualification that they deem important

Like people in Canada or any other country don't do horrific acts of violence. It was one man not an entire nation, as the OP insinuates. That is what is racist about your remarks.

Too bad that you don't apply that same equitable logic to religious institutions. It would be a refreshing approach for once
 

DurkaDurka

Internet Lawyer
Mar 15, 2006
10,385
129
63
Toronto
Apparently the US government condones the weird cultural practice of face-eating as well. Perhaps we should pour scorn upon all other countries in which other people do bad things.

it'd be awfully convenient for government people who want to keep attention away fromn the bad things they are doing

Got any bath salts you can brew up for me, Hermann? haha :p
 

earth_as_one

Time Out
Jan 5, 2006
7,933
53
48
An example of tribal, pre-modern people that take the law into their own hands and expect to get away with it. Doesn't sound like a democracy to me. ....
I don't believe dating or sex outside marriage is illegal in India. So this murder isn't an example of someone taking the law into their own hands, but an unprovoked murder.

Regarding "tribal pre-modern people that take the law into their own hands", you don't have to go far to find them. Many forum users have expressed support for crime victims taking taking the law into their own hands and even support a crime victim killing the perpetrator. It depends on the crime. Check out this thread:
http://forums.canadiancontent.net/news/106986-dad-beats-daughter-s-alleged.html