New documents show that France's military is falling apart, with MOST of its tanks, helicopters and jet fighters unusable.
France is the world's third-biggest defence spender after the United States and Britain though, unlike the US and Britain, spnding on the police force is included as part of France's defence spending.
Whereas Britain spends cash on buying - or building - some of the world's most hi-tech weaponry, such as the RAF Typhoon, the RAF Joint Strike Fighter (JSF), the British Army Apache Helicopter, robots to search for bombs in buildings and the new Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) for the RAF, the French military, on the other hand, doesn't seem to be acquiring the best equipment.
French army falling apart, documents show
By Henry Samuel in Paris
06/06/2008
The Telegraph
Most of France's tanks, helicopters and jet fighters are unusable and its defence apparatus is on the verge of "falling apart", it has emerged.
France's military has been given a bleak prognosis
According to confidential defence documents leaked to the French press, less than half of France's Leclerc tanks – 142 out of 346 – are operational and even these regularly break down.
Less than half of its Puma helicopters, 37 per cent of its Lynx choppers and 33 per cent of its Super Frelon models – built 40 years ago – are in a fit state to fly, according to documents seen by Le Parisien newspaper.
Two thirds of France's Mirage F1 reconnaissance jets are unusable at present.
When it comes to military technology, France is far behind Britain, as this new helmet for the RAF's Joint Strike Fighter aircraft shows
According to army officials, the precarious state of France's defence equipment almost led to catastrophe in April, when French special forces rescued the passengers and crew of a luxury yacht held by pirates off the Somali coast.
Although ultimately a success, the rescue operation nearly foundered at an early stage, when two of the frigates carrying troops suffered engine failure, and a launch laden with special forces' equipment sunk under its weight.
Later, an Atlantic 2 jet tracking the pirates above Somali territory suffered engine failure and had to make an emergency landing in Yemen.
"External operations, in the Ivory Coast and Lebanon are a fig leaf: we are able to keep up the pretence but in ten years our defence apparatus will fall apart," one high-ranking official said.
The disclosure comes just ten days before President Nicolas Sarkozy announces a major reform of the armed forces, with a defence white paper outlining France's military priorities for the next 15 years.
He is expected to argue that the situation can only improve by reducing the number of France's operational troops from 50,000 to 30,000, and its fighter aircraft, as well as closing military bases.
He will also use the occasion to push for greater military integration in Europe, an issue that France will highlight when it takes over the EU's six-month rotating presidency in July.
French proposals circulating in Brussels show that France wants a new EU military headquarters based in the Belgian capital and run by Europe's new foreign policy chief. It is also calling for a bigger rapid reaction force and for countries to spend more on defence.
France has played down its European defence ambitions for fear of boosting the No vote in Ireland's referendum on the Lisbon treaty on June 12.
In parallel to beefing up the EU's defence capability, Mr Sarkozy is keen on France becoming a full member of Nato's integrated military command structure, which Charles de Gaulle left in 1966. But he is unlikely to make a decision on this until next year.
WORLD'S BIGGEST DEFENCE SPENDERS 2007/08 (US dollars)
1) United States: 583,283,000,000
2) Britain: 79,872,000,000
3) France: 74,690,470,000 (including the police force)
4) China: 59,000,000,000
5) Japan: 48,860,000,000
6) Germany: 45,930,000,000
7) Russia: 41,050,000,000
8 ) Italy: 40,060,000,000
9) Saudi Arabia: 31,050,000,000
10) South Korea: 28,940,000,000
telegraph.co.uk
France is the world's third-biggest defence spender after the United States and Britain though, unlike the US and Britain, spnding on the police force is included as part of France's defence spending.
Whereas Britain spends cash on buying - or building - some of the world's most hi-tech weaponry, such as the RAF Typhoon, the RAF Joint Strike Fighter (JSF), the British Army Apache Helicopter, robots to search for bombs in buildings and the new Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) for the RAF, the French military, on the other hand, doesn't seem to be acquiring the best equipment.
French army falling apart, documents show
By Henry Samuel in Paris
06/06/2008
The Telegraph
Most of France's tanks, helicopters and jet fighters are unusable and its defence apparatus is on the verge of "falling apart", it has emerged.
France's military has been given a bleak prognosis
According to confidential defence documents leaked to the French press, less than half of France's Leclerc tanks – 142 out of 346 – are operational and even these regularly break down.
Less than half of its Puma helicopters, 37 per cent of its Lynx choppers and 33 per cent of its Super Frelon models – built 40 years ago – are in a fit state to fly, according to documents seen by Le Parisien newspaper.
Two thirds of France's Mirage F1 reconnaissance jets are unusable at present.
When it comes to military technology, France is far behind Britain, as this new helmet for the RAF's Joint Strike Fighter aircraft shows
According to army officials, the precarious state of France's defence equipment almost led to catastrophe in April, when French special forces rescued the passengers and crew of a luxury yacht held by pirates off the Somali coast.
Although ultimately a success, the rescue operation nearly foundered at an early stage, when two of the frigates carrying troops suffered engine failure, and a launch laden with special forces' equipment sunk under its weight.
Later, an Atlantic 2 jet tracking the pirates above Somali territory suffered engine failure and had to make an emergency landing in Yemen.
"External operations, in the Ivory Coast and Lebanon are a fig leaf: we are able to keep up the pretence but in ten years our defence apparatus will fall apart," one high-ranking official said.
The disclosure comes just ten days before President Nicolas Sarkozy announces a major reform of the armed forces, with a defence white paper outlining France's military priorities for the next 15 years.
He is expected to argue that the situation can only improve by reducing the number of France's operational troops from 50,000 to 30,000, and its fighter aircraft, as well as closing military bases.
He will also use the occasion to push for greater military integration in Europe, an issue that France will highlight when it takes over the EU's six-month rotating presidency in July.
French proposals circulating in Brussels show that France wants a new EU military headquarters based in the Belgian capital and run by Europe's new foreign policy chief. It is also calling for a bigger rapid reaction force and for countries to spend more on defence.
France has played down its European defence ambitions for fear of boosting the No vote in Ireland's referendum on the Lisbon treaty on June 12.
In parallel to beefing up the EU's defence capability, Mr Sarkozy is keen on France becoming a full member of Nato's integrated military command structure, which Charles de Gaulle left in 1966. But he is unlikely to make a decision on this until next year.
WORLD'S BIGGEST DEFENCE SPENDERS 2007/08 (US dollars)
1) United States: 583,283,000,000
2) Britain: 79,872,000,000
3) France: 74,690,470,000 (including the police force)
4) China: 59,000,000,000
5) Japan: 48,860,000,000
6) Germany: 45,930,000,000
7) Russia: 41,050,000,000
8 ) Italy: 40,060,000,000
9) Saudi Arabia: 31,050,000,000
10) South Korea: 28,940,000,000
telegraph.co.uk
