Reciprocal living and working rights backed in UK, Australia, NZ and Canada

Praxius

Mass'Debater
Dec 18, 2007
10,609
99
48
Halifax, NS & Melbourne, VIC
Reciprocal living and working rights backed in UK, Australia, NZ and Canada | World news | The Guardian

A new poll has found “overwhelming support” within Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the United Kingdom for granting nationals reciprocal rights to live and work freely in each other’s countries, as new immigration policies shortly to take effect in the UK have the opposite effect.

The Royal Commonwealth Society’s survey showed that most people are in support of removing barriers to live and work in the four countries, with support among New Zealanders as high as 82%. Some 75% of Canadians, 70% of Australians and 58% of Britons are also in favour.

Support has skyrocketed among young adults aged between 18 and 35, with 90% of New Zealanders and 80% of Australians in favour.

Tim Hewish, author of the report and director of policy and research at the Royal Commonwealth Society, said there was clearly “immense support” from Australians, Canadians and New Zealanders for the freedom to live and work in the UK.

“Collectively we possess a unique bond which needs protecting. We share a language, a legal system, and a Queen.”

Lord Howell of Guildford, the president of the Royal Commonwealth Society, said governments must work “to ensure as much free mobility as is workable”.


“This polling is invaluable as it shows the views and wishes of these fellow Commonwealth friends in strong support of closer ties. Governments must find ways to build them and to remove the obstacles that stand in their way.”

The poll is the latest in a series sparked by the call made by London mayor Boris Johnson on his visit to Australia in 2013 for a “free labour mobility zone” between the two countries.

But since then the number of Commonwealth nationals working in the UK has fallen significantly due to a crackdown on migration from outside the European Union, with a new tranche of immigration policies about to take effect.

From 6 April, all skilled workers from outside the EU who have been in the UK for less than 10 years will need to earn at least £35,000 a year in order to qualify for a Tier 2 visa and settle there permanently.

Australians and New Zealanders in the UK for six months or more will also be required to pay an annual surcharge of £200 (A$380 and NZ$426) to access some health services.

Australians and New Zealanders were previously exempt from the Immigration Health Surcharge, but Britain’s immigration minister, James Brokenshire, said in a statement in February it was “only fair” that they contribute to the National Health Service.

Migration specialists have reported a spike in the number of Australians based in Britain now looking to return home, though the changes have been publicised since 2011.

The governments of both Australia and New Zealand have criticised the changes. New Zealand’s prime minister, John Key, said extending the NHS surcharge to New Zealanders in the UK was “pretty cheap and not really in keeping with the history of the two countries”.

A Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade report obtained by News Corp in Australia warned that the “discriminatory” changes would make the UK “a less welcoming destination” and potentially put formal relations between the two countries at risk.

The Royal Commonwealth Society survey bolstered a November 2015 survey of 1,687 Britons with polling of 1,000 people in both New Zealand and Canada and 1,247 Australians in late January 2016.

Questions asked of Australians and New Zealanders took into account the free labour mobility already afforded between those two countries by the Trans-Tasman Travel Arrangement.

An additional question found that more Britons favoured free mobility with Canada, Australia and New Zealand than with countries in the European Union.



I say go for it. I of course wouldn't have any interest in working in the UK (wait, does Ireland Count?) but my family and I could see it making things easier to go back and forth between Australia and Canada, especially regarding family back in Canada. We could stay longer than a few weeks, get part time jobs and visit family for longer, then go back to Australia. Or move back to Canada, get full time jobs then visit Australia for a couple of months doing the same thing.
 
Last edited:

tay

Hall of Fame Member
May 20, 2012
11,548
0
36
As someone who just got back from Ozland I'm not sure how this would make it 'easier' to go back and forth as it isn't difficult. Working there legally may be another issue, but I'm not interested in working.

I notice that it is most favourable amongst 18-35 year olds. Oh to be young and naive again.
 

MHz

Time Out
Mar 16, 2007
41,030
43
48
Red Deer AB
I mow the grass in the ditches of the highway, can I get that same job in the Australian outback?

Long as y'all stay the heck out of the U.S., I'm OK with whatever y'all do.
Memo, we didn't get left out, you did. Your post is a good example of why that happened.
 

Blackleaf

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 9, 2004
48,429
1,668
113
Do we really want Britain's best being able to freely emigrate.....?

Well it seems as though you do, because in 2008 your Minister of Employment Hector Goudreau started a campaign to attract Britons to Canada to boost the economy and the country's sparse population.

However, many Britons who move to Canada eventually find out that life there is not for them and they end up returning to Britain. They discover that the quality of life there isn't quite as good as UN "studies" keep telling us and that quality of life is actually probably higher in Britain; they don't like the Canadian people (apparently, according to the comments on the link below, Brits often find Canadians to be "smug" and the social interaction amongst Canadians isn't as good as it is in Britain and America, apparently); they don't like Canada's dark, freezing, long winters; they don't like crime in Canada's big cities (violent crime and murder is significantly higher in Canada than in Britain); they don't like the cost of living, which they discover to be higher in many places in Canada than in Britain; and then there's the health service, which isn't as good in Canada as it is in Britain, with Britain's free NHS often found to be the best health service in the world.

Go here to look at the comments from Brits who have moved to Canada: Canada wants British workers to emigrate - Telegraph

Alan • 7 years ago

We left Canada in 1990 after 15 years as we eventually realised it was no longer for us. Why? Well in a nutshell it came down to our "quality of life" being more important than "standard of living" which most Canadians confuse as the same thing. We had all the material goods: lovely home, car cheap petrol etc etc but despite immersing ourselves in Canada we found the social interaction of most Canadians to be very poor compared to the UK , USA and other countries we have lived in. Our life in the UK is so much richer in term of friendship and social life, We still enjoy a good standard of living but now have much more holiday time to relax and enjoy our family. Incidentally, On a recent visit back to Canada we did a personal price check on supermarkets, pharmacies, restaurants and car dealers etc and where quite suprised to find most prices the same if not more expensive than the UK. In fact our European model car was around $2000 more there! And wages, in my profession at least, are lower than the UK and start with only two weeks vacation per year for the first 5 years! We still have Canadian citizenship but nothing would make us give up on the UK despite all it's problems. As a final note: our British born friends in Canada almost all moaned about the same political issues as the UK and commented that they would head back to the UK tomorrow if there kids where not grown up and settled there.


j jones • 7 years ago

I returned to Canada two years ago after an absence of 30 years, living in the UK, USA and other places around the world because of work. I retired, on a generous pension, I purchased a home in Niagara on the Lake and thought all was well. An illusion. Despite my trying my best to convince myself and family that Canada was the place to live, we really couldnt leave to return to the UK soon enough. No work for the family, expensive, terrible weather, Canadian smugness, the list is endless. I would guess all the UK, German, Italian etc. people we met would go back if they could possibly afford to do so. Even Canadians constantly asked what made us move to Canada. I wouldnt recommend the move to anyone.
 

MHz

Time Out
Mar 16, 2007
41,030
43
48
Red Deer AB
How cool depends if can also be called a hiway. Mexico straight to Canada (and back) Phase I of 'the Wall'

Walls only suck if there are too few gates.
 

Bar Sinister

Executive Branch Member
Jan 17, 2010
8,252
19
38
Edmonton
Where do these polls come from? I am not aware of any. However, if I was asked I would have no objection to a free flow of people between the three countries.