Why is the CBC refusing to hand over info to CRA about potential CDN tax cheats?

Locutus

Adorable Deplorable
Jun 18, 2007
32,230
45
48
65
can't understand why.


The Conservative Party’s national revenue critic is calling on the CBC to hand over its Panama Papers data to Canada’s tax agency, something the Crown corporation is refusing to do.

Ziad Aboultaif (Edmonton Manning, Alta.) says information coming out of a mammoth leak of documents detailing a global transfer of wealth into offshore accounts is fair game for the Canada Revenue Agency to demand.

“If someone says, especially the media, ‘I have something,’…I think they have to back it up,” Mr. Aboultaif told The Hill Times in an interview.

“Maybe they have information the CRA doesn’t have, and the CRA is asking for details, and I think they have the right to do so.”

The tax agency has formally asked the CBC to hand over the information, the broadcaster reported April 11, but the CBC is refusing, saying it does not reveal its sources and pointing to a similar request in 2013 that it also rejected.

Mr. Aboultaif said press freedom can’t always trump the public interest. “[If] it has to do with the public, public issues…I think they need to back it up,” he said.

There are 350 Canadians in the database leak, CBC has said, citing an unspecified report. News articles indicate that the information in the leak comes from Panamanian law firm Mossack Fonseca. The Hill Times has not seen the documents and cannot independently verify the information.

The International Consortium of Investigative Journalists is working with two Canadian news outlets, the CBC and the Toronto Star, as well as others around the world to process the cache of records into news stories.

The consortium has already rebuffed requests to release the data en masse, stating that while the Panama Papers reveal questionable activity by politicians, banks and celebrities, “other parts of the data are of a private nature and of no interest to the public.”

mo


Tory critic wants a reluctant CBC to hand over Panama Papers |
 

tay

Hall of Fame Member
May 20, 2012
11,548
0
36
They aren't tax cheats. What they are doing is legal and allowed by CRA and the tax laws the governments allow to happen.

http://tvo.org/programs/the-great-canadian-tax-dodge


The following Toronto Star story has 'tax dodgers' in the headline. That leads one to feel that what these people/corporations are doing is illegal but it isn't; unfair to all of us losers who pay all our taxes, but it is still legal for them....

Crackdown on Canada’s tax dodgers should include naming and shaming: Editorial | Toronto Star
 

MHz

Time Out
Mar 16, 2007
41,030
43
48
Red Deer AB
So it looks like they aren't giving the names of just the people they don't like.
Let's say the tax rate for somebody with $100k income is 30%, when a person has an income of $1M, $10M. $100M $1B per year the rate should rise above the 30 % mark rather than drop down below what the 'poor pay'. The rich pay more taxes but they still have a lot more money to play with in a year than the lowest earners, to the point they could not spend all they make in a single year. That is another method of taking money out of the pockets of the 'poor'.
 
Last edited:

MHz

Time Out
Mar 16, 2007
41,030
43
48
Red Deer AB
No Mulroney, your investigation is already flawed. He should be front and center and the punishment should be of the kind that the other crooks are scrambling to make a deal.
 

tay

Hall of Fame Member
May 20, 2012
11,548
0
36
Tory critic wants a reluctant CBC to hand over Panama Papers |

Names incl in these papers possibly include;

Martin
Desmarie
Chretin
The Trudeau Trust Foundation?

Martin and Desmarie for sure...

The Great Canadian Tax Dodge | TVo_Org


Senior enforcement officials from the CRA were treated to private receptions at an exclusive Ottawa club, hosted by a small group of influential tax accountants that included personnel from KPMG — even as the firm was facing a CRA probe for running a $130-million tax dodge in the Isle of Man.

At the same time Canada's tax agency was in confidential talks with KPMG over its refusal to hand over the names of its multimillionaire clients who used the offshore scheme.

The CRA wouldn't confirm who attended the events, and none of the known industry or government attendees contacted by CBC News would talk about them. The Rideau Club operates under a code known as the "Chatham House Rules": to encourage open discussion, you can't reveal what others say at meetings.

The Rideau Club gatherings were not the only industry-funded events attended by government tax officials

CBC News has documented more than 50 hospitality events, including "tailgate parties," "cocktails" and "food and drinks" at numerous tax industry conferences since 2010. The events were attended by CRA executives and employees, and sponsored and paid for by tax industry associations and accounting and law firms across the country — the very firms the agency is responsible for regulating, auditing and, on occasion, penalizing. Most of the receptions took place during conferences attended by personnel from the private tax industry and government.

Robin Benger, an independent documentary producer who directed The Great Canadian Tax Dodge for TVOntario, investigated the tax industry for more than three years and attended a 2013 Canadian Tax Foundation conference. After listening to speeches by both government and industry tax officials, he said, he vividly recalls the Osler reception at the Royal Conservatory of Music in Toronto.

"CRA top people" attended the party, he said. "They were being plied with drinks and getting on roaringly with all the tax lawyers and accountants."

Benger says he was "stunned" by the relationship he observed between the tax law companies, the accountants and the CRA. He argues the "rule makers" were too close to "rule twisters."

CRA execs treated to soirees at private club amid KPMG probe - Canada - CBC News
 

IdRatherBeSkiing

Satelitte Radio Addict
May 28, 2007
14,608
2,359
113
Toronto, ON
I am sure the CBC has reported ALL the names on the list .... not just the ones who are conservatives or business people.

But given this is legal, why is it a big deal to withhold the list?
 

tay

Hall of Fame Member
May 20, 2012
11,548
0
36
I am sure the CBC has reported ALL the names on the list .... not just the ones who are conservatives or business people.

But given this is legal, why is it a big deal to withhold the list?

Embarrassment?

Shouldn't our Conservative friend be quizzing the CRA for the names instead of the CBC? the CRA is a direct Govt agency What is the CRA hiding? Okay we already have a rough idea as to what they are hiding.

Seems like a lot of murkiness between the CRA and KPMG.

As for the CBC not wanting to release the info we need only look at who calls the shots there in the Board room....

Nine of the eleven current members of the CBC Board of Directors - were appointed by Prime Minister Harper




 

mentalfloss

Prickly Curmudgeon Smiter
Jun 28, 2010
39,778
454
83
Embarrassment?

Shouldn't our Conservative friend be quizzing the CRA for the names instead of the CBC? the CRA is a direct Govt agency What is the CRA hiding? Okay we already have a rough idea as to what they are hiding.

Seems like a lot of murkiness between the CRA and KPMG.

As for the CBC not wanting to release the info we need only look at who calls the shots there in the Board room....

Nine of the eleven current members of the CBC Board of Directors - were appointed by Prime Minister Harper





Shocking.

I am shocked.
 

taxslave

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 25, 2008
36,362
4,337
113
Vancouver Island
They aren't tax cheats. What they are doing is legal and allowed by CRA and the tax laws the governments allow to happen.

http://tvo.org/programs/the-great-canadian-tax-dodge


The following Toronto Star story has 'tax dodgers' in the headline. That leads one to feel that what these people/corporations are doing is illegal but it isn't; unfair to all of us losers who pay all our taxes, but it is still legal for them....

Crackdown on Canada’s tax dodgers should include naming and shaming: Editorial | Toronto Star
Meaning it is a non story. Typical of the CBC.
 

mentalfloss

Prickly Curmudgeon Smiter
Jun 28, 2010
39,778
454
83
Where have to been during all of this?

The whole discussion has been around the fact that it is currently legal but completely unethical.
 

mentalfloss

Prickly Curmudgeon Smiter
Jun 28, 2010
39,778
454
83
I usually believe in our legal system but even I'm not drinking this koolaid.

Also you do realize that laws don't change overnight right?

That's why it begins with these kinds of discussions.
 

TenPenny

Hall of Fame Member
Jun 9, 2004
17,466
138
63
Location, Location
Now that we know the top people at CRA in charge of investigation and enforcement were being wined and dined by KPMG, why bother to turn over anything anyway?


They're all in a little club to steal from the middle class.