Tax Loopholes For Rich Cost Canada $16 Billion A Year: Study

mentalfloss

Prickly Curmudgeon Smiter
Jun 28, 2010
39,778
454
83
Well there you have it, taxprayers.


Tax Loopholes For Rich Cost Canada $16 Billion A Year: Study

Closing five tax loopholes that mostly benefit the wealthy would raise nearly $16 billion annually for Canada’s federal and provincial governments, according to a study from a prominent economist.

Toby Sanger says these tax loopholes — which have grown more generous since the late 1990s — have increased inequality and led to greater financial instability.

The loopholes have “actually slowed down economic growth,” Sanger told HuffPost Canada, because rising inequality depresses consumer demand.

Sanger is an economist with the Canadian Union of Public Employees, and sits on the board of Canadians for Tax Fairness. He says the research is “especially pertinent ... given the new Liberal government’s commitment to review and eliminate regressive tax loopholes in their election platform.”

The federal Liberal government will release its first budget March 22. Finance Minister Bill Morneau predicted this week that Canada’s deficit for next fiscal year will be $18.4 billion. That’s five times as large as the previous estimate made just three months ago.

The largest tax loophole — costing the feds upwards of $12 billion a year — is the fact that capital gains (profits from investments) are only partially included in income taxes. This means investment gains are taxed at half the rate as wage income, Sanger says.

Sanger estimates 90 per cent of the benefits of this loophole accrue to the top 10 per cent of earners.

Using calculations from earlier research, the study found the use of tax havens costs Canada about $2 billion annually; stock option deductions cost some $800 million a year; and corporate meal and entertainment deductions cost $460 million.

Sanger’s study estimates misuse of the small-business tax credit costs the feds $500 million annually.

The small-business tax credit is “widely abused by higher income professionals including doctors, dentists and small business owners,” Sanger asserted. Individuals who incorporate themselves pay an 11-per-cent tax rate, compared to a personal income tax rate of up to 33 per cent.

Tax Loopholes For Rich Cost Canada $16 Billion A Year: Study
 

damngrumpy

Executive Branch Member
Mar 16, 2005
9,949
21
38
kelowna bc
It is time to close every avenue of games the wealthy play
In addition its time to cut off the oil industry special tax
breaks that are really subsidies and in the east Bombardier
It is time everyone paid their fair share.
Is 16 billion a big deal? Yes because people on this board
howl about fairness and yet some will defend the wealthy
getting a free ride when everyone else pays.
 

gerryh

Time Out
Nov 21, 2004
25,756
295
83
It is time to close every avenue of games the wealthy play
In addition its time to cut off the oil industry special tax
breaks that are really subsidies and in the east Bombardier
It is time everyone paid their fair share.
Is 16 billion a big deal? Yes because people on this board
howl about fairness and yet some will defend the wealthy
getting a free ride when everyone else pays.


I assume that you would also be willing to have the Okanogan apple growers forgo the subsidies and grants, etc that they get?
 

pgs

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 29, 2008
26,653
6,993
113
B.C.
It is time to close every avenue of games the wealthy play
In addition its time to cut off the oil industry special tax
breaks that are really subsidies and in the east Bombardier
It is time everyone paid their fair share.
Is 16 billion a big deal? Yes because people on this board
howl about fairness and yet some will defend the wealthy
getting a free ride when everyone else pays.
What kind of tax breaks do you get running your orchard and all ?
 

Angstrom

Hall of Fame Member
May 8, 2011
10,659
0
36
I assume that you would also be willing to have the Okanogan apple growers forgo the subsidies and grants, etc that they get?

But he pays his fair share. The millions of jobs produced by oil doesn't count.
 

bobnoorduyn

Council Member
Nov 26, 2008
2,262
28
48
Mountain Veiw County
The largest tax loophole — costing the feds upwards of $12 billion a year — is the fact that capital gains (profits from investments) are only partially included in income taxes. This means investment gains are taxed at half the rate as wage income, Sanger says.

Sanger estimates 90 per cent of the benefits of this loophole accrue to the top 10 per cent of earners.

Ah yes, the lefties most widely maligned and misunderstood of all "loopholes". This tax is most unfair to those who pay it. Sure it taxes gains at 50% at the taxpayer's marginal rate, but who made the investment and took the risk in the first place? The lefties want all the gains at no risk. It is structured so that if that same taxpayer incurs a loss, the government suffers no loss at all. Capital losses can only be used to mitigate a capital gain. It is all win for the government. Want to see investment dry up, taxing 100% of gains will do it in a flash.
 

taxslave

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 25, 2008
36,362
4,337
113
Vancouver Island
Well there you have it, taxprayers.


Tax Loopholes For Rich Cost Canada $16 Billion A Year: Study

Closing five tax loopholes that mostly benefit the wealthy would raise nearly $16 billion annually for Canada’s federal and provincial governments, according to a study from a prominent economist.

Toby Sanger says these tax loopholes — which have grown more generous since the late 1990s — have increased inequality and led to greater financial instability.

The loopholes have “actually slowed down economic growth,” Sanger told HuffPost Canada, because rising inequality depresses consumer demand.

Sanger is an economist with the Canadian Union of Public Employees, and sits on the board of Canadians for Tax Fairness. He says the research is “especially pertinent ... given the new Liberal government’s commitment to review and eliminate regressive tax loopholes in their election platform.”

The federal Liberal government will release its first budget March 22. Finance Minister Bill Morneau predicted this week that Canada’s deficit for next fiscal year will be $18.4 billion. That’s five times as large as the previous estimate made just three months ago.

The largest tax loophole — costing the feds upwards of $12 billion a year — is the fact that capital gains (profits from investments) are only partially included in income taxes. This means investment gains are taxed at half the rate as wage income, Sanger says.

Sanger estimates 90 per cent of the benefits of this loophole accrue to the top 10 per cent of earners.

Using calculations from earlier research, the study found the use of tax havens costs Canada about $2 billion annually; stock option deductions cost some $800 million a year; and corporate meal and entertainment deductions cost $460 million.

Sanger’s study estimates misuse of the small-business tax credit costs the feds $500 million annually.

The small-business tax credit is “widely abused by higher income professionals including doctors, dentists and small business owners,” Sanger asserted. Individuals who incorporate themselves pay an 11-per-cent tax rate, compared to a personal income tax rate of up to 33 per cent.

Tax Loopholes For Rich Cost Canada $16 Billion A Year: Study

Do you really think a clod that works for the government union is an unbiased source of information?
 

mentalfloss

Prickly Curmudgeon Smiter
Jun 28, 2010
39,778
454
83
Government is less biased than private corporations, no doubt.

Self-employed and small business owners are the most fraudulent people that exist today.
 

gopher

Hall of Fame Member
Jun 26, 2005
21,513
65
48
Minnesota: Gopher State
I agree in principle with the thesis of the writing. However, the $16 billion figure appears to be rather small, considering the size of Canada's population and economy.
 

petros

The Central Scrutinizer
Nov 21, 2008
109,389
11,445
113
Low Earth Orbit
Government is less biased than private corporations, no doubt.

Self-employed and small business owners are the most fraudulent people that exist today.

And you are living proof.

The largest tax loophole — costing the feds upwards of $12 billion a year — is the fact that capital gains (profits from investments) are only partially included in income taxes. This means investment gains are taxed at half the rate as wage income, Sanger says
Isn't this what everyone is banking on? Sell their house, downscale, put the remaining into a fund with monthly payments to avoid capital gains?