Next GG to "reflect the diversity of Canada"

FiveParadox

Governor General
Dec 20, 2005
5,875
43
48
Vancouver, BC
As 2017 approaches, discussions have already started as to the appointment of Canada's next governor general. The Right Hon. Justin Trudeau, P.C., M.P., seems to have started the public conversation early, commenting today that "[he] will take into account the nature of Canada and the desire of Canadians to see institutions and appointments across the government that reflect the diversity of Canada." He made the announcement at an event in Toronto, Ontario.

Appointing a Governor General

Her Majesty the Queen is Canada's head of state; of course, as the Queen is head of state for no less than sixteen Commonwealth realms, Her Majesty is represented in most of those countries by a governor general, to perform the functions of the head of state. In Canada, the governor general is appointed by the Queen, on the advice of the prime minister.

The governor general serves at the pleasure of the Queen. They usually serve for about five years, but they have sometimes served longer. The current governor general, His Excellency the Right Hon. David Johnston, C.C., C.M.M., C.O.M., C.D., had his term extended for an additional two years, as there was a risk of no party having a majority of seats in the House. (Prime ministers tend to seek experienced governors general during potentially unstable parliaments, so as to ensure that they have enough expertise to navigate uncharted constitutional waters.)

What does the Governor General do?

The governor general represents the Queen here in Canada. They are responsible for five core areas: the constitutional role of representing and exercising the powers of the head of state; acting as the commander-in-chief of the Canadian Forces; representing Canada and Canadians at home and abroad; encouraging and recognizing excellence; and bringing Canadians together through non-partisan causes, dialogue, and community-building activities.

Constitutional powers of the head of state


His Excellency reads the speech from the throne to open the 42nd Parliament.

While the governor general is not the head of state (that role remains that of the Queen), most of the Queen's powers are exercisable in Canada by the governor general. They must ensure that Canada always has a government that enjoys the confidence of the elected House of Commons. Usually, this task is straightforward; during a majority government, the political leader who has the most seats in the Lower House gets to be the prime minister. However, things are not always clear-cut.

When no party has a majority of seats, the governor general can be called upon to act as a constitutional referee. This is why governors general frequently see their terms extended if it appears that an election might not be conclusive; a seasoned governor general might be better able to navigate a political crisis, in terms of the selection of a prime minister.

The day-to-day constitutional duties of the governor general, representing the Queen, are:

  • to summon, prorogue, and dissolve parliaments;
  • to appoint justices, senators, and other key federal officials;
  • to approve orders-in-council (i.e., executive orders) requested by cabinet; and
  • to grant royal assent to bills, once passed by both the Senate and Commons.

Almost invariably, these powers are exercised on the advice of the prime minister and cabinet, who are responsible to the elected House. The governor general does have the right to advise, encourage, and warn the prime minister; they also have some reserve powers, which can be exercised during a constitutional crisis to ensure that Canadians continue to have a prime minister and a government who enjoy the confidence of our elected representatives.

Commander-in-chief of the Canadian Forces


His Excellency visits the Canadian Forces deployed abroad for Christmas.

The governor general, by letters patent, is authorized by the Queen to act as the commander-in-chief in and over Canada. As the commander-in-chief, the governor general plays a leading role in ensuring that Canadians recognize the importance of Canada's armed forces, and in recognizing and honouring excellence and bravery among our service-people.

On the advice of the prime minister, the governor general appoints the chief of the defence staff. They also appoint royal colonels of Canadian regiments, on the advice of the minister of national defence. The governor general is responsible for issuing Canada's highest military honours, including the Order of Military Merit, Meritorious Service decorations, Military Valour decorations, and Peacekeeping and Special Service medals. New insignia and badges require their approval.

The governor general regularly visits members of the Canadian Forces, and their families and loved ones, at home and abroad. They also present new colours to units, and sign commission scrolls. The governor general also serves as a colonel of the Governor General's Foot Guards, the Governor General's Horse Guards, and the Canadian Grenadier Guards.

Representing Canada and Canadians

The governor general promotes Canadian sovereignty, and represents Canada and Canadians abroad. Typically at the request of the government, the governor general receives and hosts visiting heads of state; they conduct state visits abroad, to strengthen diplomatic ties between Canada and other countries; they receive ambassadors and high commissioners; and they sign diplomatic documents.

An ambassador (or a high commissioner from a country where the Queen is not also head of state) cannot start working in Canada until they have been welcomed to Canada by the governor general, and presented to the governor general their letters of credence (i.e., the official accreditation by a foreign head of state to act as their representative here in Canada). The governor general also signs the papers of Canadian ambassadors and high commissioners, before they leave Canada to start their work abroad. There are over 130 heads of mission active in Canada.

Recognition of excellence


His Excellency presides over an investiture ceremony for the Order of Canada.

The Queen is the head of the Canadian honours system, and the governor general has a number of responsibilities as Her Majesty's representative in this respect. The purpose of the Canadian honours system is to pay special tribute to those who have shown excellence, dedication, or courage, in a way that impacts the very fabric of Canadian society.

The governor general is the chancellor and principal companion of the Order of Canada, our highest national honour. The governor general also oversees the Governor General's Caring Canadian Award, Decorations for Bravery, and myriad other national honours to recognize those who have gone above and beyond in the service of Canada and Canadians.

Bringing Canadians together

The governor general, as a non-political Canadian leader, has the duty of bringing Canadians together around non-partisan causes. The governor general encourages Canadians to build a caring and compassionate society, and they promote Canadian values, diversity, inclusiveness, culture, and heritage. The governor general undertakes numerous activities throughout the year to meet with Canadians and to advance these principles.

His Excellency the Right Hon. David Johnston, our current governor general, made 2015 the year of sport, through royal proclamation. His Excellency has also made the promotion and encouragement of volunteerism a key theme throughout his mandate. Other governors general have also selected special causes on which to focus their energies. His Excellency's predecessor, the Right Hon. Michaëlle Jean, P.C., C.C., C.M.M., C.O.M., C.D., focused on breaking down solitudes.

Sources:
 

Johnnny

Frontiersman
Jun 8, 2007
9,388
124
63
Third rock from the Sun
How can anyone person reflect the diversity of an entire nation where there are 100+ ethnic groups....

And if one person can.... Then holy **** we found the master race...

So what is wrong with our current GG? Is he just too white?


What did Michelle Jean represent? Did she represent diversity?
 
Last edited:

Johnnny

Frontiersman
Jun 8, 2007
9,388
124
63
Third rock from the Sun
That's right. How can they possibly represent all of Canada? ... even if they make up the majority of Canadians?

Exactly....

Would Trudeau deem it necessary to make the same statement if Michelle Jean was the current GG?

-no-

Why don't we have a Governor General that "Represents Canada"???? And for that anyone would do... Or how about just appointing someone GG without all the bravado????? Oh wait...... Never mind.... :lol:
 

Curious Cdn

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 22, 2015
37,070
6
36
Exactly....

Would Trudeau deem it necessary to make the same statement if Michelle Jean was the current GG?

-no-

It is actually rascist, what he is saying. Not so sunny days. Then again, it's fashionable to crap on white people because of some things that some (and only a fraction) of their ancestors did hundreds of years ago.

Build some camps, Justin and put Hedy Fry in charge of them. She'll find a solution for all of those naturally racist white people.
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
547
113
Vernon, B.C.
How can anyone person reflect the diversity of an entire nation where there are 100+ ethnic groups....

And if one person can.... Then holy **** we found the master race...

So what is wrong with our current GG? Is he just too white?


What did Michelle Jean represent? Did she represent diversity?


I can't see a single thing wrong with David Johnston and I have no criticism of Michelle Jean either- both have a lot of class! No one can be all things to all people- there's no such thing as too white or too black or too orange!
 

FiveParadox

Governor General
Dec 20, 2005
5,875
43
48
Vancouver, BC
So what is wrong with our current GG? Is he just too white?
I think that His Excellency the Governor General is performing splendidly.

And, it would appear that the prime minister agrees. Mr. Trudeau, in his statement yesterday, also applauded His Excellency the Governor General for the work that he has done over his mandate so far. Trudeau stated that "[he's] doing an exceptional job and [he's] proud to have him as our Governor General." However, his term is drawing to a close.

Governors general serve at the pleasure of the Queen, but the typical term is about five years. His Excellency agreed to an extension of his term, at the request of the Right Hon. Stephen Harper, P.C., M.P. (Calgary Heritage), then the prime minister, in order to reduce the risk that the country could see an unstable House after the general elections. Fortunately, the election resulted in a majority, and the risk that the Governor General might need to play constitutional referee was averted.

That being said, I think it is useful, appropriate, and another sign of the open and transparent attitude of this government, that the prime minister has already made a statement about the criteria that he intends to apply when seeking out the next representative of Her Majesty the Queen.

What did Michelle Jean represent? Did she represent diversity?
Mme. Jean was the first Black person, and the first Black woman, no less, to serve as the Queen's representative in Canada. She is a francophone; she came to Canada as a refugee; she fluently speaks French, English, Spanish, Italian, and Haitian Creole. Mme. Jean also believed that her appointment was a genuine and authentic expression of Canadian diversity, responding to a question about tokenism by saying: "I have never been a token, sir. And will never be."

Upon her appointment, of course, Mme. Jean represented Canada and Canadians; she represented Canadian values, diversity, inclusiveness, and heritage. As governor general, she worked to bring Canadians closer together, and to put a renewed focus on dialogue as a way to break down barriers between communities. Her theme of "breaking down solitudes" was a poignant and non-partisan reminder that there is still much work to be done in uniting Canadians.

Why don't we have a Governor General that "Represents Canada"???? And for that anyone would do... Or how about just appointing someone GG without all the bravado????? Oh wait...... Never mind.... :lol:
We do have a governor general that "represents Canada." That is one of the main parts of the job. Current and past governors general have represented Canada at home; promoting Canadian sovereignty, representing the Queen, and ensuring that Canadians can always rest assured that they have a prime minister and a government that enjoy the support of our elected representatives.

Our governors general also represent Canada abroad, working to strengthen diplomatic international ties between Canada and other countries, and sharing Canadian goodwill and friendship with foreign heads of state and heads of mission. The constant bleating from Conservatives that diversity is necessarily in diametric opposition to merit-based appointments is nothing more than a manifestation of deeply internalized misogyny and racism.
 

FiveParadox

Governor General
Dec 20, 2005
5,875
43
48
Vancouver, BC
So then if we already have all that then why change the theme? We don't need to change the theme our governor generals have been representing Canada

Who's changing the theme? Mr. Trudeau is just stating expressly what one of the criteria are as he starts looking to the appointment of the Queen's next Canadian federal representative. This express statement is, in my opinion, a valuable "codification" of the hard work that was started some time ago to elevate the role of the governor general above the patronage-based politics of the day.

The first appointment that was completely removed from patronage-based decision-making was the Right Hon. Adrienne Clarkson, P.C., C.C., C.M.M., C.O.M., C.D., and we saw that continue with the appointments of Mme. Jean, and then with His Excellency (to Mr. Harper's credit). Continuing this shift is a positive thing that we should be celebrating.

Too bad the Conservatives are more concerned about whether "the White people" are getting what they feel is due to them — such as automatic pre-eminence in searches for the governor general. Because a diverse appointment must be an unmerited one, right? (sarcasm causes brain to explode)
 

darkbeaver

the universe is electric
Jan 26, 2006
41,035
201
63
RR1 Distopia 666 Discordia
Canada is not a sovereign nation its officially still and only a united colony and the Monarch of Great Britian is acting as the agent for the corporate administrateive body of the "City of London", a city/state within England owned by the administrative corporation of the Vatican city/state The Holy Roman Empire, since King John 1213 and ever after.
 

Johnnny

Frontiersman
Jun 8, 2007
9,388
124
63
Third rock from the Sun
I see it as an unnecessary statement meant to garner votes. Politicians.

BTW just because I'm white doesn't make me a conservative. I'm far from butt hurt about the changing demographics, I got peepz

Michelle did represent Canada and a changing Canada. It's an unnecessary criteria to point out because the position has already gone to a nonwhite before and will go to another nonwhite even without the bravado.
 

Jinentonix

Hall of Fame Member
Sep 6, 2015
10,607
5,250
113
Olympus Mons
So uh, how exactly does a single person represent the diversity of Canada? What's Trudeau going to do, search for a Muslim that's part Indian and part Native who is a left-handed, transgendered female?
 

Curious Cdn

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 22, 2015
37,070
6
36
So uh, how exactly does a single person represent the diversity of Canada? What's Trudeau going to do, search for a Muslim that's part Indian and part Native who is a left-handed, transgendered female?

They'll have to volunteer to have a limb amutated, too so that they can squeeze in "disability" and therefore make the GG that much more inclusive.
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
547
113
Vernon, B.C.
How can anyone person reflect the diversity of an entire nation where there are 100+ ethnic groups....

And if one person can.... Then holy **** we found the master race...

So what is wrong with our current GG? Is he just too white?


What did Michelle Jean represent? Did she represent diversity?


You hit the nail on the head. No one can be all things to all people!:) David Johnston is as good as it gets.
 

FiveParadox

Governor General
Dec 20, 2005
5,875
43
48
Vancouver, BC
You hit the nail on the head. No one can be all things to all people!:) David Johnston is as good as it gets.

The point is that appointments to the office of the governor general should reflect the country's diversity. The fact that this is even a topic of public debate, with people questioning whether any substantial effort should go into ensuring a selection process that respects the diverse make-up of our country, is a signal that there is still work to be done to dismantle societal and systemic racism.

Yes, His Excellency is doing a fantastic job as Governor General; and yes, he had predecessors who perhaps more visibly reflected the country's ethnic diversity. That does not mean that the work is done; these more progressive appointments could go down in the history books as an anomaly if concerted work is not done to continue the trend.
 

Curious Cdn

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 22, 2015
37,070
6
36
You hit the nail on the head. No one can be all things to all people!:) David Johnston is as good as it gets.

Right on. Johnson is as good as it gets and not because because his is white.

James Bartleman (former Ontario Lt. Governor) was also as good as it gets and he is Ojibwa. Was he chosen to be "inclusive" or to honour his competence? I prefer the latter attitude.