Ezra Levant @ezralevant
Fair criticisms here. But I do like our ease of impeaching our PMs, and I prefer our Queen to their Emperor. #cdnpoli http://www.politibrew.com/politics/200-o-s-extra-constitutional-reign-a-canam-view …
O's Extra-constitutional Reign: A CanAm View
Sun News' Ezra Levant interviews a DC law Professor from George Mason University School of Law, Frank Buckley. Although Buckley is Canadian, he lives and teaches in the DC area. He makes some interesting observations about the American Presidency fast becoming a "crown" government. Boy...haven't we all been saying that...although you would probably agree that it is more like an out and out dictatorship.
Buckley briefly compares the Canadian and US constitutional systems in this segment. He claims that the Canadian constitution is superior. He must be friends with Associate Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg...I wonder if he's been slated for an interview with Nile TV in Cairo. I think he is full of well...you know. But I digress.
Canada's Charter of Rights and Freedoms is a tortured and contorted lumbering mess of competing rights claims in comparison to the US Bill of Rights. Canada's British based parliamentary system of governance is fairly laudable, with divisions of powers. But it has a reverse Tenth Amendment...that is...all powers not designated to the Provinces go to the "general" government, i.e. the federal government; surely a magnet for abuse.
And built into the Canadian Constitution of 1982 is a "transfer" system...in other words, we have a redistribution of wealth system that takes money from the "have" provinces and gives it to the "have not" provinces; an abusive entitlement system for provincial leaders if ever one could be devised. And there are a few lazy provincial leaders unwilling to exploit their own natural resources to become energy independent...Quebec and Nova Scotia come to mind. Quebec always sucks at the teat of the Feds and what we call "The Rest of Canada". Those dirty oil Albertans can pay for lazy Quebec Marxist radicals by giving them cheaper University subsidized by oil through the transfer system.
However...Buckley does make a good point: Canada's parliamentary system can jettison a Prime Minister or his government almost on notice through a thing called a "non-confidence" motion. Non-confidence motions occur mostly with a minority government like what occurred just yesterday in Ontario. Ontario's minority New Democratic Party, holding a balance of power with the Progressive Conservatives, declared no confidence in the Liberal government's budget. Non-confidence usually occurs on budget motions. Ontario goes to the polls in about six weeks.
In another way also, Canada's constitutional system takes a burden off of the executive; Canada does not have a magisterial Prime Minister, but a Queen and a Governor General to fulfill that roll. In America...that roll is unfortunately fulfilled by a President who goes to Hollywood parties...or has the Hollywood parties come to him.
So there are some interesting points here in the clip. It is certain that Ezra Levant does not believe the BS about a superior Canadian constitutional system...but he's good to his guests and he picks his fights. Many times he has extolled the betterness of the US system...but unfortunately a constitution is only as good as it's people...something John Adams warned against.
video at link:
O's Extra-constitutional Reign: A CanAm View